Modernism VS Postmodernism

Modernism

The time period which modernism became a period of experimentation was during the late 19th to the mid 20th century and was mostly popular in the years after World War One.

Key Characteristics- Modernism is the art movement which associates with cultural trends and changes which came from the transformations in Western society during the late 19th century. There are different modern-isms which are often incompatible and they reject the dominance of older movements such as Naturalism, Classicism as well as Academicism which is done in the favor of producing art. It inspires all aspects of society in its cultural form through Architecture, Painting, Photography and Fiction, this is because it is characterized intellectually. Photography was invented as part of the process of modernization which took place in the industrial revolution. It is known as a modern form of image making which helps the development of modernism.

Key Conventions- Modernism can be done through other smaller projects such as straight photography and realism. Straight photography was used by photographers who believed in intrinsic qualities and provided accurate/ descriptive records of the visual world. They aimed the make images which were photographic rather than painterly as they didn’t want to treat photography as a type of paining such as monochrome. Because of this they used handwork and soft focus in a wide depth-of-field. In addition to this, Realism is associated very closely to straight photography as it is taking images while trying to recreate the image you see in front of you, therefore showing it has a relationship towards reality and shows a cameras ability to capture the world as it appears.

Artists Associated

  • Alfred Stieglitz (1864-1946)- He was influenced by European avant-garde art movements as images in this range included underlying abstract geometric forms. Stiegliz took an image called ‘The Steerage’ which wasn’t up to Pictorialism’s aesthetic which was then therefore qualified to go into the ‘Straight Photography Means’.
  • Alexander Rodchenko, Russian, 1891-1956- Rodchenko worked on a new aesthetic vision using extreme viewpoints through their photography and graphic design. They rejected illusions so that photographic representation could be um problematic aspects of reality.

Key Works

Methods/ Techniques/ Processes- Black and white edits are used for emphasis, sharp focus images in order for them to be seen clearly, as well as a large frame size.

PostModernism

Post Modernism was first discovered through ‘Pop Art’ in the 1960s which was then developed into the aspect we know now which was made in the 1970s.

Key Characteristics/ Conventions- Postmodernism is known to be a reaction against ideas as well as values of modernism. The term of modernism’s dominance in cultural theory is associated with irony and philosophical concepts of universal truths. There is a known distinction between high and low art which incorporate popular elements making the overall postmodernism. Key conventions of postmodernism makes references towards outside art work which adds to the contextual work.

Artists Associated

  • Cindy Sherman (1977-1980)- Photographs are taken from videos and she untitled films in order to showcase female stereotypes and feminism.
  • Barbera Kruger (1945)- She is seen challenging cultural stereotypes and her work is displayed through the use of posters.

Key Works

Methods/ Techniques/ Processes- Photographs are usually blown hip, edited, cropped etc to be used used in newspapers and billboards. Others use repetition to create emphasis on the image.

Pictorialism VS Realism

Pictorialism

Pictorialism was created first in 1880 but flourished during the period of 1885- 1915 and it overall refers to style and aesthetic movements. It is the approach to photography which shows the beauty of the subject as well as the composition which creates the feel that it isn’t reality. It also refers to the style in which the photographer has manipulated an image, meaning its a created image.

Key Characteristics/Conventions- The people who first came up with the overall idea of this subject matter wanted their photographic work to be related closely to art and drawing, therefore they created techniques which made images look like paintings when they were taking the photograph eg, taking images in darkrooms, blurry/fuzzed images, soft focus, markings on canvas which all are based on religious scenes. Pictorialism also dismays the industrial exploitation of photography which connects to professional establishment. Following this, the photographs give individual expressions.

Artists Associated

  • Julia Margaret Cameron- She was a photographer in the Victoria era and she is known for her closely framed portraits and illustrative/ religious works. Her photographs are unconventional and have a particular created blur through long exposures.
  • Sally Mann (1951)- She creates haunting images which represents the loss of life. She includes a lot of darkness in her mixed landscape and portrait images which explores the divide between body and souk, and life and death. This is clearly shown in her images of decomposing bodies and portraits of her children.
  • Peter Henry Emerson (1856-1936)- He has a theory of Naturalistic Photography which the subject of Pictorialism used to promote photography as an overall art. He handcrafted the prints in a visual form.

Key works

Methods/ techniques/ processes- The first technique being putting Vaseline on the camera lens which created a smudge allowing a symbolic meaning to do with religion. This is also an example of pictorial photographs lacking sharp focus, creating its overall style. Some work as groups to create more ideas, not very good quality cameras are used as they intend a blur anyway.

Realism/Straight Photography

Photo-Realism photography first began in the 1920s and became extremely popular in the 1960s as it became more well known and took overall photography as an inspiration. Photographers who photograph realist images are called ‘Photo- Realists’ and they are people who created high quality images which are illusionistic and reproduce the original image.

Key Characteristics/Conventions- Realism is known as a style of photography which creates an image for what it is, a pure documentary style. It is a very accurate and doesn’t have any metaphorical manners as it focuses on real people in their natural situations. The photographers who capture these moments use sharp focus techniques and use a wide depth of field in order to capture the whole scene, representing the realistic side. In relation, Straight Photography is closely associated with Realism and these photographers believe in intrinsic qualities and it has an ability to provide records of the visual world through descriptive aspects.

A smaller group in the subject of Realism, ‘Social Reform Photography’ which is when people photograph the conditions in which people live in and represents how different it is to a ‘average’ persons living way.

Artists Associated

  • Walker Evens (1903-1975)- Evens was a documentary photographer in the 20th century who previously rejected Pictorialism as he wanted to create new photographic art which has an obscure look. He photographed several families who work on different farms to represent their uniforms, backgrounds/ living environments. He also made a book which shows all the different families in comparison.
  • Alfrid Stieglitz- He tells images through a story through capturing images of immigrants in abstract pictures.

Key Works

Methods/ techniques/ processes- There is a constant use of a sharp focus which allows for the image being taken to be seen in detail, this also represents the ‘Realism’ aspect in detail. A wide depth of field is also seen the be used which again, shows the realism. The use of environmental photography is supporting the overall role.

pictorialism vs realism/straight

PICTORIALISM

From the 1880s and onwards, photographers wanted photography to be art by trying to capture images that are similar to paintings. For example, manipulating images in the darkroom, scratching and marking their prints to imitate the texture of canvas using blurred and fuzzy images including imagery based on spiritual subject matter and religious scenes. Pictorialism reacted against mechanisation and industrialisation.

ALLEGORICAL PAINTING

Allegory convey meaning which are not literal. It communicates its message by symbolic figures, actions or symbolic representations. The underlying meaning has moral, social, religious or political significance and the figures are often personifications of ideas such as greed, charity or envy.

Paolo Veronese (1556)
JULIA MARGARET CAMERON

Julia Margaret Cameron was a photographer in the Victorian era. Her work can fit into two categories such as closely framed portraits and illustrative allegories based on religious and literary works. Her photographs were out of the ordinary since she created blur through long exposures, where the subject moved and sometimes by leaving the lens out of focus.

PETER HENRY EMERSON: NATURALISTIC PHOTOGRAPHY

In 1889 he presented his theory of Naturalistic photography which the Pictorialist used to promote photography as an art form.

SALLY MANN

From her personal experiences she has created a haunting series of photographs about the loss of life. What Remains is a body of work that depicts landscapes, decomposing bodies and portraits of her children. She explores the divide between body and soul, life and death, spirit and earth through her photography.

Various photography groups and associations were involved in pictorialism such as: The Vienna Camera Club, The brotherhood of the Linked ring and Photo-Secession

Heinrich Kuhn
Alfred Horlsey Hinton Fleeting and Far (1903)
STRAIGHT

Photographers who believed in the photographic medium to provide accurate and descriptive records of the visual world. These photographers wanted to create images that were only photographic rather than artistic. They focused on capturing clear images with great detail and sharpness.

REALISM

Associated with straight photography, it claims that photography has a special relationship to reality and the camera’s ability to record objectively was unquestioned. The media relies on photographs to show the truth of what took place.

Paul Strand
WALKER EVANS

He was the leading American documentary photographer of the 20th century. He rejected Pictorialism and focused on serious subject matters such as photographs of three Sharecropper families in the American South during the 1930s Depression.

SOCIAL REFORM PHOTOGRAPHY

A number of photographer’s such as Lewis W Wine and Dorothea Lange began to document the effects of industrialisation and urbanisation on working class Americans. Their work brought the need for housing and labour reform to the attention of legislators and is what we now call photojournalism.

Lewis W Wine
Dorothea Lange

PICTORIAL-ISM VS. REALISM

PICTORIAL-ISM

time period : 1880-1920s

Key characteristics/ conventions : Pictoralism was born out of the desire to have photography accepted as an art form, as such the photographs were made to look more like paintings. Alot of influence from romanticism and various painting movements. Use of allegorical subject matter. Heavily stylized.

Artists associated: The vienna camera club (Heinrich Kuhn, Hans Watcek, Hugo Henneberg) , The brotherhood of the linked ring (H P Robinson), Photo-secession (Frank Fugene, F Holland Day, Clarence H White, Gertrude Kasebier), Sally Mann

Key works:

Henry Peach Robinson: Fading Away (1858)
George Davison: The Onion Field, Mersea Island, Essex (1890)


Methods/ techniques/ processes: Vaseline on lens, chiaroscuro, autochromes

REALISM / STRAIGHT PHOTOGRAPHY

Time period: Started in 1840s

Key characteristics/ conventions : Realistic photography in retaliation to pictorial-ism. Capturing realities of contemporary life synonymous with the depressive era. Documentary photography.

Artists associated: Walker Evans, Paul Strand, Alfred Stieglitz

Key works:

Image result for alfred stieglitz

Methods/ techniques/ processes: SLR, modern glass, small aperture.

Post Modernism

POST-MODERNISM

Time period:

Time period : Late 20th century

Key characteristics/ conventions :

  • It is the movement away from modernism.
  • It involves the mixture of different art medium that reference political, cultural and historical issues.
  • The concept itself lacks rules, it’s up to the photographer to decide what messages they encode and how these messages are represented in an image.
  • In a way it’s initial motive was to challenge the idea of modernism.

Postmodernism is best understood by defining the modernist ethos it replaced – that of the ‘avant-garde’ who were active from 1860s to the 1950s. Postmodernism overturned the idea that there was one inherent meaning to a work of art or that this meaning was determined by the artist at the time of creation. Instead, the viewer became an important determiner of meaning, even allowed by some artists to participate in the work as in the case of some performance pieces.


Key characteristics/ conventions : Common targets of postmodernism and critical theory include universalist notions of objective reality, morality, truth, human nature, reason, language, and social progress. The ideas rejected by postmodernists include the idea of artistic development as goal-oriented, the notion that only men are artistic geniuses, and the outdated assumption that non-white races are inferior. Feminist art and minority art that challenged canonical ways of thinking are often included under the umbrella of postmodernism or seen as representations of it.


Artists associated: William Eggleston and Robert Rauschenberg.

Image result for Robert Rauschenberg

Dadaism: Dada or Dadaism was an art movement of the European avant-garde in the early 20th century. Dadasim had an influence on postmodernism in its questioning of authenticity and originality. ‘Combined with the notion of appropriation, postmodernism often took the undermining of originality to the point of copyright infringement, even in the use of photographs with little or no alteration to the original.’ -The Art Story.

STYLISTIC AND CONTEXTUAL IDEAS:

The snapshot type imagery which Eggleston created throughout his career, created anecdotal meaning about everyday aspects of life. The accessible and simplistic method of his photography, such as using the Kodak’s Brownie camera, meant that his work had a personal touch to subjects he had no direct personal link with. Color also represented a multitude of themes in his work such as the contrast between the new and the old, the ordinary and extraordinary, the man-made and the natural. In many senses he was a non-conformist, associating him as a prominent figure in the postmodernist art scene. He also explored a contemporary commercial printing process of dye transfer to see the ways in which this could contribute to the representation of color and how this could become the focal point instead of the selling of lifestyle, concepts or ideas. During his career there were a few occasions where Eggleston encountered the work of Andy Worhol, exposing him to other popular forms of mediums, contributing to his experimental photography style. Eggleston’s use of the anecdotal and everyday is set apart by his focus on details such as facial expression which can be seen in the image above. Throughout his career he pushed the boundaries of documentary photography associated with the works of Robert Frank and Walker Evans. His photography effectively captured the shift of life in the South from rural to cosmopolitan societies.

In the work above we can see an example of the extreme focus which Eggleston pays to the facial expressions and body language of the subjects. There is a clear contrast in character from the youthful appearance of the woman on the right and the sickly, pale and tired lady on the right hand side of the image. There is also an overall contrast of color from the left and right with the radiant blonde hair, African print dress and the dark, flat hair and blue toned dress. There is a distinct lack of facial expression with with the woman on the left as she lays on the sofa, in a lifeless and melancholy fashion, observed by the Goddess like presence of the light haired woman. The image provokes overall feelings of conflict and change. Opposed to the typical conventions of postmodernism, this image in particular follows close conventions of Tableau and Renaissance art with the stylized body language and dramatic lighting. This image very effectively showcases the postmodernist features which Eggleston focused on within his work.

Methods/ techniques/ processes:

  • Tableaux- staged photography which displays a pictorial narrative.
  • Intertextuality – when you include others work.
  • Eclecticism – the mixture of styles.
  • Refiguration – re-structuring an original image.
  • Collaboration-working alongside other artists.
  • Pastiche – copying an original.
  • Re-cycling- using materials more than once.

Modernism vs POSTMODERNISM

MODERNISM

Time period: first half of the 20th century

Key characteristics/ conventions : Modernism refers to a global movement in society and culture that from the early decades of the twentieth century sought a new alignment with the experience and values of modern industrial life. Building on late nineteenth-century precedents, artists around the world used new imagery, materials and techniques to create artworks that they felt better reflected the realities and hopes of modern societies.


Artists associated: Margareth Bourke-White


Key works: Grant Wood-American Gothic

Methods/ techniques/ processes:

  • photojournalism
  • avant-garde movement

POST-MODERNISM

Time period : Postmodernism is best understood by defining the modernist ethos it replaced – that of the ‘avant-garde’ who were active from 1860s to the 1950s. Postmodernism overturned the idea that there was one inherent meaning to a work of art or that this meaning was determined by the artist at the time of creation. Instead, the viewer became an important determiner of meaning, even allowed by some artists to participate in the work as in the case of some performance pieces.

Key characteristics/ conventions :

  • It is the movement away from modernism.
  • It involves the mixture of different art medium that reference political, cultural and historical issues.
  • The concept itself lacks rules, it’s up to the photographer to decide what messages they encode and how these messages are represented in an image.
  • In a way it’s initial motive was to challenge the idea of modernism.
  • Common targets of postmodernism and critical theory include universalist notions of objective reality, morality, truth, human nature, reason, language, and social progress. The ideas rejected by postmodernists include the idea of artistic development as goal-oriented, the notion that only men are artistic geniuses, and the outdated assumption that non-white races are inferior. Feminist art and minority art that challenged canonical ways of thinking are often included under the umbrella of postmodernism or seen as representations of it.

Artists associated: William Eggleston and Robert Rauschenberg.

The snapshot type imagery which Eggleston created throughout his career, created anecdotal meaning about everyday aspects of life. The accessible and simplistic method of his photography, such as using the Kodak’s Brownie camera, meant that his work had a personal touch to subjects he had no direct personal link with. Color also represented a multitude of themes in his work such as the contrast between the new and the old, the ordinary and extraordinary, the man-made and the natural. In many senses he was a non-conformist, associating him as a prominent figure in the postmodernist art scene. He also explored a contemporary commercial printing process of dye transfer to see the ways in which this could contribute to the representation of color and how this could become the focal point instead of the selling of lifestyle, concepts or ideas. During his career there were a few occasions where Eggleston encountered the work of Andy Worhol, exposing him to other popular forms of mediums, contributing to his experimental photography style. Eggleston’s use of the anecdotal and everyday is set apart by his focus on details such as facial expression which can be seen in the image above. Throughout his career he pushed the boundaries of documentary photography associated with the works of Robert Frank and Walker Evans. His photography effectively captured the shift of life in the South from rural to cosmopolitan societies.

In the work above we can see an example of the extreme focus which Eggleston pays to the facial expressions and body language of the subjects. There is a clear contrast in character from the youthful appearance of the woman on the right and the sickly, pale and tired lady on the right hand side of the image. There is also an overall contrast of color from the left and right with the radiant blonde hair, African print dress and the dark, flat hair and blue toned dress. There is a distinct lack of facial expression with with the woman on the left as she lays on the sofa, in a lifeless and melancholy fashion, observed by the Goddess like presence of the light haired woman. The image provokes overall feelings of conflict and change. Opposed to the typical conventions of postmodernism, this image in particular follows close conventions of Tableau and Renaissance art with the stylized body language and dramatic lighting. This image very effectively showcases the postmodernist features which Eggleston focused on within his work.

Image result for william eggleston


Methods/ techniques/ processes:

  • Tableaux- staged photography which displays a pictorial narrative.
  • Intertextuality – when you include others work.
  • Eclecticism – the mixture of styles.
  • Refiguration – re-structuring an original image.
  • Collaboration-working alongside other artists.
  • Pastiche – copying an original.
  • Re-cycling- using materials more than once.
  • Dadaism: Dada or Dadaism was an art movement of the European avant-garde in the early 20th century. Dadasim had an influence on postmodernism in its questioning of authenticity and originality. ‘Combined with the notion of appropriation, postmodernism often took the undermining of originality to the point of copyright infringement, even in the use of photographs with little or no alteration to the original.’ -The Art Story.

POSTMODERNISM

Time period: Postmodernism is best understood by defining the modernist ethos it replaced – that of the ‘avant-garde’ who were active from 1860s to the 1950s. Postmodernism overturned the idea that there was one inherent meaning to a work of art or that this meaning was determined by the artist at the time of creation. Instead, the viewer became an important determiner of meaning, even allowed by some artists to participate in the work as in the case of some performance pieces.


Key characteristics/ conventions : Common targets of postmodernism and critical theory include universalist notions of objective reality, morality, truth, human nature, reason, language, and social progress. The ideas rejected by postmodernists include the idea of artistic development as goal-oriented, the notion that only men are artistic geniuses, and the outdated assumption that non-white races are inferior. Feminist art and minority art that challenged canonical ways of thinking are often included under the umbrella of postmodernism or seen as representations of it.


Artists associated: William Eggleston and Robert Rauschenberg.

Image result for Robert Rauschenberg

Dadaism: Dada or Dadaism was an art movement of the European avant-garde in the early 20th century. Dadasim had an influence on postmodernism in its questioning of authenticity and originality. ‘Combined with the notion of appropriation, postmodernism often took the undermining of originality to the point of copyright infringement, even in the use of photographs with little or no alteration to the original.’ -The Art Story.

Key characteristics/ conventions :

  • It is the movement away from modernism.
  • It involves the mixture of different art medium that reference political, cultural and historical issues.
  • The concept itself lacks rules, it’s up to the photographer to decide what messages they encode and how these messages are represented in an image.
  • In a way it’s initial motive was to challenge the idea of modernism.

Methods/ techniques/ processes:

  • Tableaux- staged photography which displays a pictorial narrative.
  • Intertextuality – when you include others work.
  • Eclecticism – the mixture of styles.
  • Refiguration – re-structuring an original image.
  • Collaboration-working alongside other artists.
  • Pastiche – copying an original.
  • Re-cycling- using materials more than once.

Image result for William Eggleston post modernist
Image result for william eggleston photography

STYLISTIC AND CONTEXTUAL IDEAS:

The snapshot type imagery which Eggleston created throughout his career, created anecdotal meaning about everyday aspects of life. The accessible and simplistic method of his photography, such as using the Kodak’s Brownie camera, meant that his work had a personal touch to subjects he had no direct personal link with. Color also represented a multitude of themes in his work such as the contrast between the new and the old, the ordinary and extraordinary, the man-made and the natural. In many senses he was a non-conformist, associating him as a prominent figure in the postmodernist art scene. He also explored a contemporary commercial printing process of dye transfer to see the ways in which this could contribute to the representation of color and how this could become the focal point instead of the selling of lifestyle, concepts or ideas. During his career there were a few occasions where Eggleston encountered the work of Andy Worhol, exposing him to other popular forms of mediums, contributing to his experimental photography style. Eggleston’s use of the anecdotal and everyday is set apart by his focus on details such as facial expression which can be seen in the image above. Throughout his career he pushed the boundaries of documentary photography associated with the works of Robert Frank and Walker Evans. His photography effectively captured the shift of life in the South from rural to cosmopolitan societies.

In the work above we can see an example of the extreme focus which Eggleston pays to the facial expressions and body language of the subjects. There is a clear contrast in character from the youthful appearance of the woman on the right and the sickly, pale and tired lady on the right hand side of the image. There is also an overall contrast of color from the left and right with the radiant blonde hair, African print dress and the dark, flat hair and blue toned dress. There is a distinct lack of facial expression with with the woman on the left as she lays on the sofa, in a lifeless and melancholy fashion, observed by the Goddess like presence of the light haired woman. The image provokes overall feelings of conflict and change. Opposed to the typical conventions of postmodernism, this image in particular follows close conventions of Tableau and Renaissance art with the stylized body language and dramatic lighting. This image very effectively showcases the postmodernist features which Eggleston focused on within his work.

Pictorialism vs Realism

PICTORIALISM

Time period: 1880s – 1920s


Key characteristics/ conventions: often uses landscapes and figures within, influenced by allegorical imagery


Artists associated: Julia Margaret Cameron (1815-1879)

Sally Mann

The Vienna Camera Club (Austria) – Hans Watcek, Heinrich Kuhn, Hugo Henneberg

The Brotherhood of the Linked Ring (London) –

Photo-Secession (New York) – Frank Eugene, Gertrude Kasebier, F Holland Day, Clarence H White


Methods/ techniques/ processes: vaseline on lenses to make it not sharp, manipulate images (mimic artwork)

REALISM / STRAIGHT PHOTOGRAPHY

Time period: Late 1800s and the early 1900s


Key characteristics/ conventions: Shows images of peoples lives to show poor/helpless/homeless normally


Artists associated: Walker Evans (1903-75)


Methods/ techniques/ processes: Social reform photography (imagery of poor/homeless) used to help people within the images