This is England first response

Rating: 6/10

I feel that the first 40 or so minuets of ‘This is England’ are the best of the whole movie. After Shaun stops being around Woody and starts hanging around with Combo more, I feel that the movie becomes less enjoyable, as to me it just felt like watching a child being manipulated and mistreated by adults he trusted for another hour, which I was not the biggest fan of. But I understand that this is probably the reaction that was wanted from the audience, and I enjoy some aspects of how it makes the viewer feel uncomfortable and as if they’re intruding on something they shouldn’t be.

Stand out scene:

I feel that the stand out scene for me was when Combo took Shaun, Gadget and Pukey to the nationalist meeting. It stood out to me because when I watched it, it made me feel uneasy, like I was intruding on something private that I shouldn’t and don’t want to see. The view of all these men listening to the man at the front spew hateful ideology, while later belittling the one person who decides to speak out on how stupid and hateful it was, really accentuates how the path Shaun is going down is a completely wrong one.

Representation

All aspects of a film form including narrative contribute to the representations of cultures and societies (gender, ethnicity and age) including the ideological nature of those representations.

Performance-

  • age
  • ethnicity
  • body language/gestures
  • facial expressions
  • costume

Stereotype- widely held but fixed oversimplified idea about a certain type of person or thing

Countertype- something that aims to go against its stereotype (i.e. black president of America)

Example: Sarah Connor

In the first terminator movie, Sarah is shown as timid and clumsy. She is a stereotypical waitress in the first movie, which being a fast pace and stressful environment, highlights these attributes by showing her in confrontations with customers.

While in the second movie, she is shown as very Countertypical compared to her first appearance. she is portrayed as an action heroine, showing her confidently handling guns. as well as this, her outfit now reflects her new role in the movie.

Trainspotting representation :

  1. who is doing the representation?- Danny Bo
  2. Who is being represented?- Drug addicts, Scottish lower class and men
  3. what social groups are omitted from representations?- non-white people. women are underrepresented. children
  4. what messages about particular social groups are being convicted?- Drug addicts are being shown in a very negative light and are shown to be reliant on them
  5. which characters or social groups have power within the representations?- men and the people who supply drugs to people
  6. do the characters adhere to or challenge stereotypes?- i feel they adhere to stereotypes about people who are addicted to drugs
  7. what do representations tell audiences about society at the time the film was made and/or set?- showing the underside of Edinburgh to audiences

Trainspotting representation

Older people– After Renton’s overdose, his parents take him in and care for him. Being some of the older characters who have a semi-prominent role in the story, they are shown as caring and nurturing as they look after Renton while he recovers and becomes sober.

Scottish people– during this scene, Renton talks about how he is not proud to be Scottish. He calls them ‘the lowest of the low’, and talks about how people hate the British, while they’re colonized by them. This is showing Scottish people as angry at the British, which is a common stereotype.

Addicts– There is two sides of addicts shown in Trainspotting. Towards the beginning, addicts are shown to be carefree and in a very positive light. They talk about how heroin is ‘better than sex’ multiple times though out the film. Which is then echoed by Tommy when he’s asking Renton for heroin after his breakup, which then leads t his downwards spiral and eventual death. Which is where the other, and much more prominent viewpoint comes from. Trainspotting shows how life as a drug addict is with little to no sugar coating, showing how it can impact someone’s social life, their reputation and relationships. Overall the portrayal and representation of addicts is very negative, but that is the films point.

Men– during this bar fight scene, all of the men are shown to be very aggressive, while the women leave. the confrontation starts very quickly and kicks off and while it started with only two people, it now involves the whole floor, which implies that men are aggressive and always wanting to fight.

Women– this scene is showing the women as cunning and well planned. Gail talks about how she enjoys seeing spud suffer from waiting. In the following scene they ask the boys what they where talking about, and when they get asked themselves, they reply with ‘shopping’ which pulls humour from a common stereotype that women like shopping

This is England Micro-elements

Sound

The movie starts of with an upbeat song over the credits. The song started the movie on a positive note which made me feel like the movie was going to be light and happy which was partially true since the movie included a lot of humor however it was mostly negative. The music was a form of non-diegetic sound since it didn’t come from the world of the movie.

cinematography

The cinematography throughout This is England makes the movie feel more personal to the audience. In this specific scene there is a close up of Shaun while talking Combo about how he feels. This close up shows how much the two characters are getting along especially since its switching between the two characters (POV shot). Not only does the close up make the characters feel closer, but it also makes the audience feel closer as well.

mise-en-scene

The mise en scene in the movie is consistent and gives the movie a overall chaotic feel. In this shot specifically, it shows how unserious the characters are since their costuming is random and not sensible. The setting they are in is also an abandoned house filed with graffiti which shows how they don’t tend to follow the rules and live life freely. A final mise en scene factor in this image is the coloring on Woody, while everyone else is wearing dull colors and balding in, Woody is wearing a bright blue which shows how he’s the ‘leader’.

editing

Throughout the movie, the editing is subtle and adds small but necessary visuals for the scene. The editing in this scene is particularly impressive since its a fading transitions of the English flag. This adds to the movie since its a bold way of showing what every character in this image stands for. Its also only a short insert and only slightly visible so it doesn’t take away from the visuals of the scene but it servers as a reminder of why the characters are connected.

Aesthetic

Verisimilitude– the quality of seeming true or of having the appearance of being real.

Social Realism– It is showing a realistic representation on what life was like at that moment in time. E.G- Making a WW2 film as accurate as possible. -Saving Private Ryan

Magic Realism– E.G- Harry Potter

Hyperreality– A film set in the future with amazing technology. E.G- The Matrix

Iconography– Iconography simply refers to the pattern of signs we associate with a particular genre. An obvious example would be the combination of futuristic costumes, props, and settings in science-fiction films. 

Intertextual Referencing– it’s where a movie overlaps with another work of film. -Family Guy

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is image-11-1024x1024.png

Visual/ Sound motifs in film– Objects, colours, shapes, settings.

James Bond

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is image-26.png

Colour Grading– digital tools or photochemical processes are used to make videos or films look better or change the colour tone and mood. 

Auteur Trademarks– A reference (character, an angle a theme) that is recurrent to the directors work. E.G- Tim Burton

Tone

Pathos, or the appeal to emotion, means to persuade an audience by purposely evoking certain emotions to make them feel the way the author wants them to feel.

 Bathos, Anticlimactic ending. Expecting something but gets something else.

Suspense, a sequence leading up to a jump scare. Tension within the scene.

Comedy, professional entertainment consisting of jokes and sketches, intended to make an audience laugh.

Dramatic irony, occurs when the audience knows something that the characters don’t. E.G, When the Jaws music plays we know the shark is near.

Distancing Effect, Reminding the audience that you are watching a film. Breaking the 3rd wall in the film E.G, Narration, Deadpool when he speaks to the audience.

Postmodern Humour, when a comedy presents an undeceived view of life.

Aesthetics

A overarching style and idea, including costumes and cinema and set design

Task 1 – find definitions for the following:

Verisimilitude– The idea of something appearing true.

The breakfast club, takes place in a school showing the events of a Sunday detention. Its believable as the customs are what American teenagers in the 80s would of worn along with the school which is realistic.

Social Realism – How films show how someone’s environment can change the development of the character. Emphasises the relationship between someone’s identity and there location.

This is England, shows how the current social state of England influences people into believing things that are against their morals. We see that the national front changes how Shaun sees people.

Magic Realism– This shows magical events as a normal world event, where characters accept it as a part of their life.

In harry potter Magic Realism is used to create the story line, showing that characters have magic as part of their daily life. This is used showing it in a school setting which is apart of the ordinary world.

Hyperreality – Anything that seems so real , and perhaps impossible to separate from reality.

In the Barbie Movie, the world they live in is supposed to be perfect showing how everyone can live happily carefree. The use of bright pink plastic materials and deliberately fake items shows the hyperreality to differentiate from the real world.

Visual Style

Visual style is the look or the feel of the film.

Task 2 – find definitions for the following:

Iconography – The use of a recurring symbol or image’s that can covey themes, evoke emotions or build a films identity.

In the Hunger Games it uses symbols to build up the character’s ideas and there personality’s. With the mocking jay noise and symbol becoming iconic to the movie.

Intertextual Referencing – When a movie uses ideas from a text or another piece of art.

In Shrek, it refences over popular child stories such as fairy god mother and three blind mice. This helps link the fairy-tale idea of Shrek to over movies.

Visual/ Sound motifs– A motif is a recurring story element that can highlight a moment happening in a movie.

In the movie UP a instrumental plays while showing carl and Ellies life , It also plays at the end when carl has found happiness. This music acts motif to show a important moment.

Colour Grading– Editing that creates a consistent tone of colour throughout the movie.

In the joker movie the overall tones are grey showing the depressing world that he lives is reflected in the colours.

Auteur Trademarks-A reference (e.g. to an object, a character, or a happening)

Wes Anderson has a trademark style with bright style and symmetrical shots. This makes his work easy to spot.

Task 3 – find definitions for the following:

Pathos-Pathos is a technique that seeks ton appeal to the audiences emotions, this is often used as sadness to have a emotional impact to the spectator.

In the movie the dogs purpose it shows the dog and its owner reuniting multiple times in the movie sparking emotion in the movie.

Suspense- A anxious uncertainly about what may happen.

In this scene in the shining the music, atmosphere builds tension on what way happens next.

Comedy– A genre of film which aims to amuse the audience.

In the movie home alone it makes the boy in the story try and fool the robbers creating a funny situation out of a what might have been a serious situation.

Dramatic Irony-Where the audience is aware of something that the characters aren’t.

We are aware that Truman is being filmed, however he doesn’t creating dramatic irony throughout the film.

Distancing Effect – Where the director purposing makes the story seem unbelievable, such as having a unfinished set or the character constantly talk to the camera.

In fleabag she often speaks to the camera, throughout the movie this pulls away from the believability that your watching a movie.

Postmodern Humour– Dark humour that is often about society.

Representations

All aspects of film form including narrative contribute to the representations of cultures and societies (gender, ethnicity and age) including the ideological nature of those representations

PERFORMANCE- Age, Ethnicity, wardrobe, Facial expressions, body language and reactions.

STEREOTYPE– a widely held but fixed and oversimplified image or idea of a particular type of person or thing.

COUNTERTYPE– A representation that actively seeks to subvert and challenge negative stereotypes usually of a person, group or place.

SARAH CONNNOR REPRESENTATIONS

In terminator one Sarah Connor started off as a small town “girl next door” archetype who works as a waitress. Sarah is represented as a ditsy girl who had no interest in being a waitress. Sarah’s character represents the dominant ideology of female characters in Hollywood.

In terminator 2 Sarah’s character does a complete 180 turning into a soldier almost. Sarah is spotted with many assault rifles and adorning big muscular arms. The clothing she is wearing is not showing cleavage which would usually be expected in a 90s action thriller. Sarah’s character has taken on more male characteristics like smoking a cigarette and wearing a pair of sleek sunglasses. The director James Cameron has evolved the character of Sarah Connor to be able to carry out her purpose as a fighter.

TRAINSPOTTING REPRESENTATIONS

1.WHO IS DOING THE REPRESENTATION? (DIRECTOR’S VIEWPOINT) DANNY BOYLE (DIRECTOR)

2.WHO IS BEING REPRESENTED ? (Identify specific social groups) The middle to lower class groups of Scotland who have been affected by heroin use directly or indirectly.

3.WHAT SOCIAL GROUPS ARE OMITTED FROM THE REPRESENTATIONS?- The upper class of Scotland and England. Young teenagers and children

4.WHAT MESSAGES ABOUT PARTICULAR SOCIAL GROUPS ARE BEING CONVEYED?- Tells the audience how lower class communities are affected by drug abuse and crime

5.WHICH CHARACTERS OR SOCIAL GROUPS HAVE POWER WITHIN THE REPRESENTATIONS? arguably the women. Lizzie broke up with tommy which lead him to heroin addiction. Diane coerced Mark into a illegal relationship despite only being 15. Gail denies spud sex because of an article in cosmopolitan.

6.DO THE CHARACTERS ADHERE TO OR CHALLENGE STEREOTYPES? characters like Renton challenge stereotypes with his commentary on gender and society adhering to neither male or female stereotypes

7.ARE THE CHARACTERS TYPICAL OF FILMS IN THAT GENRE?– The characters in Trainspotting break many stereotypes that are attached them, including sexual stereotypes and philosophical stereotypes and manage to show the audience that they do not think as people who are products of their environments, but as people who yearn for more outside of Scotland.

8.WHAT DO REPRESENTATIONS TELL AUDIENCES ABOUT SOCIETY AT THE TIME THE FILM WAS MADE AND/OR SET?

GENDER– Trainspotting has a unique take on gender expression throughout the film. Mark Renton quotes “1000 years from now there will be no guys and no girls, just wankers. Sounds great to me.” Mark Renton is so deep into his addiction that his ideas on gender and how society is changing could be an example of the haze that addiction has put him in. Most of the women in this film are more authoritative than the men, with the exception of Allison who was not level-headed due to her addiction.

DRUGS– Drugs on this film are represented though the middle to lower class, this is a direct reference to the Thatcherism that created a generational legacy of destruction and drug use that is still effecting Scotland today. In the film Renton says  ‘There was no such thing as society. Even if there was, I most certainly had nothing to do with it.’ Margaret Thatcher made a similar sentiment in 1987 saying ‘they are casting their problems on society and who is society? There is no such thing! There are individual men and women and there are families, and no government can do anything except through people and people look to themselves first.’ Renton indirectly quoting Thatcher shows the effect her policies had on the working class. The claim that there “is no society” is the same attitude that creates drug epidemics in the first place by making people believe that there is no place for them. In trainspotting addiction isn’t just about drugs, these men use drugs to fill a void of the empty and decrepit society they see around them, an emotional result of decades worth of corrupt politics.

SCOTLAND AND ENGLAND– When Trainspotting was released, Scotland’s is represented as a gritty location rather than a place full of Scottish history and culture. Because of this, us as the audience see a more realistic and current representation of Scottish people in the 1980s. A lot of slangs, Scottish dialect and even hints of Football culture is used/shown throughout the film that helped solidify the culture of Scotland. England or more specifically London was shown as a place of consumerism and new culture. Mark Renton got a new higher paying job selling over-priced apartments to young yuppies in London, showing the difference between the economic and class structure in England and Scotland. Mark Renton also experiences the new culture of electronic music, compared to the Iggy Pop era he was in whilst living in Edinburgh showing that Edinburgh was not as progressive as London was.

SEXUALITY – Sexuality is represented through the use of heroin. All the male characters do not have regular girlfriends apart from Tommy. When Tommy and his girlfriend break-up he subsequently gets hooked on Heroin creating a new damaging and lethal relationship. There is also a lot of female driven sexuality, we can see this through the character Diane who is only 15, but pursuing a sexual relationship with Renton.

AESTHETICS.

AESTHETIC DEFINITION.- the way a film’s visual and aural features are used to create essentially non-narrative dimensions of the film, including the film’s ‘look’. Aesthetics can be understand to relate to the style, tone, look or mood of a film

Social Realism- the realistic depiction in art of contemporary life, as a means of social or political comment.

Kneecap is a social realism film as it tackles the issue of sectarianism in the North of Ireland and the characters express their troubles and bio-logical trauma which stems from colonialism through music and self-expression, all while evading the police and R.R.A.D (radical republicans against drugs)

Verisimilitude- the appearance of being true or real.

I would class this film as having verisimilitude because of Gena Rowlands incredible portrait of an unstable bi-polar mother.

Magic Realism- Magical realism portrays fantastical events in an otherwise realistic tone.

Donnie Darko would be classed as magic realism. Donnie commonly converses with Frank a bunny who tells Donnie the date at which the world will end, Donnie believes this bunny is real, which classes this film as magic realism

Hyperreality-a condition in which what is real and what is fiction are seamlessly blended together so that there is no clear distinction between where one ends and the other begins.

Mulholland rive would fit into the hyperreality category as the watcher is not aware that the first half of this film is a dream and the second is reality.

AESTHETICS TERM 2-

•Iconography- the visual images and symbols used in a work of art or the study or interpretation of these. The film heavily evolves around dreams, what is real and what isn’t.

•Intertextual Referencing- the relationship between media products where one text references another text by reusing some its ideas and meanings.

I would class Almost Famous as intertextual referencing as many real-life bands including Lynyrd Skynyrd and the eagles are mentioned as if they belong in that world with the fictional band Still Water.

•Visual motif- commonly seen, repetitive symbol in a film

red roses are commonly used in American beauty to represent, love, lust, passion, murder, blood,

Sound motifs- commonly heard- repetitive sound in a film.

Gregorian chants are often heard at high tension points in the film as to make the spectator feel uneasy.

•Colour Grading- digital tools or photochemical processes are used to make videos or films look better or change the colour tone and mood

•Auteur Trademarks-An auteur is a director that has such a distinctive style of directing that they are considered the “author” because you can recognise their style from one clip- David Lynch as an example. A particular kind of irony where the very macabre and the very mundane combine in such a way as to reveal the former’s perpetual containment within the latter.” David Lynch has a very recognisable style of directing, as the topics he usually drifts to are on the subjects of dreams, mystery and alternate realities. He often uses the colour blue in his films.

PATHOS- a quality that evokes pity or sadness.

BATHOS- an effect of anti-climax created by an unintentional lapse in mood from the sublime to the trivial or ridiculous.

SUSPENSE- a state or feeling of excited or anxious uncertainty about what may happen.

COMEDY- film genre that emphasizes humor

DRAMATIC IRONY-  a literary device by which the audience’s or reader’s understanding of events or individuals in a work surpasses that of its characters.

VERFREMDUNG- The distancing effect, also translated as alienation effect is a concept in performing arts credited to German playwright Bertolt Brecht. Paul breaks the fourth wall talking to the audience

POSTMODERN HUMOUR- postmodern humor features jokes about serious topics like murder or war. By writing characters who make light of such topics, postmodernists highlight the dehumanization they see in their society.

Travis Bickle makes it his mission to “cleanse the filth” from New Yorks streets.

This Is England: Representation

Young people in This Is England play a big part in representing this time period in England, the youngest being Shaun who’s 12, along with Woody’s group who are all young adults. For the most part, they’re depicted to the spectator as being reckless, carefree, and unified by style.

Older people in the film have a range of roles, there’s Cynthia who is Shaun’s mother, she is caring and down to earth, and then there is Combo who has an authoritarian approach to keeping people close to him, instilling fear and nationalist propaganda onto others. The audience is shown that this heavily impacts Shaun, since Combo hones in on Shaun’s grief, weaponizing it so that Shaun becomes an asset to Combo’s gang.

The working class is the prominent class in This Is England, this is important to the spectator because it signifies how Margaret Thatcher’s time in parliament wasn’t taken lightly by those in the working class, as shown multiple times with graffiti.

English people are only represented by those from the North of England, in depth, the only time we ever see Southern citizens is on news broadcasts about those in power, like Margaret Thatcher and the Royal Family. This indicates to the audience that it is a common occurrence that the South have an overpowering hold on the North, along with classism against northern England.

Asian and Black people are depicted in a bad light whenever Combo has something to say about it, casual racism is a common occurrence throughout the film, for example, when Combo first visits Woody and the others to tell them a story about his time in prison, openly discriminating a black inmate whilst Milky is in the room (a Jamaican man). Asian people are portrayed as “job stealers”, according to Combo, as well as being verbally abused and taken advantage of in the scene where Shaun and Combo’s gang raid Sandhu’s shop.

Aesthetics

Aesthetics: The overall style, feel, and texture of a film. This can involve scenery, costume, and how they all tie in

Realism:  an artistic approach and narrative style that aims to represent life, characters, settings, and events as closely as possible to their real-world counterparts.

verisimilitude – the appearance of being real or true (in terms of world building and costume design)

Creep, 2014 (Patrick Brice)

social realism – drawing attention to the social and political conditions (issues) of a particular time period and location.

Interview With The Vampire, 2022 (Rolin Jones)

magic realism – portrays fantastical events in a realistic tone to successfully build a believable world for the spectator.

Pan’s Labyrinth, 2006 (Guillermo del Toro)

hyperreality – artificially created media that is perceived to be reality, a heightened reality.

Hannibal, 2013-2015 (Bryan Fuller)

Visual Style: The visual language of a film, the look and feel of the film.

iconography – the use of reoccurring visual images and symbols that convey specific themes, evoke emotions, and build the film’s narrative.

The Silence of The Lambs, 1991 (Jonathan Demme)

intertextual referencing – the overlap of media, utilised to support the narrative of the film. The media could be other films, music, poetry, and literature.

Lolita, 1997 (Adrian Lyne)

visual/sound motifs – a visible or audible element that reoccurs throughout the film to carry the storyline, plays a symbolic role.

The Substance, 2024 (Coralie Fargeat)

colour grading -a post-production process to alter the visual appearance of the film/shot. This can either be to make it more vibrant to convey a lighter, happier narrative, or it could be desaturated to convey dullness or negativity.

Barbarian, 2022 (Zach Cregger)

auteur trademarks – a trademark style, making a directors work immediately recognisable.

Lost Highway, 1997 (David Lynch) – surrealism

Tone: The overall atmosphere or mood of a film.

pathos – appeals to the audience’s emotions, typically sadness.

Uptown Girls, 2003, (Boaz Yakin): This scene is sad because of Ray’s angry display of grief alongside Molly’s bittersweet nostalgia as she recreates the moment she did years ago when her dad passed – mirroring Ray’s situation.

bathos – an anti-climax or a juxtaposition of shots to create a humorous effect.

Contact, 1997 (Robert Zemeckis): Instead of ending in Eleanor finally making contact with the aliens like the audience was lead to believe, the alien takes form of her deceased father to pass on a message.

suspense – excitement or anxiousness created by tension.

Black Swan, 2010 (Darren Aronofsky)

Suspenseful because it’s a Darren Aronofsky film; paranoia, perfectionism, and horror.

comedy – provides the audience with amusement, usually consisting of explicit one-liners, or on the other hand, intellectual pieces which are implicitly/unintentionally ‘funny’.

Interview With The Vampire, 2022-present (Rolin Jones)

For context, this episode is particularly funny because in the image on the left, Lestat is reassuring Louis (out of frame) that he is free to sleep with whoever he wants as long as Louis comes home to him. Image 2 completely contradicts Lestat’s plethora of “Of course! Of course!”, Louis comes home after having relations with another man, Lestat is clearly not that calm nor collected. There’s 15 minutes between these scenes.

dramatic irony – when the audience understands more about a situation that most characters do; an ‘inside joke’.

The Truman Show, 1998 (Peter Weir)

distancing effect – also known as ‘breaking the fourth wall’, is when the illusion of being an unseen spectator is shattered, the characters on screen are directly interacting with the audience.

Fleabag, 2016-2019 (Harry Bradbeer)

postmodern humour – Challenges accepted notions and expectations of genre, philosophy, and humanity.

Twin Peaks, 1990 (David Lynch) – 02×01