Mens Health analysis

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is mens-health-article.jpg
creates more room for a larger audience.

The front magazine page suggest that the anchorage which is the picture of the male figure is linked with the header as it means ‘MENS HEALTH’ a way to which help the male audience to tag along and read more on how to look like the front male figure on the page.

Semiotics

Representation – straight ‘alpha male’ men is reactionary. reinforces the idea that men need to be powerful and strong.

– Media language

“get back in shape special” Use of capital letters, exclamation points, colours blue and black stereotypically appealing to men, dialogue “true grit” of men’s wants and desires for their body – all are signifiers to men.

“Best fitness classes for men” – target audience is undoubtedly is for men.

”103 shortcuts to tee shirt arms”, this is a male ‘want’ to aspire to look like Vin Diesel, as his body type is typically what a dream body for a man is, alike skinny arms and a slim waist for women.

Steve Neal says that audience targeting that genres create an appeal for specific audience segments for example to attract the male audience they want something to be portrayed to make them seem powerful and strong to make all of their masculine traits come out.

onimatopia and alliteration.

David g- 4 personality types

  • constructed identity- words such as ”muscle, smash, demolish”, construct a typical male identity.

The school of life… thus supporting gauntlets notion of fluid, negotiated, constructive identity.

For example, on page 24 it displays a man topless doing exercise, he is seamlessly lifting weights without any struggle which a ‘warm man’ would display.

key facts on men’s health:

  • circulation analysis:
  • Joined ABC: 12 April 1995
  • Owner: Hearst UK
  • ABC Status: Registered
  • Reporting Frequency: 12 Monthly (Jan to Dec)
  • Standards: Consumer Magazines
  • Area: Men’s Lifestyle: General
  • 27,871 bought copies in one year
  • 66,428 subscription copies in one year
  • 1,174 free copies in one year
  • 23,077 digital copies bought in one year

Hearst company (parent company) is a conglomerate- owns company’s such as:

Hearst owns newspapers, magazines, television channels, and television stations, including the San Francisco Chronicle, the Houston Chronicle, Cosmopolitan and Esquire

-Men’s health

-ELLE

-country living

-cosmopolitan

-women’s health

-runners world

– Monthly reach of Men’s Health magazine in the United Kingdom from April 2019 to March 2020, by demographic group.

15+ –1,819

Men- 708

women- 365

adults 15-34- 519

adults 35+ –554

households with children- 391

  • Men’s Health magazine had an average monthly reach of around 1.8 million individuals in the United Kingdom from April 2019 to March 2020. Reach was lower among households with children, with 391 thousand readers from this demographic reached by the print title or its website during this period.

To feature in Men’s health:

full page- $205,065 dollars

2/3 page- $159,995

1/2 page- $127,145

1/3 page-$88,180

second cover- $246.080

third cover- $237,880

fourth cover- $268,640

Laswell’s model

who(sender)

-Hearst communications (parent company)

-Morgan Rees

-says what(message)

-media pack (unique strategies men’s health use to get people to buy and read)

-”professional men to get control of their mental and physical lives”

-Channel(medium)

-print

-online (web portal)

-social media

-To whom(receiver)

-men interested in fitness and health

-Educated men

-family men

-college educated

With What Effect.

-Making people more healthy

-more happy men in the country

key facts for exam:

dominant signifier – Vin diesel on the front cover of the magazine

dominant ideology – Body image

reactionary representation – A heterosexual man and what society expects on him.

negative stereotype – this creates a negative stereotype to men having to be seen as strong and loose weight

The blue background is associated with male stereotypes, a traditional boy colour

Laswell’s module:

Sender – Men’s health’s is one of the largest men’s magazine and is aimed mainly at “manly” men

Says What – The brand of the magazine called ‘Men’s Health’ aimed for active men who want a better control on their physique / appearance to impress society.

What Channel – Men’s health is a print lifestyle magazine and can also be accessed on their website and social media.

To Whom – Aimed at men who are ‘sporty’ or active. If a man wants motivation to get into shape then the magazine provides information on loosing weight to get that ‘perfect body’

What Effect – Selling the magazine to their target audience through shops, website or social media.

CS Peirce:

Iconic sign – The bold text tells you what you can find inside of this magazine issue. It all relates to loosing weight fast.

Indexical signs – The only image is the dominant signifier placed right in the middle. The muscles relates to the text and the magazine.

Symbolic sign – The magazines colour theme is mostly blue which is seen as a stereotypical colour for men, influences them to buy the magazine. Big bold texts all about loosing weight “demolish junk food cravings” and “Blast body fat”. The dominant signifier, vin diesel, is positioned in the middle showing off his muscles.

Stuart hall – Hall provides a framework for decoding messages:

accept the dominant message
negotiate the dominant message
reject the dominant message

Facts:

  • Men’s health magazine had an average monthly reach of around 1.8 million individuals in the UK between 2019 to 2020
  • The ages of people who buy this magazine between 2019 to 2020 were 15 years and above and could potentially be harmful for young teenagers because they feel this is how they should look like and that the magazine would help them with their goal to looking muscular.
  • The media chooses how people should look like. By adding a celebrity to the front page of their magazine it influences young people to buy and read it.

    – Mens health is owned by hearst who own 40 different companies founded in 1887.

what needs to be in the exam-

mainstreaming- guerbner said amount of company’s make the same products – feeding us the same info conglomerates0- concentration of owner ship.

Industry– Hearts communications (conglomerate), concentration of ownership (eg: other mag that heart owns), hesmandhale (risky buisness), cross media platforms( digital and print), role and prominence of advertising, profit, income, sales, online data.

Language– Use of colour, font, layout, image, semantic fields(words used), juxtaposition, semiotics, genre, narrative

Representation– reactionary and radical, stereotype, counter type, collective identity, negotiated identity (ie: guentlt,) mulvey (male gaze), Butler (gender performance)

Audience-

Stuart hall (preferred reading) guerdner (cultivation theory, mainstreaming), lazerfeld( 2 step slow, opinion leader, audience profile\demographics-see men’s health media profile, psychographic profile- all ages)

CSP – MENS HEALTH

Men’s Health

  • January/ February 2017 Edition

Front Cover

  • Use of hashtag to link to social media and perhaps trying to access a younger demographic
  • Reactionary, stereotypical text colouring through the different shades of blues and black. A typical symbolic (arbitrary) sign of masculinity
  • Semantic field of power and strength, connoting to something that needs to be destroyed. – “Lose, Demolish, Slay, Blast, Burn, Detox, Reboot”
  • Alliteration and plosives through ‘blast body’
  • Stereotypical representation of masculinity through the man as the dominant signifier on the front cover. He seems strong, physically fit and physically intimidating which mirror the masculine traits often portrayed in the media -‘what defines a man’
  • Alpha male – Muscles, standing pose, perhaps an enhanced/ edited image – “not a true window into the world”
  • ‘Gender as performance’ – Judith Butler (Gender is constructed through a repeated set of actions, sex is a biological factor)

Contents Page

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is mens-health-contents-page.jpg
  • Links to online website ‘menshealth.co.uk’, perhaps encouraging readers to move online to view the magazine – Moving into the digital world of social media.
  • Reactionary representation of exercise, strength and fitness through links to articles within the magazine on the contents page. This is shown through image signifiers such as pictures of trainers, weights etc. Creating this unrealistic ideal that to be a ‘real’ man you must be physically at top performance. Although there is a radical representation through the inclusion of men of different ages and races.
  • Typical male characteristics displayed through linking to an article with a picture featuring spanners, lock and key, cogs etc. Perhaps, men are ‘meant’ to be good with construction etc.

Article (within magazine)

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is mens-health-article.jpg
  • Main image of ‘The Marathon Man’ running.
  • Inclusion of a quotation from him – Motivation and drive – “Your only limit is your self-belief”
  • Q+A style interview signposted through bold font for question and different for answers.
  • Iconic sign of a arrow, clearly marking that he is the topic of the conversation.

Magazines CSP, MEN’S HEALTH

Paper 2 CSP:
Page 1:

Vin Diesel on Men’s Health magazine

Semiotics:

  1. Dominant signifier being Vin Diesel, we know this because he is the main focus within the first page, being the biggest and most outward object on the page.
  2. The title “Men’s Health” being indexical to men’s health and the gender performance of the male gender.
  3. The page is reactionary, supporting the typical view of strong, independent men.
  4. The syntagm of men’s gender performance and what men should be like. This suggestion is that men should be fit and strong with muscular developments. “Lose 8kg fast”, “127 ways to build a stronger core” “103 shortcuts to t-shirt arms”
  5. The title and Vin Diesel in the magazine provide anchorage that the magazine is targeted and made for men.

Representation:

  1. Gender is represented through the magazines choice of colours, the colour being an aggressive dark blue which can represent masculinity.
  2. The sub-title “Get Back in Shape Special” represents men and the typical stereotype that men are fit and strong.
  3. The model used (Vin Diesel) supports and promotes the idea of gender as a performance and fits the heterosexual gaze.
  4. The constructed identity of a typical man is represented on the front page, but also other pages. Firstly, Vin Diesel is seen to represent the typical male, being strong, fit and have a aggressive, alpha stance.


    Lazarfelds idea within men’s health:
    Vin Diesel represents the idea of a strong and fit man, therefore his supporters or followers are going to buy the magazine and follow its tips to try and end up looking like him, because its his idea and his opinion that says you should be fit and active, that’s why he is also fit and active himself.

    On page 6 -7 Gerard Butler can be seen as a model for the Boss aftershave “Intense”, the idea is that his supporters and people who follow him will look at this advert and think “he’s cool and he’s wearing that aftershave, so i should buy it to be cool like him”

    Page 2:
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is mens-health-contents-page.jpg

Semiotics:

  1. Icon – Vin diesel photograph in the bottom left
  2. Dominant signifier being the editors letter positioned in the bottom right, talking about new years resolutions.
  3. Anchorage being each photo posted with the page number it correlates to.
  4. The picture of Vin Diesel creates the strong male ideology.

Representation:

  1. The constructed identity of the Male gender is represented here through the selection and combination of images of vin diesel along with pictures of the other pages, some of these pages contain weights or running shoes, implying the stereotype of how men are fit and strong.
  2. The individual identity of different types of men, being the strong man (Vin Diesel) down the bottom left, the old man in the middle (True Grit) and the cool man also in the middle (Page 125).

The school of life released a video called how to be a man, while this is not an academic theory, it nevertheless presents two versions of masculinity, the warm man and the cool man. It is possible to identify these two versions in men’s health thus supporting David Gauntlets notion of Fluid, negotiated, constructive identity. For example, on page 125 you can see a calm and collected man who isn’t ridiculously built up and fit, however he is positioned to be inspirational and confident. This is the representation of the “Warm Man” who knows his anxiety’s and flaws, but makes the most of what he has and stays as he is, calm and relaxed. However on page 2, within the advert for Dolce and Gabbana, the male within that photo is seen to be strong and fit, fitting the typical constructed identity of a cool man. He’s holding a woman, and shirtless in the middle of the snowy cold Alpes, but he doesn’t care, he’s calm and relaxed, and confident within himself.

Media Industries (And Audiences)

Men’s health is owned by a company called “Hearst” which has business in the UK and US, it’s mainly based in New York and started after the Founder William Randolph Hearst took over his fathers newspaper, the “San Francisco Analyser”
Hearst is a media conglomerate owning 7 different companies,
Fitch Ratings – A Market analysis company
First Database – A pharmaceutical company
Hearst Television – Owns 34 different television channels.
A-E Networks – Multinational joint broadcasting company between Disney and Hearst.

Men’s health reaches on average 89,111 people in one year, this is through majority paid subscriptions to the magazine. However, per month in the UK it is seen that it reaches 708 men aged 15+ (study made from April 2019 to March 2020) which fits the targeted demographic group.

Hearst not only has men’s health, they also have woman’s health. Along with 10 other woman focused magazines, however only 1 for men.

Woman’s health reaches on average 96,350 people in one year, which is 7,239 more than men’s health. with 65,000 of them being monthly subscriptions which is 1000 less than men’s health. This supports the idea that the media conglomerate of Hearst is supporting and creating content for both genders and many different beliefs to maximise profits and followers.

Stuart hall in “Men’s Health”:

Page 12-13

Here we can see the creators idea that weightless, nutrition, health, fitness, style and muscle are the main things in your life to focus and produce upon. I could see how health fanatics and body building see that and agree with it because that the way they are and that’s what they focus on the most, however to someone like me I can agree that all of those things are very important but it shouldn’t be the be all and end all of your life, you should be with your family and friends, and focus on relationships rather than everything being for yourself and impressing others, however I can also see how someone who is unhealthy, sits at home eating takeaways constantly and is over weight would look at this page and completely disagree with it and continue on with their ideas of life rather than re-considering with these.

CSP: MEN’S HEALTH

PRINT MAGAZINE

  • Big clear graphological features
  • Society’s stereotypical, ideology of a man ‘Alpha male’
  • The dominant signifier is the man standing in the middle looking ‘strong’
  • Reactionary representations of masculinity and physical health
  • Target audience/Ideal audience are men
  • Alliteration and Onomatopoeia ‘Blast Body Fat’
  • Lexical pattern
  • Judith butler- gender is a performance
  • Semantic pattern of physical power and strength
  • Symbolism of physical health (Weights) throughout 3 pages
  • The main icon is a picture of the interviewee runny- making links to the article: him being a marathon runner

Representation-

The school of Life:

Produced a video called ‘How to be a man’, while this isn’t an academic theory, it nevertheless it presents 2 versions of masculinity: the warm man, and the cool man. It is possible to identify these 2 versions in men’s health , thus supporting Gauntlett’s notion of Fluid, Negotiated, Constructed identity.

For example, on page 167,

On page 44, they are warm men

Page 6, cool men

CSP 11 & 12 – Magazine

Research –

men and women’s health magazine – both play appeal to the male gaze. With men’s health magazine being marketed towards men and women’s magazine being marketed towards women who want to achieve the male gaze. The women are far mor sexualised than the men, with 90% of women’s health magazine front covers featuring sexualised women, and just 40% of men’s health magazine featuring sexualised men.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is mens-health-front-cover.jpg
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is mens-health-contents-page.jpg
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is mens-health-article.jpg

Semiotics

Representation – straight ‘alpha male’ men – reactionary – reinforces the idea that men need to be powerful and strong – “get back in shape special”

Use of capital letters – exclamation points – colours – dialogue “true grit” – all appeal to men

Actor Vin Diesel (dominant signifier) – appeals more to men than women

“Best fitness classes for men” – target audience is undoubtedly men

Icon – picture of Vin Diesal

Indexical link – sweat = worked out

Genre – Steve Neale states that genres all contain instances of repetition and difference, difference is essential to the to the economy of the genre. Neale states that the film and it’s genre is defined by two things: How much is conforms to its genre’s individual conventions and stereotypes.

I’d argue that the genre of this magazine is lifestyle / fitness aimed at men

Narrative

Print Language

‘The School of Life’ video ‘How to be a man’ presents the ‘cool’ man and the ‘warm’ man, this links to Gauntlets notion that identity is fluid and negotiated. We can see examples of both the cool man, and the warm man, in Men’s health, for instance, on the front cover of the magazine, Vin Diesel is an example of the ‘cool’ man. He is confident, strong, and powerful which are all qualities of the cool man. His pose is strong and wise, which connotes masculinity.

Stuart Hall

Through using Vin Diesel as the face of Men’s Health, there is an encoded message that men should look powerful and dominant like Vin Diesel. There is a suggestion that if you (as a man) are not muscular and strong, then you are not a real man.

Magazines – Men’s Health

Semiotics: how images signify cultural meanings

The front magazine page suggest that the anchorage which is the picture of the male figure is linked with the header as it means ‘MENS HEALTH’ a way to which help the male audience to tag along and read more on how to look like the front male figure on the page.

The media naturalises ideas through repetition as there are many phrases that have similar meaning suggesting it has one overall meaning to portray.

Character oppositions can be found in real life world products as we can see in the magazine that it deploys the male audience to want to be like them and make them want to change to be more masculine.

It creates compelling narratives as as the audience are more likely to engage with a media product if they are presented with the promise of a narrative clash.

Steve Neal says that audience targeting that genres create an appeal for specific audience segments for example to attract the male audience they want something to be portrayed to make them seem powerful and strong to make all of their masculine traits come out.

Barthes says that imagery does not construct meaning by itself, it works alongside text-based components. Headers and taglines give meaning to photos while photos themselves provide an accompanying visual explanation for news copy.

You can apply David Gauntlet’s work into the men’s magazine as men are expected to assume stereotypically masculine identities to gain the role of the primary earner.

The school of life video how to be a man presents the cool man and the warm man. This links to Gauntlet’s notion that identity is fluid and negotiated. Although this is not a theory we can see examples of the cool man and the warm man is men’s health.

For instance on page 8-9 it links to Gauntlet’s work as a huge diversity of identities is portrayed. Men are assumed to have masculine identities to portray the role of the primary earn.

Lasswell’s model

The sender is Hearst communication. The CEO is Steven Swartz

The message is to go out into psychological terms and make sure that social control is better in health.

To whom – Active people who are willing to listen. People who are willing and encouraged to do stuff, you can talk about people who have a stable relationship.

Channel – Print through lifestyle magazine, also online on their website.

With what effect – How much paper can they sell, they attract audiences to sell more. To promote it as well

Lazarfeld relates to Men’s health as we can see that Vin diesel (Male figure) in the picture is the dominant signifier making him the opinion leader making the audience want to passively seek out how to become like him although you could argue it can be active as the public is seeking out information to gain the knowledge on how to be like him. However, the concept has been a subject of growing criticism, leading to a decline in the popularity and attraction of the original concept which is taking away the idea of men’s health.

Uses and gratification can be seen to link with Men’s health in page 7 as that the idea of media audiences are active rather than passive, meaning they do not only receive information, but also unconsciously attempt to make sense of the message in their own context. This is because it is showing us a picture of cars where it is making the influencer want to have a motive to consume it. Their are many audience’s that may need new cars so therefore it is a good opportunity for the product to be sold. This could be seen as a sense of escapism as they may want to participate in the role of buying the product to make it enjoyable for them.

On page 48-49 we can link this to men’s health as it is suggesting that there is a various of ways that decoding can be interpreted as we can see a picture of a man in some sort of abandoned studio trying to reflect on how men could be like him all muscular and not fear anything. Stuart Hall suggest that media is represented through codes and be can be seen through imagery. Transcoding can refer to representation strategies that contest stereotypical assumptions.

Men’s health

-Semiotics, signifier, codes and conventions.

-Positive and negative stereotypes/ reactionary and radical.

-Manufacturing consent, mass media filters e.g. we are the product of advertisement.

-Dominant ideologies – stereotypes.

-Identity through negotiation, constructed. Fluidity of identity.

-Audience position, misrepresentation links to representation.

-Key feminist thinking- Laura Mulvey the mail guys.

the school of life’s video “how to be be a man” presents the cool man and the warm man, this links to gauntlets notion that identity is fluid and negotiated. Although this isn’t a theory we can can see example of the cool man and the warm man in Men’s health

for instance:

MAGAZINES

Semiotics – The man who is in the front cover is the signifier as he is the largest object in the front cover, the signification of him is that he is strong and manly, he is also an icon as its not the real vin diesel. The man is connotating that if u want to look like him, you have to read the magazine.

Narrative –

Print Language – The magazine is reactionary because there is a strong guy which people typically accept as its a fitness magazine, the colours are also blue which indicates it to be a boys / mans magazine backed up by the masthead.

Genre – The genre this fits into would be what its like to be a Man and it includes similar features that relate to being a Man.

Representation – The dominant signifier seems to have a collective identity as he seems to represent the whole group of men.

The school of life video, how to be a man presents the ‘cool man’ and the ‘warm man’ this links to Gauntletts notion that identity is fluid and negotiated. Although this is not a theory we can see examples of the ‘cool man’ and the ‘warm man’ in men’s health

For instance, on page 1 you will see the cool man, who is vin diesel. And on page 101 you will see the warm man who seems to be a lot more frail and older than the first man

Lasswells Model –

  • Sender – Hearst Communications
  • Says what – Get greater health over your physical, mental and emotional lives of a man.

Stuart Hall (Representation) –

Dominant – is the fact that the audience accepts and decodes the message the way the producer intended it to be.

Negotiated – For example in GTA you may be willing to negotiate your identity by killing people in the game and robbing people, but do not agree with those morals in real life.

Opposition – you wouldn’t see a purpose of the men’s health magazine and wouldn’t sell to you.

The media chooses how things and people are represented, usually by the higher ups which reflect their values and identities. They do this through stereotyping and choosing whether they want to reflect what’s going on in a positive or negative way (eg. Brexit, one paper may say its good, the other bad)

George Gerbner – Found that heavy viewers of news were more likely to overestimate crime rates and risk of personal exposure to crime and underestimate the safety of their neighbourhoods which is called the World Mean Index.
Mainstreaming – The more mainstream media that we consume the more “mainstream” we become.

Clay Shirky – Believes that Gerbners ideas are no longer applicable to contemporary models of media consumption