The prominent similarities between my work and the work of Naomi White and my work is the use of plastic in order to create art. Furthermore, the colours in both photographs are vibrant and the tones are very contrasting within both images. Finally, there is a strong sense of contrasting shadows and highlights due to the use of studio lighting.
On the other hand, there is also visible differences between the image created by White and my own work. For example, White only uses one colour in her photos, which creates a jarring contrast against the white background. However, because I used coloured acetate over the studio lights, multiple tones and colours are projected onto the plastic. Furthermore, my image lacks the blinding, white background that White uses in order to create an intense juxtaposition between the coloured plastic.
Overall, I believe my recreation of Naomi White’s work was successful because they carry similar ideas and messages, however I altered specific aspects of Naomi White’s work in order to make my images more unique and prove that White’s work is an ideal influence in terms of Anthropocene.
I wanted to edit my photos to explore new ideas and meanings. To create a story between humans and nature. For that I used photoshop. I decided to use different special effects like black and white, blur… For the first picture I used the lasso tool to select the middle after that I inversed to select only the outside part of the it . I choose to put the outside in black and white because I wanted to give an more sad atmosphere to it. I highlighted the objects to show the waste. For the second picture I decided to use the lasso tool again to have two parts one that is full of rubbish and the other that is clean. To create the part full of waste I cut out parts of chairs from another photos then I pasted them on my image. With these effects I want to show a side that we could have if we do not pay attention to what surrounds us. The two tests represent the waste that we live with. For the third one I decided to do something simpler I use a picture from my second shoot because it had more nature to it. I just use the blur tool to demonstrate the nature vanishing bit by bit.
Differences – The layout of both images is different as mine has a clear horizon that splits the image in the top middle thrid with a straight line, whereas Yao Lu’s is a horizon made from the mountain tops which is in the very top third. I also left most of the natural landscape in the image, however Lu covered all/most of the natural landscape with waste and netting. The colouring in Lu’s image is more muted and made of more neutral colours. Mine is muted but there is certain aspects, specifically the added waste piles where it is more graphic and vibrant. the overall style of Lu’s image is very painterly and delicate, but mine is more graphic and bold.
Similarities – Both images have the same concept of photo montaging waste in the form of the natural landscape. Both images are overall warmer toned. Also the images have been framed and cropped to be circular in the same way.
Evaluation
Even though the final outcomes I had planned in my head looked more like Yao Lu’s painterly photographs I am happy that the non-natural aspects of the image (the fishing abandoned equipment), are more graphic and contrast with the natural landscape that should be there. This gives the image more contrast physically and metaphorically in the sense that the earth is turning into a waste land because all these waste products that human kind have made and harmed the earth with are going to be the new reality as the natural landscapes are being damaged and slowly disappearing. therefore based on this I have clearly shown the theme of Anthropecene, how the earth is changing based on human error, through my series images.
Edited using duplicating layers, lowering opacity and altering tones
Edited using iris blur tool
Experimenting with landscapes
“Shipwrecked V” – Naomi White (2017)
To edit these images, I cut out sections of my plastic bag images with the magnetic lasso tool and pasted them onto sections of my landscape images from one of my previous projects. I also changed the hues of the colours and tones of the sections of plastic bag in order for it to fit better into the environment. I think these images look at Anthropocene in a more obvious and direct way, in the sense that nature is being replaced by artificial materials.
More abstract exploration
“Shipwrecked III” – Naomi White (2017)
To edit this image, I used the magnetic lasso tool to cut out shapes of the plastic bags, and layered them onto one layer.
First, I lowered the brightness of my image and increased the contrast in order to create a stronger contrast between the different colours and provide darker tones to the image.
I then altered the curves setting of the image to darken the shadows of the image, and to increase the brightness of the highlights within the photo.
I increased the hue of the image to a blue-tone to enhance the blue hues of the image. I also increased the saturation and decreased the lightness to make the colours more vibrant and contrasting.
To further bring out the blue and red tones of the image, I altered the colour balance to increase cyan-toned colours and magenta-toned colours. This makes both the blues and the reds more vibrant, creating a more juxtaposing contrast.
For my main piece, I am creating a photo manipulation to raise awareness about ocean pollution, so I need photos of :
– Rubbish – Fishing Gear (nets, buoys) – Underwater – The sea – The coastal headline – Boats – Rocks
I made a table to visually display all the photo shoots I need to do for my main piece.
ST BRELADES PHOTO SHOOT
I went to St Brelades in the evening when it was clear, and took photos at the end of the beach that the pier was at. Then moved towards Quasine. Firstly I took photos of the boats in the sand, then in the middle of the beach, I took photos of the sea with the horizon in. I plan to make that the surface of the sea in my final piece. After went to the rocky area, and took photos the larger rocks.
BOULEY BAY PHOTO SHOOT
I decided to get more photos, as I didn’t really like the lighting and the reflections of the sunset from the St Brelades photo shoot. Firstly, I started near the island to get photos of the rocks. Then I went to the end of the pier where I got another photo looking out to the sea. Then lots of photos of boats, and there was a man putting his boat into the sea, so I was able to get a clear picture of the bottom of the boat, which had some buoys on. Additionally, I got some pictures of sea gulls, which I could add into the sky. in Photoshop.
RUBBISH / PLASTIC PHOTO SHOOT
I took photos of various waste and plastic items, such as, plastic water bottles, plastic bags, crisp packets, and, cans. Nothing complicated, I positioned the subject in the centre of the frame, and for the items that had weight like plastic bags, I filled with air to make it look like it would be floating, so it would be easier to blend in Photoshop, and not look out of place.
SECOND PIECE PHOTO SHOOT / PLAN / (If I have spare time)
If I have spare time I plan to create a photo manipulation of space. For my photos I need :
– Galaxy – Foreground photo (white house in St Ouens) – Moon
GALAXY PHOTO SHOOT
I would need to go to a place where there is no light pollution. St Ouens would be a good place. I would need to bring a tripod and a camera. The camera settings would be at the lowest f-stop number, manual focus on the brightest star, wide angle lens (35mm), 800-3200 ISO, shutter speed is 25-30 seconds, but no longer as it would create star trails.
FOREGROUND (WHITE HOUSE) PHOTO SHOOT
I need a subject that would be the foreground, I chose the White house. I would need to go when there is natural light, so I went in the morning (10am) as there was good light and no people.
MOON PHOTO SHOOT
I chose to take photos when there was a full moon. I would use the same setup as the galaxy photo shoot, except the lens. I would use a 300mm lens the capture the moon, with a 1 second shutter speed.
Above are my final chosen and edited images. When beginning this project, my idea was to work with the idea of Marine Pollution. Marine pollution is a combination of chemicals and trash, most of which comes from land sources and is washed or blown into the ocean. This pollution results in damage to the environment, to the health of all organisms, and to economic structures worldwide. Instead of stating the obvious in my photographs, I wanted to create a metaphor within them. As stated in my action plan in a previous blog, I wanted to ask the question, ‘What if it was me?’ and most importantly, ‘What if it was you?’. The waste that was placed in these photographs does just represent the waste in the ocean, however, as you can see they are placed in different places around a home- and this represents the ocean, home to more, both discovered and undiscovered creatures, that live here with us on land. Our apathy towards waste and the ocean is leading not only invasion of their lives but also destruction. Not only do these photographs portray that metaphor, they also symbolise the circle of life. The bed represents sleep and rest. The plate represents nourishment, eating to stay alive and the bathtub represents health and hygiene. These are the 3 basic necessities of life. Another thing we are taking away.
Image 1 ‘Falsely Comfortable’
Image one is of my own bed at home- as also stated in an earlier post, it is one of my safe places that brings me comfort and relaxation. In the photograph, the duvet is pulled back, exposing a large amount of waste. This contradicts the idea of comfort. Not only that, it represents the fact that people ‘keep the cover on’- the majority of the population don’t think twice about the subject of ocean pollution. Even if they do, ‘making the bed’ take the thought back to the back of their head. Its time to pull the duvet back for good.
It was also stated by somebody that my image had similarities to an artwork called My Bed by Tracey Emin.
‘Still filthy, still repulsive, and still one of the most moving works of contemporary art, Tracey Emin’s My Bed, 1998 gave us a delicious glimpse into the lifestyle of a despairing 35-year old artist. The crumpled bed sheets still seemingly ooze with her bodily secretions, the blood stain from her period clearly visible to all onlookers’. She decided on this piece after a breakup, spending a week in bed. This particular display was very personal to her but at the same time was also very empowering- it shows the imperfection as well as means of mental health and how some experience it. Although a lot more graphic than my photograph, it is a messy bed, filled and surrounded by waste as is mine. It also represents a side that people do not often think about- for her this would mean depression, for my photograph it means marine pollution.
Image 2 ‘When’s Dessert?’
Image 2 at first glance is a dinner plate with plastic waste and a can on it, along with a metal knife and fork. This represents contamination of the ocean and the destruction of the food chain. Due to the pollution in the ocean, both chemical and plastic, many animals and fish are dying out. This alters the food chain, creating less food for some. The way the cutlery is placed on the plate symbolises that the person has finished eating- however the plate is still full and therefore they didn’t eat anything.
Image 3 ‘Self-care Routine’
The final photograph, Image 3 is a bathtub, only a few inches filled with waste floating around. The small amount of water represents the ocean and how many of us care about it. The amount of waste is large for the small amount of water which represents how big of an impact we are all making- and not in a positive way. Along with the other images it also symbolises one of the necessities of the circle of life- hygiene, water and health.
As for the colour choice, this was briefly mentioned but although it was partly for the aesthetic side, it shows the unatural side of polluting our oceans- its just something that should not be happening.
Using photoshop, I tested different ways in which I could present my images and at the same time figuring out which colour combinations worked best.
1
2
3
4
In example 1, I tried putting together the images with different hues. I didn’t particularly like this outcome- although the images were supposed to be messy it seemed like they were too messy and didn’t go well together. The image in the middle was too dim and overall it didn’t work. Example 2 did look better; the images were symmetrically lined up and the colour scheme matched although it felt too simple to me. When making example 3, I really liked the composition, it felt easier to look at all the images, and finally what came to mind is which of these holds the most importance? They are all important of course but some slightly more than the other. So I decided on the plate being the largest image, the bed being the middle and the bathtub being the smallest- overall I liked the final composition and presentation.
Photographer Comparison:
Brett Stanley:
Brett’s photographs are about how we blindly pollute the ocean on a daily basis as you can see in the image above. In my work, the concept is slightly different because in my photographs it is right in front of you, you aren’t doing it blindly, you just don’t care.
Jeremy Carroll:
The message conveyed through Jeremy Carroll’s work and mine is almost the same. Through their work they asked the question, what if it was you? My photographs did the same thing. This photographers work took more of a graphic, painful point of view- showing exactly what creatures of the ocean feel through the use of human models where as my message was portrayed in a calmer manor, where people are made to think about it some more. They way in which the photos were taken are very different, these here are portraits in a studio where as mine are more objects set in place using natural lighting.