Theme | Newsbeat | War of the Worlds |
Regulation | – Ofcom regulates BBC therefore regulates Newsbeat. Government gives regulative guidelines to Ofcom. – The Royal Charter is the constitutional basis for the BBC. It sets out the BBC’s objective (BBC Charter). | – Regulated by the Federal Communication Commissions (Regulate media across the United States) |
Ownership | – Owned and produced by the BBC (British Broadcasting Corporation) – TV license fee | – Owned by CBS (Columbia Broadcasting System) which is owned by Paramount Global. |
James Curran (Power and responsibility) | – ‘Independence poses a serious threat to political institutions’ – Pg 134 meaning that the independence of the BBC is threatening political institutions such as the government. | – “profit-driven motives take precedence over creativity” meaning that CBS creates the idea of a massive panic to produce a large sum of money over the idea of making a good entertainment. CBS are in for the money making scheme rather than an entertainment scheme. |
Jean Seaton | – ‘Commercial broadcasting is based not on the sale of programmes to audiences but on the sale of audiences to advertisers’ – pg 126 – meaning broadcasting requires advertising revenue to maintain programming and they are designed to attract ‘economically affluent audiences’, meaning audiences who want to buy the product that are promoted, although the BBC does not have adverts. The BBC does not want to chase big fantasy stories, this proves they seek to inform audiences on international and national information rather than entertain. | – Seeks to entertain with stories rather than inform audiences. |
Noam Chomsky | ||
Paul Lazarfeld (Two-step flow communication model) | – Two-step flow communication model is most people form their opinions under the influence of opinion leaders, who in turn are influenced by the mass media. (People form their ideas from influencers and those with a high reputation.) – An example of this is Prince Harry and Kate the Princess of Wales promoting mental health through Newsbeat. This impacts audiences as opinions leaders like the royal family are helping others. (11th October 2022 – Prince and Princess of Wales take over Radio 1 Newsbeat on World Mental Health day) | – Famous author Orsen Welles reads War of the Worlds, to share their message of entertainment. |
Jurgen Habermas (Transofrmation of the Public Sphere) | – He states that a variety of factors have affected the way people share their ideas and social issues willingly and freely. -Transformation of the public sphere. – The BBC (when making money) re-invests back into the company to make it better, adapt it and sticks to their charter tighter. (Inform, entertain, educate) | – CBS sticks to making a profit rather than creating better content for their audiences. They do not transform the public sphere as CBS do not share knowledge and news, but only entertain. |
Cross Media | – | – |
Category Archives: Radio
Filters
RADIO 20 MARK REVISION
Theme | Newsbeat | War of the Worlds |
Ownership | Owned by the BBC, the BBC is owned and payed for the by the public. Payed through TV licenses BBC Charter: Educate, Inform, Entertain | Owned by CBS, CBS is payed for by Paramount global. Privately owned, available to everyone. |
Regulation | Regulated by Ofcom which receives it regulation rules through the UK gov. Also regulates off of the BBC’s Charter. | CBS is regulated by the The Federal Communications Commission (US FCC) |
Habermas | Transformation of the public sphere, the BBC (when making money) re-invests it into BBC to make it better, adapt it and sticks to their charter tighter. | Sticks to making a profit rather than bettering itself. Does not transform the public sphere, the polar opposite of the BBC. |
Chomsky | 5 filters of mass media: 1.Structures of ownership – BBC owned by the public, regulated by their own Ethos. 2.The role of advertising – Ads for the BBC are on social media platforms displaying what they offer, for example the “Trust is earned” publication video they made. 3.Links with ‘The Establishment’ – BBC isn’t directly connected to the government however it is regulated by a set of rules the government chooses. 4.Diversionary tactics – ‘flack’ – None really applies as the BBC specialises in its truth. 5.Uniting against a ‘common enemy’ | |
Audience | Active consumption, choosing to listen in and create opinions and thoughts based on the stories which are on the media/radio from newsbeat. | Passive consumption, taking in what war of the worlds is saying and just believing it. |
Lazarfeld | Harry and Kate promoting mental Health on mental Health Day, Stormzy being put on the show. This uses opinion leaders so that its not the BBC directly telling the audience how to feel, its their favourite influencers. | It is written by Orsen Wells, who was a popular author uses the two step flow of directly injecting the idea of entertain through War Of the Worlds, at 0:20 it is announced that Orsen will be reading the show and is also announced it is a story from the Theatre on Air. |
Stuart Hall | ||
New Technology | Newsbeat is on social media, internet radio and apps. | |
Cross media creation | Newsbeat is on social media, internet radio and apps. Can be read and understood on different platforms for the younger audiences to access it anywhere and whenever they want. | The show was originally published as a book in the UK and US in 1897, then a radio show in 1938 and then a TV series in 1988 |
Curran | “profit-driven motives take precedence over creativity” CBS creating the idea of a a massive panic to create a huge amount of money over the idea of making a good entertainment. | |
Seaton | POWER AND MEDIA: patterns of ownership and control are the most significant factors in how the media operate. Controls how they want to target audiences that are informed and want to learn. Seaton says “Sells audiences to advertisers not products to audiences” which the BBC doesn’t do, they do this by sticking to their “educate” ethos and making stories to educate. | Provides to audiences the idea of entertainment without sticking to any sort of ethos or education. Only entertainment and selling a big story which we don’t know is true (I.E people running out of their homes in fear of the story that they are hearing. |
Comparative Table
Theme | Newsbeat | War of the Worlds |
Ownership | – Owned by BBC -First Director General: Lord Reith -Multi-media/cross media -Not a monopoly – Left wing libertarian views Concentration of ownership- small number of firms own radio or tv – Paternalist approach – owned by public- Tv license | (private company, cross-media conglomerate, an example of concentration of ownership i.e. just a few companies own everything – oligopoly/cartel) |
Habermas | ||
Chomsky | ||
Regulation | – Government is at an ‘arms length’ from the media, they don’t control it but advise and ‘look after’ the content, public. | |
Audience (active/passive) | ||
Lazerfeld | ||
Hall | ||
New technology | ||
Cross Media Convergance | ||
Curran | -Theory of Liberal free press | some general ideas: 1. concerns about the commercial interest of big companies (prioritising profits over social concerns) 2. concentration of ownership – although not monopolies, the small number of big companies is not good for 3. competition 4. Diverse range of voices (plurality) 5. audience choices |
Seaton | –Commercial broadcasting is based on the sale of audiences to advertisers” – Commercial broadcasters (such as ITV) need to secure long term advertising revenue to survive programming. – No adverts when watching BBC – need for an active audience. – money wins (profit-driven) – accountability –who looks after the BBC: Annan Report 1980 “on balance the chain of accountability is adequate” -independence – ie keeping free from state control “without a commitment to public service, broadcasters are increasingly vulnerable to political interference” | -Seaton talks about rise and inevitable need for competition with new technologies – which provides choice -Provides more entertainment for wider audiences -WoW targets mainstream entertainment seeking audiences maybe linking to popular culture? the allusion of Choice – “Choice, without positive direction is a myth, all too often the market will deliver more -but only more of the same” |
CSP – WOTW + NEWSBEAT
COMPARISION | WOTW | NEWSBEAT |
OWNERSHIP (INSTITUTIONS) | – CBS (Columbia Broadcasting Service) – Owned by Paramount Global (“multinational mass media conglomerate”) – Funded mostly through advertising time on air – War of the Worlds episode was the 17th in ‘The Mercury Theatre on the Air’ series in 1938. – Key terms: Globalization, conglomerate, multinational, vertical integration, ‘risky business’ | – BBC (British Broadcasting Corperation) -Owned publicly by the general public of the UK – Funded through TV Licenses (paid annually – £159 per year) – Paternalist approach (giving audiences what they should have/ need) – First Director General was Lord Reith (he created original ethos) – “provide impartial, high-quality and distinctive output and services which inform, educate and entertain“ – Key Terms: Populist VS Paternalist, public service broadcasting, funded publicly |
AUDIENCE (Demographic) | – Listeners of CBS Radio Network. Those in the USA. | – Young people – Listeners of BBC Radio 1, 1 Extra and Asian Network. – Ages 15-29 |
HABERMAS | – Commercial broadcasting goes against Habermas’ ideas. – Commercial broadcasting focuses on profit and entertainment rather than audience. | Transformation of the public sphere. – The BBC values transforming knowledge through entertainment. They provide a paternalistic approach as a way of informing their range of audience on diverse, current and important issues. (quality programming) – Cecil Lewis said that the BBC “opens up new worlds to people”. Discussion VS Directorial – “arena of public debate” |
HESMONDHALGH | – “the creative industries are a risky business” | |
CURRAN – The role of public service broadcasting is to ‘diversify voices’ – Plurality | “profit -driven motives take precedence over creativity in the world of commercial media” – Perhaps CBS used the notion of a “moral panic” across the USA as a marketing approach following the broadcast. Commercial broadcasting (especially CBS lacks a public service remit – it can slightly subvert regulation/ enforcement) – Taking a risk | – Media of the “Victorian era” were “engines for social and political change” (linking to Habermas’ ideas on the transformation of the public sphere) – “peak-time television schedules are dominated by lighter entertainment formats” – The BBC is now being overthrown by the rise of social media/ commercial broadcasting due to profit. |
SEATON | – Power of the media “commercial broadcasting is based on the sale of audiences to advertisers” – CBS were selling ‘War of the Worlds’ to listeners | “the work of broadcasting should be regarded as a public service for a social purpose” – BBC has a remit to inform, entertain and educate (a social purpose). “public service” – Something to serve the public, “social purpose” – Something to help transform our society for the better – Her ideas imply that commercial broadcasting is more of a money making product rather than important to making a change. – “to lead public opinion” “catering for all sections of the community, reaching all parts of the country” – Linking to their Royal Charter: ACCOUNTABILITY |
REGULATION | Federal Communications Commission regulates privately. Not for interest of the public | – The BBC is overseen by the government through the ‘Royal Charter’. This agreement is proposed in parliament and is reviewed annually. First established in 1927, the Charter provides a remit that the BBC must accustom to. – As well as their charter, The BBC is regulated externally by Ofcom. Ofcom closely monitor the BBC through their Broadcasting Code. They provide a yearly report on their findings. – The emergence of new technologies/ generations today means that the BBC is challenged. Perhaps, the BBC is struggling to keep up with the needs of a changing society. |
CHOMSKY – Manufacturing consent. | ||
TEXTUAL EVIDENCE | War of the Worlds: – “We know now that in the early years of the 20th century, this world was being watched closely by intelligences greater than man’s” – “out of character” – “the war of the worlds has no further significance” | – Inclusion of relevant news stories, similar to ones featured on BBC News but delivered in a way that is easy to follow/ is more engaging and interactive. – Stories very much focused on ‘young people’ and how current issues are affect the youth: – ‘Young people face surge in homelessness’ – ‘The young NHS workers who voted yes to striking’ A range of articles focus on celebrities/ pop culture. A way of providing entertainment through a multi-media form that also informs. Debbie Ramsay (Newsbeat editor) said that reporters do not “dumb down” a story. They summarise it without any “airs or graces” |
EVIDENCE (EXTERNAL QUOTES) | “Radio 1 is about giving young people a voice” – |
War of the Worlds – csp
- War of the Worlds was a special edition episode of the radio series The Mercury Theatre on the Air as a Halloween special.
- It was directed and narrated by Orson Welles as an adaptation of H. G Well’s novel, “The War of the Worlds” (1898)
- Broadcast live at 8pm on October 30th, 1938 through the CBS Radio Network (provides news to more than 1,000 radio stations throughout the U.S)
- The episode is famously known for inciting panic from the public by convincing some members of the audience that an alien invasion was happening.
- The program begins with a monologue resembling the introductory monologue in the original novel
- It then follows on to the usual radio show (music/speaking) where it is then periodically interrupted by news bulletins talking about explosions on mars.
- An on-scene reporter describes the crisis in a sense of panic before the feed goes dead.
- After a series of news updates the presenter goes into silence where a radio operator asks “Is there anyone on the air? Isn’t there… anyone?” with no response. The program takes its first break thirty minutes after Welles’s introduction.
- The broadcast ends with a brief “out of character” announcement by Welles in which he compares the show to “dressing up in a sheet and jumping out of a bush and saying ‘boo!'”
- In the days following, widespread outrage was expressed in the media. The program was described as “deceptive” by newspapers and opinion leaders.
- This lead to an outcry against the broadcasters and implications for a regulatory assessment by the FCC.
- Welles then apologized at a news conference the next morning, and no punitive action was taken.
- The broadcast and subsequent publicity brought the 23-year-old Welles to the attention of the general public leaving him with the reputation of a storyteller and “trickster”
- “I had conceived the idea of doing a radio broadcast in such a manner that a crisis would actually seem to be happening, and would be broadcast in such a dramatized form as to appear to be a real event taking place at that time, rather than a mere radio play.” – Welles
- Welles took inspiration from Ronald Knox’s radio hoax “Broadcasting the Barricade” which was broadcast by the BBC in 1926
- Actor Stefan Schnabel recalled sitting in the anteroom after finishing his on-air performance. “A few policemen trickled in, then a few more. Soon, the room was full of policemen and a massive struggle was going on between the police, page boys, and CBS executives, who were trying to prevent the cops from busting in and stopping the show. It was a show to witness.”
- Due to some listeners only hearing a portion of the broadcast and in the tension and anxiety prior to World War II mistook it for a genuine news broadcast.
- Thousands shared the false reports with others or called CBS, newspapers, or the police to ask if the broadcast was real.
- Many newspapers assumed that the large number of phone calls and the scattered reports of listeners rushing about or fleeing their homes proved the existence of a mass panic
- The broadcast was even shown flashing in Times Square (New York)
- Host Jack Paar of the Tonight Show received calls to the studio asking if the world was coming to an end. After Paar denied it listeners started to accuse him with “covering up the truth”
- On November 2, 1938, the Australian newspaper The Age characterized the incident as “mass hysteria” and stated that “never in the history of the United States had such a wave of terror and panic swept the continent”. Unnamed observers quoted by The Age commented that “the panic could have only happened in America”
Media Institutions
- Broadcast by Columbia Broadcasting Company – an institution still in existence (a television and radio network) today.
- Radio broadcasting was seen as competition to newspapers which had previously been the only way of receiving news.
- Radio broadcasting was regulated by the Federal Communications Commission
- They also investigated the broadcast to see if it had broken any laws.
- The broadcast provides an excellent example to consider the effect of individual producers on media industries (known as ‘auteur theory’) as this is the work of Orson Welles.
- Auteur theory is an artist with a distinctive approach whose control is so unbound but personal that they are likened to be the “author”.
Media Audiences
- Gerbner: Cultivation Theory – People who are more exposed to “living” in the television world, the more likely they are to believe that social reality aligns with the reality portrayed on television
- Exposure to media affects a viewer’s perceptions of reality, drawing attention to three aspects: institutions, messages, and publics – linking to mainstreaming and how viewers develop a common outlook.
csp: War of the worlds
Facts and Figures:
- The War of the Worlds was an episode of the radio series “The Mercury Theatre on the Air”, this was a radio series of live dramas which were created and hosted by Orson Welles in the United States and was originally released on July 11th to December 4th 1938.
- “The War of the Worlds” was specifically a Halloween radio episode which was performed and broadcasted live at 8pm until 9pm on October 30th 1938 and ran for 60 minutes (1 hour).
- “The War of the Worlds” episode instigated panic by convincing members of the public that specific events were taking place such as a Martian invasion although the episode only had few listeners so this did not become a global panic.
- According to Wikipedia, 6 million people heard the episode and caused 1.2 million to be frightened and disturbed. Although 30 minutes into the show before its first break, people still believed this.
- The episode was broadcasted over the CBS (Columbia Broadcasting company Radio Network. This radio network provided news to more than 1,000 radio stations throughout the United States and is owned by Paramount Global. CBS Radio was launched in 1927.
Theorists:
- George Gerbner: Created the Cultivation Theory and suggested that the theory’s key proposition is that “the more time people spend ‘living’ in the television world, the more likely they are to believe social reality aligns with reality portrayed on television.” and this links to War of the Worlds as most of the audiences who listened to the radio drama episode believed the stories which were mentioned causing the watchers to become disturbed and uncomfortable. I feel the main section which may have started the belief of the live drama was when producers interrupted the music to announce an important message e.g alien invasion from Mars (First announcement at 3:38)
- Stuart Hall developed the Theory of encoding and decoding and created ‘The Encoding/decoding model of communication’ which is a theoretical approach of how media messages are produced, disseminated, and interpreted. In terms of War of the Worlds,
- Harold Lasswell: Created the One step-flow of Hypothermic Needle theory which suggests that media explores information in such a way that it injects in the mind of audiences as bullets which causes different reactions to the media messages.
csp- War of the worlds
Quick notes:
- 1930s
- Early example of a hybrid radio form
- It adapts the H.G. Wells story using news and documentary conventions
- Broadcast and initial response to it has a historical significance
- example of the mass media apparently having a direct effect on an audience’s behaviour
- Academic research was put into the broadcast
- Provided some of the early media audience research
- Findings are extremely influential in the media, advertising and political campaigning
- timestamp 39:30 the audio goes silent. this is unusual in radio, trying to add to the eeriness and trying to make the story more believable?
WHAT IS IT?
- A radio play about Martians invading New Jersey.
- It fooled people
MEDIA INSTITUTIONS:
- Broadcasted by Colombia Broadcasting Company
- an institution still in existence
- Radio broadcasting was a direct competition to newspapers
- The broadcast= good example of institutions branching out to attract new audiences
- The broadcast is a good example to consider the effect of individual producers on media industries [the work of Orson Welles]
REGULATION
- Radio broadcasting was regulated by the Federal Communications Commission
- It investigated the broadcast to see if it had broken any laws
AUDIENCES:
- External factors that influence audience response:
HISTORICAL, POLITICAL, SOCIAL AND CULTURAL CONTEXTS:
MEDIA LANGUAGE:
CSP – WAR OF THE WORLDS
- Hybrid Radio form
- War of the Worlds was a novel published in 1989 by H.G Wells. In 1938, it was adapted into a radio drama directed and narrated by Orson Welles for CBS Radio Network (Columbia Broadcasting Company)
- 1930’s/40’s = The ‘Golden Age’ of Radio
- The ‘War of the Worlds’ episode was the 17th episode in the ‘The Mercury Theatre on the Air’ series in which Orson Welles transformed a series of classic literature into radio dramas.
Evidence
- Interruption in broadcast (39.30 mins) – News goes silent
- “We know now that in the early years of the 20th century, this world was being watched closely by intelligences greater than man’s”
Institution
CBS Radio Network:
- ‘CBS Radio Network’ is owned by ‘Paramount Global’ (a “multinational mass media conglomerate”) through horizontal integration.
- ‘Paramount Global’ was formed in 2019 as a product of the merging between CBS Cooperation and Viacom.
Audience
“Radio listeners in Panic, Taking War Drama as Fact”
Regulation
- In the 1930’s, Radio was regulated by the Federal Communications Commission
War of the Worlds
War of the Worlds is a drama, and it uses the codes and conventions of a news broadcast in order to make a made up explosion and invasion of aliens seem like a real world issue and crisis.
Media Institutions
War of the Worlds was broadcast by Columbia Broadcasting Company – an institution still in existence
At the time, radio and broadcasting was seen as direct competition to newspapers.
The broadcast heavily shows that institutions are always looking for new styles of products to make to attract new audiences.
Regulation – radio broadcasting was regulated by the Federal Communications Commission and it investigated the broadcast to see if it had broken any laws.
The broadcast shows the effect of individual producers on media industries (known as ‘auteur theory’)
Media Audiences
Stuart Hall – Preferred reading – Dominant reading would be to acknowledge the broadcast as not real and a work of fiction, while other people took it very seriously and it greatly affected their lives.
Cultivation theory – Gerbner stated that if enough content is produced with a certain agenda is produced, people will accept it as reality – Radio was growing so much in the 1930s, and so people were unclear whether radio itself could ever consist of lies.
CBS likely exaggerated impact of War of the Worlds for marketing and publicity purposes – people didn’t actually kill themselves and believe martians were invading – according to Jean Baudrillard’s theories around postmodernism. He states that “people lose the ability to distinguish between reality and fantasy.
CE Hooper rating survey conducted 12 hours after the program went live found 98% of the people at the time weren’t listening. Of the 2%, no one took it as a legitimate news broadcast.
This shows that the dominant reading as depicted by Hall’s theory of preferred reading is that people treated it as fake.
CSP 13: NewsBeat
Industries
Newsbeat is a BBC News product with bulletins which are broadcast on BBC Radio 1, BBC Radio 1 Xtra and BBC Asian Network. Newsbeat- radio service from the BBC
The main focus is news towards teenagers and “twentysomethings”.
Funded by the tax from the government, hypothecated tax, money from a specific tax goes towards the BBC for education.
Launched on the 10th September 1973
What could be asked?
How do media companies use industrial strategies to target specific audiences?
Newsbeat has Twitter, YouTube and other social media accounts and features on the BBC’s website, reaching over 9 million people a week. This would not be possible without the addition of social media platforms, which demonstrates the strategies used by the BBC in order to mitigate risk – Hesmondhalgh.
Reporters on NewsBeat have been told to address listeners as if they were “talking to a friend” as described by the editor, Danielle Dwyer. This adds a friendly feel to the programme which helps to appeal to the younger audience which it is made for. They have also been told to steer clear of long, complicated words which allows for listeners to not have to pay as much attention when listening and also easy for younger people to digest and decode – Hall’s reception theory.
What could I argue?
I want to argue that the BBC uses many different industrial strategies in order to reduce the risks of the media industries and increase the appeal of their products.