Essay Question
Here were some potential essay questions which I came up with:
In what way are the work of … and Lewis Baltz influenced by the change in Architectural Styles?
How has the New Topographics exhibition influenced contemporary photography?
How have the changes in Architectural Styles been documented through Photography?
To what extent was Lewis Baltz and the aesthetics of New Topographics a reaction to Ansel Adams and Romanticism/ classic landscape photography?
How is photography influenced by the changing styles in architecture?
I ended up settling for this question:
How have Historical Periods of Time influenced Architectural Changes and therefore Photographic Styles?
Essay Plan
Introduction (250-500 words): What is your area of study? Which artists will you be analysing and why? How will you be responding to their work and essay question?
For this essay, I would like to explore the link between different periods of time/social events and their outcomes. An example of this would be romanticism. Romanticism was a reaction to the age of enlightenment and people began to explore the beauty of nature, emotion and life. I would like to then link the new topographic as it was a reaction to romanticism and showed the new reality of an industrial/modern world.
Pg 1 (500 words): Historical/ theoretical context within art, photography and visual culture relevant to your area of study. Make links to art movements/ isms and some of the methods employed by critics and historian.
For this paragraph, I would like to write about Romanticism and what it is/what it was a reaction to. I will link this to how it saw changes in architectural styles and in photography. I will also write a bit about Ansel Adams as he was a key photographer who was associated with this movement.
Pg 2 (500 words): Analyse first artist/photographer in relation to your essay question. Present and evaluate your own images and responses.
For this paragraph, I would like to move on to talking about the New Topographics Exhibition and how it was a reaction to Romanticism and classic landscape photography. I would also like to refer to how it proposed a new way of thinking about landscape, place and environment with a focus on urban/ modern architecture. Furthermore, I will also refer to a photographer who was part of the new topographic exhibition, potentially Lewis Baltz.
Pg 3 (500 words): Analyse second artist/photographer in relation to your essay question. Present and evaluate your own images and responses.
For this paragraph I would like to interpret/analyse the work of Bernd & Hilla Becher and their formation of the Typology as a new aesthetics style/ approach to photography. I am going to use interview texts as a source of information for this, specifically an interview with Jean-Francois Chevrier, James Lingwood and Thomas Struth. I will link this change in photographic styles to the fact that they were influenced by the increasingly industrial environment at the time.
Conclusion (250-500 words): Draw parallels, explore differences/ similarities between artists/photographers and that of your own work that you have produced
I will conclude this essay by linking back the essay question and exploring the things I had previously spoken about and how they are relevant to the question.
Essay Draft
This is the first draft of my essay, before I made any final changes/adjustments.
Question: How have Historical Periods of Time influenced Architectural Changes and therefore Photographic Styles?
Intro
Photography is a way of preserving the world around you. It allows you to capture a moment of time and freeze it. This is significant as the world we live in is ever-changing. The world changes due to different movements and events. For example, the Climate Movement has caused people to be more considerate of the environment and, as a result, produce sustainable and energy efficient buildings. People also use Photography as a way of promoting that change is needed. Similarly, the Romanticism movement, an artistic and intellectual movement during the Industrial Revolution, influenced Architects and Artists to use nature as an inspiration for their designs. As we can see, there is a tie between social activities and world development. In photography, The New Topographics Exhibition was a reaction to the Romanticism movement and idealised landscape photography. Lewis Baltz, a photographer who was associated with this exhibition, explored the beauty within the realistic, industrial environment at this time.
Paragraph 1
Romanticism, first used as a term for aesthetic, became an artistic and intellectual movement in Europe in the late 18th Century. This movement was a reaction against the age of Enlightenment. This was when emotion had been sucked from art and literature and people focused mainly on science and logic. Romanticism was introduced during the Industrial Revolution, a time in which places such as Europe and the US experienced change in economy to one dominated by industry and machinery. The upbringing of Romanticism was heavily influenced by the political and economic atmosphere at the time and people used it as an escape from the new reality. During the Age of Romanticism, people explored the beauty of nature, emotion and life, creating an idealised reality within art and literature. This period also experienced a change in architecture, returning to medieval styles. Architects would use nature as an inspiration for their intricate designs, whilst also prioritising emotion and individualism. Furthermore, Romanticism is still present to this day. It can be found in art, music, films, literature, photography and more. An example of this would be Ansel Adams.
Ansel Adams was a modern-day photographer who was said to have embraced Romanticism. He was known for capturing the beauty of the natural landscape in America. Ansel Adams was part of the Sierra club which was an organisation that worked to protect the environment from industrialisation. He would use his photographic portfolios of the areas as a way to try and convince the members of congress to turn the areas into national parks. After many failed attempts, Adams had success in creating the King’s Canyon National Park in 1940, after publishing a photo book which caught the attention of many people, including President Roosevelt.
Paragraph 2
‘The New Topographics: Photographs of a Man-Altered Landscape’ was a photographic exhibition which consisted of the work of 10 different photographers. These photographers included Lewis Baltz, Robert Adams and Bernd and Hilla Becher. The exhibition was hosted at the George Eastman Museum by William Jenkins in 1975. It consisted of 168 prints, mostly in black and white. These prints were of things such as streets, industrial sites, warehouses and suburban houses. This exhibition was a reaction against romanticism and the idealised landscape, particularly the work of Ansel Adams. Its purpose was to challenge these traditional landscapes of the untouched by documenting reality and the growing impacts of industrialisation. After the II World War, America experienced a large increase in their economy, resulting in mass production of buildings and industrial developments. These buildings were constructed for their function, rather than their appearance, leading to the introduction of modern architectural styles and less detailed/aesthetically pleasing buildings. Although the photographers involved in The New Topographics simply displayed their everyday surroundings, the exhibition experienced a range of opinions. Many people felt responsibility towards the future of America’s landscape. This is suggested by the quote “I don’t like to think there are ugly streets in America, but when it’s shown to you – without beautification – maybe it tells you how much more we need here”. People were left feeling off-put with the representation of the American Landscape this exhibition displayed, making it one of the most groundbreaking exhibitions of the 20th Century as it completely rewrote the rules of Landscape Photography. This exhibition displayed settings which were often hidden from the camera, settings where the impacts of man-kind are evident. It proved that landscape photography can be more than just photographing the beautiful natural scenery and that it can also be capturing the ‘unattractive’ built environment.
Lewis Baltz, a crucial photographer of The New Topographics Exhibition, focused his work on searching for the beauty in bleakness. In an interview with Mr Witkovsky, Baltz stated that there’s an implied human presence in his work. There are traces of people but an absence of their physical presence. This is due to the fact that the subject of his photographs is the man-made environment. Baltz would capture stark images of the suburban landscape, revealing the impacts of urbanisation and mass construction. His photographs, displayed in black and white,
Paragraph 3
Bernd and Hilla Becher were another two photographers who were part of The New Topographics exhibition. They are best known for their method named the ‘typology’. In Carl Andre’s notes on Bernd and Hilla Becher, he stated that a ‘typology’ is simply ‘grouping similar views of different structures built to serve the same purpose’. This is evident in the image below.
This is a Typology consisting of 24 blast furnaces. These images were taken between 1969 and 1995. The blast furnaces are from locations all over the world and each have distinct features, however, they all were made for the same utilitarian function.
Previous to meeting Hilla, Bernd would produce paintings and lithographs of industrial structures. He would make these paintings from photographs, however, he soon discovered that he preferred taking the photographs than he did painting them. His interest in photography advanced and he found himself collecting old photographs of industrial structures so that he could later capture them himself. He would take these images using a step ladder to avoid optical distortion. After meeting Hilla, she too became fascinated by photography and Bernd’s ideas. She soon left her job in advertising to help him. The couple would travel together and make families of objects that they discovered in their path so that they could later create a typology. From 1961 to 1965, they worked mostly in the German Ruhr district which is known as the largest Urban area in Germany and the third largest in Europe. The pair had immense interest in the fact that the industrial world would one day disappear. This is why they photographed it as they wanted to fix it. They wanted to make sure that their typologies were able to describe the structures visually so that people can read the photographs and not need to visit them as they would be unable to, due to them no longer existing. They would consider their projects as finished once the structures had been destroyed. Additionally, in an interview with Jean-Francois Chevrier, James Lingwood and Thomas Struth, Hilla expressed that industrial structures are ‘nomadic forms of architecture’ and that they ‘come and go like nature’. Here, she is emphasising that these structures are only temporary and will be built or replaced depending on the need for them, alike nature’s lifecycle. I find this reference to nature very interesting as there is a huge contrast between the industrial and natural world in the sense that the natural world is completely organic and untouched and the industrial world is a man-made environment which is proven to be destructive to the natural environment. In this same interview, Bernd later made another reference to nature. He claimed that ‘all these objects that are linked to industrialization are disappearing. As in the world of nature, they consume each other.’ By this, Bernd is referring to the fact that industrial objects are constantly superseded by newer, better models, alike the food chain in nature. He also stated that, the fact there is no aesthetic thinking behind the architecture for industrial structures, it proves that people are only concerned with the idea of making money fast and efficiently. These structures are not built to last or to leave an impact as they will soon be replaced. Furthermore, the couple believed that photography should be used to describe and document things which is what they did in their work as they used their typologies to document industrial architecture and emphasize its nature, function and aesthetics.
Overall, Bernd and Hilla’s fascination in the industrial environment resulted in the upcoming of a new photographic technique, the Typology.
Conclusion
Link all together
Literary Sources/Bibliography
https://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/roma/hd_roma.htm
https://www.britannica.com/event/Industrial-Revolution
https://www.britannica.com/art/Romanticism
https://www.tate.org.uk/art/art-terms/n/new-topographics
https://www.artspace.com/magazine/art_101/book_report/phaidon-art-in-time-new-topographics-54444
https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2010/feb/08/new-topographics-photographs-american-landscapes
https://smarthistory.org/new-topographics
Carle Andre – A Note on Bernhard and Hilla Becher (1972)
Bernd and Hilla Becher – Conversation with Jean-Francios Chevrier, James Lingwood and Thomas Struth (1989)
https://socks-studio.com/2015/10/16/absence-of-style-lewis-baltz-and-the-new-topographics/
https://emilyallenphotographyblog.blogspot.com/2016/11/the-new-topographics.html
https://www.icp.org/browse/archive/constituents/lewis-baltz?all/all/all/all/0
https://www.guggenheim.org/artwork/artist/lewis-baltz