comparison and evaluation

My first response to romanticism landscape was inspired by Ansel Adams and his work. I have previously done an analysis of his work which gave me an idea as well as inspiration to explore his way of making images.

my image
“Clearing Winter Storm, Yosemite National Park,” by Ansel Adams, about 1937.
“Clearing Winter Storm, Yosemite National Park,” by Ansel Adams, about 1937

Comparing my image inspired by him to his own work, I think what is a big resemblance is the exposure of the image and the amount of darkness to brightness. his photograph has a much larger area of the clouds, this also means that area is lighter in relation to the rest of the components in the photograph. regarding my photograph I have very small amount of clouds shown, this is because in order to show as much land as well as different plans like the trees nearest to me, from the area that I was standing in I had to compromise on what to and how to point the camera to capture what I wanted. because Ansel Adams photographs much bigger areas he is able to shoot the desired photograph from further away and be able to get a lot in the frame as well as a big area of clouds, as I was limited to much smaller areas in jersey photographing a larger area of the sky could mean I may loose detail I wanted in the frame. a similarity between his and my image is that he also has layers in his image where he has a first plan, second , maybe even more , background etc. the object nearest to the camera, like the 2 trees in the bottom right corner are much darker, being a pure black likewise like my own photograph, where the trees nearest to me are also a pure black , however what is different is that they are much bigger and therefore the larger surface area is black.

How to Use the Zone System in Photography | PetaPixel

The trees near to me in the photograph frame the image whereas his is more open as in his photograph there aren’t any objects close to the camera on the sides of the photo. this could be good and bad, depending on the viewer as framing an image may result in capturing less of the desired landscape, it will also make the landscape look less open , which when photographing an area which is already beautiful may take away its value as then there’s less of that landscape area visible. But this framing may also mean the photograph gives more of a personal value as then it feels more like the viewer is in it , it may seem more realistic. I picked this image out of a couple of my final images to analyse, where I also have an image of the same view without the trees in the first plan, however although that image is also a good photograph , it doesn’t have that personal value to me and the frame that the trees created to me make it much more interesting as there are more detail in the photograph and they also balance the bright and dark areas as the rest of the landscape and clouds are quite bright whereas this frame contrasts with this as it is very dark and to me creates more of a sublime photograph.

Photograph without the framing caused by trees

With the above image I wanted to represent a different tone to black and white photography which meant adding a different filter on the image and working from that with exposure brightness etc. This image does a good job at representing a vintage photography style, however I felt like the fist analysis image had more in comparison to Ansel Adams works. although the style of the above image interest me and although it was firstly inspired by Ansel and it doesn’t have to look exactly like his work, I found the other images more interesting to analyse fully.

Another similarity between mine and his photograph is that he has a small area, in contrast with the rest of the photograph , of pure white which is the lightest colour he can achieve. This white can be visible on top of the mountains he photographed. The snow and a bit in some clouds are his lightest points whereas my photograph also has a small area of pure white but it can be seen in the water, when waves crash onto the shore and similarly in the sky and clouds. To me the amount of brightness in the photo is very similar to Ansel Adams photograph . however his white usually pairs up with a darker shade that the rocks on the mountain have making it look much more dramatic and make the white stand out more whereas mine blends in with the shade of the sand.

As a whole I have enjoyed exploring his style and although his landscape locations are much more fascinating and interesting then the ones I am capable of capturing right now, the style of his work like the enhancement of the shadows and dramatics of his images was very fun and different then what I’m used to edit. however what I should of payed more attention to was the colours that contrast each other, as with his work because of these opposite colours that are right next to each other, his photographs look so pronounced. 2 colours of completely different shaded being next to each other, quickly changing from one another, meaning they are not smooth or blended in, will make the image look sharp as a whole and this is why Ansel’s photographs look this conspicuous.

My photographs:

Ansel Adams’ Photographs:

urban landscape photography-Photoshoot plan

who, what, where, when, how, why

who: since this project is about urban landscape photography and new topographics, I will want to include some people in some of my shots, to add a natural feel to them. However, I will also take some photos without any people to create a deserted look in them. The people present will most likely all be natural, going abut the day and showing the ways they interact with the environment around them.

what: I will attempt to photograph an abandoned building surrounded by some nature to show the effects they have had on each other through the decades. I will also want to photograph different areas around town, such as older roads and buildings.

where: I will go around St. Helier to create some photos of the older and more modern structures around town. I will also find a more remote location including some kind of abandoned structure to photograph.

when: I will take a my photos at a range of different times to capture the effect light has on the environment, especially buildings. I will take some pictures at around noon when the day is brightest to capture detailed pictures of different buildings and some during the night using a slow shutter speed to photograph the dimly lit buildings.

how: I will use a tripod (especially when going out at night) to take the low exposure and slow shutter speed photos. I will also use a range of techniques such as exposure bracketing to create a wide range of photos with different exposures.

why: I think this way will be a good way of taking photos that capture the industrial landscapes we have in Jersey. The dramatic weather and different times will create a interesting selection of images.

Urban, industrial and typographic landscapes

Urban Landscapes

Urban landscapes – complex structures that are the result of the interaction between humans and the environment. It also involves a social, cultural and economic dimensions. Urban landscapes are formed and shaped, mainly under the influence of human activity’s.

Examples of urban landscapes:

Urban Landscape: Reading Nature from Big to Small Scales – The Nature of  Cities
Urban Landscape Photography
6 Tips For Capturing Better Urban Landscapes

Industrial Landscapes

Industrial landscapes – are typical areas where industrial activities are very intense, such as factories.

Examples of industrial landscapes:

Why the industrial landscape? — Mechanical Landscapes
Why Is the Revitalization of Industrial Landscapes so Popular?
INDUSTRIAL LANDSCAPES 01 on Behance

Topography

Topography – the study of the forms and features of land surfaces. The topography of an area may refer to the land forms and features themselves, or a description or depiction in maps.

Examples of topography:

Is New Topographics still relevant in 2020? — Andy Feltham Photography
New Topographics (Redux) : The Picture Show : NPR
Photographs of a Man-Altered Landscape - Pellicola Magazine

Urban/ industrial Landscapes and new topographics

Urban/ Indistrial Landscapes are images that bear witness to major human works, ranging from factories to quarries, or enormous mining complexes and abandoned zones. They carry the reader into inaccessible and little-known areas, between sublime and disarray, to witness the imposing reality of industry that we try now to erase. The result of humans let into nature, has ended up in a physical, social and cultural reality, which is reflected in the landscapes through specific architectures and iconic elements; showing the impact humans have had on nature.

New Topographics was a term thought up by William Jenkins in 1975 to describe a group of American photographers (such as Robert Adams and Lewis Baltz). These were photographers who criticised romantic photography, as they believed human impact on our landscapes shouldn’t be ignored. The photos these artists took mostly consisted of a repeated banal aesthetic, in that they were formal, mostly black and white prints of the urban landscape. They were people who found a sense of beauty in the disruption causes by repetitive and conventional architecture placed in nature.

On the other hand, “New Topographics: Photographs of a Man-Altered Landscape” was a ground-breaking exhibition of contemporary landscape photography held at the George Eastman House’s International Museum of Photography from October 1975 to February 1976.

New Topographics Photography

All of these artists combine nature and architecture/ human impact on the world in their photography, creating a whole new concept of landscape photography.

The first picture (top left) is a photo capturing a estate of mobile homes in an empty piece of land. The background consists of a looming mountain over towering the homes, the smooth shape of it contrasting with the blocky appearances of the houses. The nature and industrial landscape, present in the photo, clash- Adams promoting the idea of new topographics by showing us this mixed landscape and the reality of our world.

The second picture (top right) consists of a blocky box shaped building- creating an interesting photograph of a usually seen as unappealing location. Baltz included some of the silky sky to contrast with the roughly shaped architecture built on the ground below it. The solid strip of paint across the building further adds to the industrial shape of the building.

The third picture (bottom left) presents a empty parking lot surrounded by some boxy structures. The background consists of a mountain almost hidden in the fog, contrasting with the industrial foreground. I think Gohlke tried to create an idea of isolation and loneliness in the photo, creating a photo presenting a deserted parking lot contrasting with the soaring mountain peaking over the harsh edges of the buildings.

The fourth picture (bottom right) is a photograph of a seemingly abandoned house almost hidden in a thick forest of overgrown plants around it. I think Wessel tried to show that nature is more powerful than any architecture that we create, and is immortal in a sense.

New topographics

Topography is the study of the forms and features of land surfaces. The word topography comes from the greek word “topo,” which means place, and “graphia,” which means to write or to record. Which in photography, would mean taking pictures of places i.e. landscapes.

New topographics refers to a term coined by William Jenkins in 1975 to describe a group of American photographers (such as Robert Adams and Lewis Baltz) whose pictures had a similar banal aesthetic, in that they were formal, mostly black and white prints of the urban landscape. New topographic photographs would consist of man-altered landscapes which include both natural and man-made aspects.

Here are some examples:

New Topographics | Frieze
Robert Adams
Mobile homes, Jefferson County, Colorado, (1973)
New Topographics (Redux) : The Picture Show : NPR
Frank Gohlke
Landscape, Los Angeles, 1974
New Topographics (article) | Khan Academy
Robert Adams
Tract house, Boulder County, Colorado, 1973
Robert Adams | Fraenkel Gallery
Robert Adams
New housing. North Denver, Colorado, 1973

As you can see, most of these photographs were created by Robert Adams. This is because he was partially responsible for the creation of new topographics.

What was the new topographics a reaction to?

It reflects how the world has become increasingly suburbanised and the collaboration of both man-made and natural aspects in a landscape. New topographics is considered a reaction to the tyranny of idealized landscape photography that elevated the natural and elemental.

Mood-board

exposure bracketing

Exposure bracketing is a technique used to create a HDR (high dynamic range) photo at the end of a shoot.

It is used in low lighting, and done by taking around three of the same images, but with different exposures in each. One over, one under and one normally exposed.

What is Exposure Bracketing?

I experimented with this one my shoot as the light was low.

This meant I could use the photo with the best light, and determine how to edit my final image.

Ansel Adams

Ansel Adams was born February 20, 1902, San Francisco, United States and passed away April 22, 1984. He was an American landscape photographer and was known for his black-and-white images of the American West (Grand Canyon in Arizona and, his favourite, Yosemite National Park). Distinguished by extraordinary clarity and profundity, his photographs are amongst the most recognizable images in the world, reprinted in numerous magazines, journals, and wallpapers. Since an early age Ansel had shown some interest in spending majority of his time outdoors considering he was home schooled. Until he was eighteen years old he considered himself a musician, but later swapped his career in music with photography.

The morning of April 10th, 1927, Ansel Adams set out along Yosemite’s LeConte Gully to capture an image of the striking sheer face of Half Dome, one of Yosemite National Park’s most iconic natural features

When the group reached the Diving Board, a steep outcropping more than 3,500 feet above Yosemite Valley, Ansel knew this was the perfect vista from which to capture Half Dome’s sheer face. The photograph he made, “Monolith, the Face of Half Dome,” shows the mountain rising from an ink-black sky, its face illuminated by a dazzling midday sun just out of frame. 

Group f/64

The group’s name (Group f/64) derives from a small aperture setting on a large format camera, which secures great depth of field and renders a photograph evenly sharp from foreground to background.

During the Great Depression, the citizens of America looked towards the West and the opportunities it offered, particularly through massive public works projects. This is why it was important for individuals like Ansel AdamsImogen CunninghamEdward WestonWillard Van DykeHenry SwiftJohn Paul EdwardsBrett WestonConsuelo KanagaAlma LavensonSonya Noskowiak, and Preston Holder, who were the original f64 group members, to present it to the rest of the country in the most realistic, revealing way.

Edward Weston

From 1934 through to 1948 Edward Weston explored his favourite subject matter which contained natural forms, landscape, nudes and people.

The Sublime – Andalucía

Spanish Autonomous Region of Andalucía (My location displayed by red dot – near Málaga)

During our half-term break, I spent my week down in the Spanish region of Andalucía, photographing the gorgeous natural landscapes around the nearby towns I visited. I planned each day around where I could take photos for my landscape project, such as travelling to cities such as Torremolinos, travelling to rural towns including Guaro and central Coín, and just walking through the area.

I ended up with over 2,000 photographs by the end of my trip, varying from urban landscapes to features of typical romanticism, at different times of day and multiple angles.

I flagged the images I wanted to keep, and colour-coded each photo with their potential value for editing. I also gave each one a star rating out of five, for how good they were as a composition.

I edited 20 images overall, a few in the dramatic, monochrome style of Ansel Adams, and the rest in a style that brings out the natural beauty of the photograph.

When it came to making these images, I wanted to adapt Ansel Adams’ style into my work, but more loosely and modernised, especially with the issue of most of the local area being covered in roads, paths and more traces of civilisation, as opposed to Adams’ pristine natural landscapes, so I decided to replace his use of rivers to lead the viewer’s eyes across the image with the paths and roads I was walking across, creating a similar, but unique composition. When editing, I also had to make the decision of whether to desaturate the photographs into black and white, to mimic his style – to do this further I had to dehaze the image to imitate the dark, moody skies featured in his pieces thanks to the red lens filter he used. Although I did take a lot of photos at night, because of my inexperience with camera settings I wasn’t really able to get a good, clear image that wasn’t grainy, so I would need to improve on that for the future.