AO2 Explore Ideas

Pictorialism vs Realism

Leave a comment

PICTORIALISM

Image result for Julia Margaret Cameron photography
Julia Margaret Cameron: Cameron used a soft focus in her images in order to create an overall dream-like appearance in her images, and is well known as one of the most influential portrait photographers of the 19th century. Her delicate and whimsical portraits of women and children placed the unconscious mind, dreams and imagination at the forefront of her images, and are often based on illustrative allegories or have religious undertones/meanings.

Time period : 1880s – 1920s

Key characteristics/ conventions : Pictorialism focuses on the beauty of the subject and the perfection of the composition, rather than the accurate documentation of the true, real world. Pictorialism often takes inspiration from works of literature, fair-tales and stories, incorporating a sense of dream-like wonder and spirituality into images in order to create a photograph that is visually, as well as contextually, interesting.

Sally Mann: Mann takes advantage of pictorialism in order to use her own personal experiences to create images which follow key elements of the movement closely. Mann focuses on the editing process of her photos, layering over the top of the images to create disturbed or washed out effects which bring the context of the image to the forefront of the viewers mind, forcing them to question why the image has been edited or disturbed in that way.

Methods/ techniques/ processes: Making pictures that resemble paintings by manipulating images in the darkroom, scratching and marking prints to imitate canvas texture, and using soft focus, often basing the image on allegorical and spiritual subject matter.

Frederick H. Evans: Evans was a member of the photographers association, The Brotherhood of the Linked Ring. The Linked Ring was a photographic society that sought to prove that photography was as much an art form as it was a science, and supported photography as a fine art. The society held exhibitions in which they rejected the notion of the technical approach of contemporary photography.

Artists associated: Julia Margaret Cameron, Peter Henry Emerson, The Brotherhood of the Linked Ring, Sally Mann

Plan a response: In order to create a piece of work that reflects the key elements of pictorialism, the editing of the photograph must be carefully planned and developed, and the subjects within the frame of the image may have a spiritual or religious meaning. Edits to the image itself should involve scratching an marking layers of the image, and there should be a reduction in harsh formal lines and tones in the final image, as to reflect the softness of many images found in pictorialism.

Image result for Peter Henry Emerson pictorialism
Peter Henry Emerson: Emerson was of the belief that cameras should be used to depict and document people as they were in real life, and should not follow the themes of posed scenes such as tableaux. Although Emerson believed that cameras should be used to document reality, the overall aesthetic of his images ran parallel with the ideals of pictorialism, with his images focusing on the beauty and composition of the subject matter.

REALISM / STRAIGHT PHOTOGRAPHY

Image result for walker evans
Walker Evans: Evans focuses on documenting the lives of working class society in America, and took inspiration from a range of other documentary photographers and artists. Evans work gives an intimate view into the lives of people that the viewers otherwise would not get a chance to meet or understand, and presents their lives, flaws and all, in a bare and stark manner, allowing the viewer to compare their own lives with that of the subjects in the images.

Time period: 1930’s – present

Key characteristics/ conventions : Straight photography relies on the cameras ability to produce detailed and sharp images that reflect the reality of the subject they are shooting. These images are often left un-edited, and with very little manipulation, in order to emphasise the real beauty and form of the subjects. The photographer is able to visualise the final image though encountering a scene they wish to photograph, and therefore the camera is used as a method of saving that scene, the exact way it was originally seen and experienced by the artist. Straight photography is able to capture a true moment in time, and reflect it accurately and realistically the viewers.

Image result for Jacob Riis photography
Jacob Riis: Riis documented the harsh reality of immigrants living in poverty in the slums of New York City during the late 19th century, providing the first real documentation of these people, and the upsetting truth of the areas of New York that had never received acknowledgement from the public before. Riis work can be seen as some of the first straight photography, where upsetting, real scenes of poverty were documented without censoring or being hidden/manipulated.

Methods/ techniques/ processes: Straight photography focuses on the cameras ability to show tone, form, focus, detail and contrast. The main aspect of taking the photograph involves the photographer first experiencing the scene, and visualising the image before it is taken. Straight photography relies on the photographers ability to decide on a time, place and subject matter that they wish to document, and therefore takes into account the wishes and observation abilities of the artist. Subjects can vary to encompass things that the photographer finds beautiful, important or rare, and therefore straight photography is often a reflection of the photographers own taste in what they believe to be an appropriate subject for their concept.

Image result for Paul Strand straight photography
Paul Strand: Strand, while also well known for his modernism work, can also be classed as contributing work in the category of straight photography. Strands straight photography work looks into the environments of everyday life, using cities, streets, machines and people to express social reform, and to give a detailed documentation of current life.

Artists associated: Walker Evans, Alfred Stieglitz, Paul Strand, Jacob Riis

Plan a response: Straight photography relies on the artists ability to see and observe a scene which they believe to be an important representation of an idea or social/political problem, and through the medium of photography, they are able to document the scene. Therefore straight photography relies on an idea being developed from the observation of a scene, and as this movement does not rely on the editing/manipulation of the image, it is important for the person taking the image to focus on the technical aspects of the camera, ensuring the IOS, focus and shutter-speed of the camera is appropriately set, and that the shadows, tones, time of day and shapes of the scene itself is all appropriate, and will reflect the natural beauty of the scenes without the need for enhancement.

Image result for Alfred Stieglitz photography
Alfred Stieglitz: Stieglitz‘s later work moves away from pictorialism, and further towards straight photography, in which his work depicts the truth of the modern world through the use of sharp focus and a high level of contrast. Stieglitz helped to drive the movement of the time from pictorialism, towards modernism (such as straight photography).

Leave a Reply