CONTROLLED CONDITIONS Identity Case Studies

‘Claude Cahun, born Lucy Renee Mathilde Schwob, was a French lesbian photographer, sculptor and writer. Schwob adopted the pseudonym Claude Cahun in 1917 and is best known for self-portraits, in which Cahun assumed a variety of personae.’ As a gender neutral person, Claude created many artworks starting at 20 years old, up to her death in her 50’s. She used this artwork to express her identity- this being mostly gender identity. I would describe her work as fascinating and odd with a sense of deep meaning yet a bit of fun.

Claude Cahun, Self-Portrait #art #artist #artworld #portrait #portraiture  #photography #faces #checkers #fashio… | Portrait, Self portrait,  Surrealist photographers

Much of the artist’s work was destroyed following an arrest and subsequent imprisonment for resistance against the Nazis. This also meant that many of her found pieces were not dated or named.

“Here, Cahun presents herself as bold, androgynous, and doubled by a mirrored-reflection. The image is lush with textures and tones: the checkerboard jacket, highlighted hair, and smooth sun-kissed skin all make the image vivid with the abundance of life. Traditionally, the inclusion of a mirror in art was used as a convenient way to expose two enticing views of a female subject or, alternatively, as a way to emphasize a woman’s vanity. In this case however, the ‘real’ Cahun looks away from the mirror and engages with and meets the viewer’s gaze. Cahun rejects being typecast as a passive woman who is visually consumed by admiring herself. There is no sin of vanity at work here, and instead qualities of thoughtfulness, exploration, and self-assurance confront the viewer.” – Art historian Shelley Rice

See the source image

Claude Cahun was not the basic photographer of her time, she liked to explore different methods and tried many different things with her artworks, for example double exposure (as you can see above), photomontages and the use of masks and other props. In this image we see a dark backdrop- this makes Claude’s light skin pop, making her the only focus point. As it is only her head and shoulders in the photograph, it allows the viewers to focus on her facial expression and bold look. The way the two exposures have been also put together create a sense of symmetry in the image- even though there is not.

Lucas Simoes is an independent artist based in São Paulo, with a background in architecture and design. His experiences of training as an architect redefined his perceptions of art and opened new paths of discovery. He was born in 1980, whereas Cahun was born in 1894- this is almost a generation apart.

 His works explore the limits and unpredictability of behaviour of materials and the final results always spans between an act of research and a genuine art piece. I will be focusing on his photographic project called ‘Burns’ where he would print out photographs of people and create burns in the paper.

“To burn pictures, a way of physically erase a memory by burning it, so with time, the image that is burnt will disappear from your memory.
The pictures in that series are not mine, I took it from many different sources, and the coloured tag under it is my way of telling that the image is not original, but printed in a paper, it symbolises the “ink on paper”…

Every photograph we take represents a memory, one we can see clearer than our brains remember. In my project, this could represent how people are seen in memory/remembered- and how it varies and changes.

“Because personal and collective memories are so inextricably intertwined with photographs—the result of the medium’s progressive saturation of everyday life for the past century and a half—this revolutionary change in the production and dissemination of photographic images is altering society’s relationship to memory.” – https://www.eastman.org/matter-memory-photography-object-digital-age

He describes these photographs as memories which he is ‘burning away’. This work is different to Claude’s in the sense that hers shows confidence and almost self-discovery in some, whereas Lucas’s work represents the erasing of memories and pictures from someone’s mind. He also added strips of hot colour to his work which made the images pop- and Claude’s images consisted of high contrast which made her images pop in a different way to Lucas’s. Another difference between these two artists is that Claude would take self portraits- and Lucas took images of others that weren’t his.

Jesse Draxler is a mixed media and multidisciplinary artist, and his pieces combine painting, photography, collage, typography and digital painting. He also wrote a book in which he incorporated the first photograph below among many others. “Misophonia incorporates various mediums and styles from figurative painting and harsh typography to deliriously textural photography and collage. The book serves not only as a master collection of Draxler’s work throughout his career to date, but also as a living organism, in which each piece communicates with the others, the whole, and itself.”

The photographs above are the ones I will be focusing on. Draxler cut out sections of the same person at different angles and put them all together. With my project this could potentially represent the different angles and perspectives that people are seen by.

Identity and place

Identity is the fact of being who or what a person or thing is, which could include there surroundings, upbringing, gender, cultural, social identity, geographical identity, political identity as well as loss of identity. An example of this could be someones environment which they are surrendered by such as a coastal environment as it could impact them in several ways due to their surroundings.

Going ahead i’m going to take photos in relation to the mood board above as I feel the way the artists have disguised the faces to almost hide their identity, makes the photos have more depth and meaning to them. Furthermore I would also like to take photographs of peoples environment which they are surrounded by as I believe this adds to peoples identities.

IDENTITY – case study and comparison

Claude Cahun

Claude Cahun was a French lesbian photographer, sculptor and writer. She has attracted what amounts to a cult following among art historians and critics working from postmodern, feminist, and queer theoretical perspectives. She is most remembered for her highly staged self-portraits and tableaux that incorporated the visual aesthetics of surrealism. Many of Cahun’s portraits feature the artist looking directly at the viewer, head shaved, often revealing only head and shoulders (eliminating body from the view), and a blurring of gender indicators and behaviours. Cahun made work for herself and did not want to be famous. It wasn’t until 40 years after her death that her work became recognized. In many ways, Cahun’s life was marked by a sense of role reversal, and like many early queer pioneers, their public identity became a commentary upon the public’s notions of sexuality, gender, beauty, and logic. Her adoption of a gender neutral name and her androgynous self-portraits display a revolutionary way of thinking and creating, experimenting with the audience’s understanding of photography as a documentation of reality

Laia Abril

Abril takes photographs associated with eating disorders, rape, abortion and sexuality. Since 2010, Abril has been working on various projects exploring the subject of eating disorders. Abril is a thoughtful conceptualist who tells metaphorical stories about difficult subjects using a mixture of research and whatever raw material comes to hand: found photos, her own images, family photographs, personal testimonies, official archives, interviews and diaries. “There are so many stories,” says Abril, “and it was important to find ways of telling them visually. Her work typically studies hard , painful subjects that seem difficult to talk about.

Photographers Cahun and Abril both relate to the theme of identity. They send a strong message and address serious matters that should be publicly discussed and accepted. Both photographers express how people are worried about how others view you as a person. They both express sexuality in their work, Cahun’s work protested gender and sexual norms, Abril had a project that began with the intention of depicting notions of femininity of the young lesbian community in New York:

CC – Identity And Place

What is identity?

Identity is the qualities, beliefs, personality, looks and expressions that make a person or group of people. People categories others identity as positive or destructive. A psychological identity relates to self-image and self-esteem.

Identity can be manipulated by various ways, such as parental upbringing, friends, family, culture, work, place and environment, I plan to use this in my photography work, mainly within Photoshop.

Mood Board

Initial Ideas

My first idea is to take about 3-4 photos then line them up in Photoshop, them merge them together, each photo will have the subject doing different facial expressions displaying various emotions. The 2 photos at each end will be anger with 1 hand on the hand creating a sandwich type concept. Additionally, I may add other photos of there face into the image, like the image of the girl with the lipstick on in the mood board.

Another idea is to mask the face in Photoshop and detach it from the head and fill it in with a black area behind the floating face, it could have items coming from behind the face out of the head.

Next, I could have a blank face then edit the faces upside down or swap peoples faces.

I could have 5 blank faces all the same then add facial features on each face, like steps. It shows the process of building identity.

CASE STUDY on Claude Cahun

Claude Cahun, born 1894 and died in 1954 , was a French lesbian photographer, sculptor and writer. In 1917 Claude was best known for self-portraits. These portraits where photographed to show off the culture or identity of lesbian/gay people. As for it was frowned apron to be that type of person in that time, these images (portraits) that Claude took were strong, powerful images that were hated by some but loved but others. The torture that if people in around 1917 chose to be somebody different to what society wanted us to be like , people would be beaten up, tormented , or even killed.

MOOD BOARD –

Images by Claude Cahun
Claude Cahun: The trans artist years ahead of her time - BBC Culture
1921 – Claude Cahun

This image of Claude herself shows her transformation of a girl into a boy like style. As for the short hair and the no makeup look as well as the boy fleece. In 1921 when this image had been taken, it was a horrible era for gay/trans people as for it was so disgusted by others. This image shows a reflection of Claudes face in the mirror, this may indicate that she looks at herself as a boy/lesbian, even in her own reflection. She looks at the camera with a strong look in her eyes that she’s not disheartened of who she is , she seems to give off a sense that she is proud of who she is. This reflection in the mirror gives off two sides to her life as for her being born one way and identifying as another.

Identity and place – Claude Cahun study

Claude Cahun

Claude Cahun: The trans artist years ahead of her time - BBC Culture
A self-portrait by Claude Cahun (1928)

Claude Cahun was a French lesbian photographer born in 1894 in Nantes, France. Cahun’s birth name given to her was Renee Mathilde Schwob, however she changed her legal name to Claude Cahun in 1917. Cahun was most recognised for her activist work repelling gender norms. She moved to Jersey in 1937 with her partner, Marcel Moore (named at birth as Suzanne Malherbe). The couple became active as resistance workers and propagandists during the German occupation of Jersey and the other Channel Islands. Cahun and Moore would attend Germany military events and placed activist leaflets in the pockets of soldiers, on chairs and even hid them in cigarette boxes for soldiers to later discover. Cahun continued to take self portraits presenting herself in non-binary characteristics until her later life, although she did not want to be famous therefore didn’t gain recognition for her photography until she died in 1954, after se and Moore had been arrested and sentenced to death in 1944 due to their activist movements. However before their death sentence, Jersey was liberated in 1945, resulting in both of their releases although Cahun later died due to being poorly treated in prison. Claude Cahun’s writings were published in 2002, as she leaves behind her iconic legacy in the non-binary and LGBTQ community.

Analysis of Claude Cahun’s work

“I am in training, don’t kiss me” reads the enigmatic slogan on the artist’s jersey in this self-portrait (Credit: Jersey Heritage Collection)
I am in training don’t kiss me” – Claude Cahun (1927)

The lighting in the image is rather soft, as it creates subtle shadows which can be seen in the face and especially under the eyes. However the juxtaposition between light and dark is still very intense. This is shown in the clothing, makeup and hair, and how they create an extreme contrast in tone against Cahun’s fair skin. The main source of light appears to be coming from behind the camera, as the face is lit quite evenly.

There is no distinct use of line in this photograph, as there is neither a repetition of line of use of leading lines, which makes the composition more complex.

Similar to the use of line, there is no representation of repetition in this image, presumably to focus on the activist message of the composition of the image.

The majority of the shapes in the image are organic and curved. The only representation of artificial shapes is the rounded weight in the hands of Cahun.

It is difficult to recognise the depth of field in this image as the background is made up of purely empty space, therefore making it difficult to compare the focal point’s focus with the background.

Although texture is not the main focus for this image, the overall texture of the image is rather smooth as the shapes in the photograph are organic and curved. There is no representation of rough or jagged edges.

There is a range of tones from dark to light in this image. The darkest sections of the photograph can be seen in the hair, clothing and makeup of Claude Cahun aswell as the background. The lightest areas are found in Cahun’s fair skin tone and the white images on the weights in Cahun’s arms. The image, overall, tends towards darkness as the entire background and elements of the foreground prioritise darker tones.

There is no colours featured in this photograph as the photo was taken in 1927, and colour photography was only made accessible in the late 1930’s. However I believe the vintage greyscale appearance of the photo adds a sense of intimidation and courage.

The composition of this photograph is very artificial and purposely set up. In the photograph, Cahun dresses as a ‘strong man’ from a circus, in order to create controversy over the stereotypical woman being weak or insignificant. This would have been a risky and revolutionary protest for both women and the LGBTQ community as these groups had been oppressed for centuries, yet Cahun celebrates her differences and sexuality.

Examples of Claude Cahun’s work

Claude Cahun, Je Tends Les Bas, 1931, Courtesy and copyright Jersey  Heritage | East GalleryNUA
“I extend my arms” – Claude Cahun (1931)
“Untitled (Claude Cahun in Le Mystère d’Adam)” by Claude Cahun and Marcel Moore, 1929.
“Untitled” – Claude Cahun and Marcel Moore (1929)
“Que me veux-tu?” by Claude Cahun, 1928.
“Que me veux-tu?” – Claude Cahun (1928)

CONTROLLED CONDITIONS Identity Project Ideas + Mood Board

An aspect of the theme Identity that I would like to explore and express is that the way you see yourself, whether that’s physically or mentally, and how it differs from all the different ways that others may view you. Each and every person around you view you in a different way than you do yourself, they see other angles, have different memories of how you looked and acted. There are a variety of ways that this message can be conveyed through one or a few images. This can be linked to ‘body dysmorphia’ which is a mental disorder characterized by the obsessive idea that some aspect of one’s own body part or appearance is severely flawed and therefore warrants exceptional measures to hide or fix it (most of the time, only the person sees this flaw and others do not notice it to the extent that the person themselves does)

Approach idea 1: The use of mirrors, glass, plastic to create reflections and or distortions representing viewpoints and angles of how a person is seen or sees themselves.

Approach idea 2: Multi-exposure images to display multiple viewpoints similarly to my first idea.

identity

The definition of identity is who you are, the way you think about yourself, the way you are viewed by the world and the characteristics that define you. An example of identity is a person’s name . An example of identity are the traditional characteristics of an American. Identity has two important features: continuity and contrast. Continuity means that people can count on you to be the same person tomorrow as you are today. Obviously, people change but many important aspects of social identity remain relatively stable such as gender, surname, language and ethnicity. Your identity can be influenced by “place”, such as where you grew up. It is much easier to understand an individuals identity when you realize everyone is a product of their environment, that is why I think that “place” is the biggest influence that shapes your identity and who you are as a person.

Mood Board

Mind Map

Exploring Identity

Photographers that explore identity: Sam Contis, speaks to the idea of community and the social self. Andrzej Steinbach, Paul Mpagi Sepuya, Sofia Borges and Shilpa Gupta. Photographers that explore identity solely through portraiture: Kandara Enyeasi, Cedric Nzaka, Zarita Zevallos, Ussi’n Yala and Thompson S. Ekong.

Phillip Toledano’s series ‘Days With My Father’ follows his fathers life after his mother died and how he is coping living without her and dealing with the grief.

Sam Contis’ series “Deep Springs” speaks to the idea of community and the social self. Contis spent lengthy visits at a traditionally all-male liberal arts college in the high desert of California, a remote backdrop that contrasts starkly with the group mode of collegiate life. “Contis’ subjects are pictured at a moment in their lives – the early college years – that has been typically understood as a time of coming into one’s adult self,” said Gallun.  “In this case, such identity-formation is impacted by group social dynamics as well as connection to the characteristic western landscape.”

Zerita Zevallos focuses on the racial aspect of identity with her work. Her work is described as having ‘those unique characteristics of blending the ruthless reality and trauma Black folks go through on a daily basis, while capturing the attention of all gazes towards a narrative far too long ignored’.  Her visual composition is simplistic but powerful and elegant, all while using a model presenting a physique long rejected by Western social standards of beauty. I believe that her work, subject and concepts are elegant and so timelessly impactful.

Introduction to Identity

Definition of Identity

“the distinguishing character or personality of an individual”.

How an individual views themselves.

How others view an individual.

Identity can affect people in many different ways and each persons identity can be resultant on their upbringing due to the Tabula Rasa theory which states that individuals are born as a “blank slate” and the people that raise you and the culture of the environment you grow up in mould your identity. People can relate their identity to many aspects of their life – gender identity /cultural identity /social identity /
geographical identity /political identity /lack of / loss of identity.