Category Archives: Contextual Studies

Filters

Author:
Category:

Contextual Study – Origins of Street/Documentary photograph

Realism Photography Movement

The first successful form of photography was a Daguerroetype, named after Louis-Jacques-Mandé Daguerre from France, he invented the technique in collaboration with Nicéphore Niépce in 1830s. Daguerre and Niépce found that if a copper plate coated with silver iodide was exposed to light in a camera then fumed with mercury vapour and fixed by a solution of common salt, a permanent image would be formed. A great number of daguerreotypes, especially portraits, were made in the mid-19th century; the technique was supplanted by the wet collodion process. Daguerreotypes soon became popular by the hundreds of thousands. The first photo portrait was made by Samuel F.B. Morse, inventor of the telegraph.

With the invention of photography, the art of portraiture would become almost non-existent. By 1858, photography was an assured fact, and photographers were able to prove at last how living beings really look in motion, to the great discomfiture of artists in the classic tradition with their contrived poses. In other words, photographs capture the essence of the action, the movement as it is, and there is absolutely no doubt in the veracity or accuracy of the photograph. This fits in perfectly with the realists because their sole focus is to portray the world, as it is, and not in a blown-up, romantic manner.

The term realism was coined by the French novelist Champfleury in the 1840s In practice, a realist subject matter was  scenes of peasant and working class life, the life of the city streets, cafes and popular entertainments. The term generally implies a certain grittiness in choice of subject. Such subject matter combined with the new naturalism of treatment caused shock among the predominantly upper and middle class audiences for art. Photorealism evolved from Pop Art, as a counter movement to Abstract Expressionism, Minimalism and Pictorialism in the late 1960s and early 1970s in the United States.

Famous Realism Photographers

Walker Evans, America (1903-75)

Often considered to be the leading American documentary photographer of the 20th century. He rejected Pictorialism and wanted to establish a new photographic art based on a detached and disinterested look. He was particularly interested in the vernacular of American architecture, but his most celebrated work is his pictures of three Sharecropper families in the American South during the 1930s Depression.

Paul Strand, America (1890-1976)

Paul Strand searched for a higher truth using the camera machine to capture life. Considered a master and one of the initial contributors to the modern art era not only by his “straight” use of the camera but also by what and how he photographed. Paul Strand was inducted into the International Photography Hall of Fame and Museum in 1984.

Alfred Stieglitz, America (1864- 1946)

Emerging first in the era of Pictorial photography, Stieglitz sought to gain recognition for his medium by producing effects that paralleled those found in other fine arts such as painting. Many of his peers resorted to elaborate re-touching to create an impression of the handmade, but Stieglitz relied more on compositional effects and mastery of tone, often concentrating on natural effects such as snow and steam to create qualities similar to those of the Impressionists.

Documentary Photography

Shortly after the invention of photography in 1839, several Scottish photographers began documenting the Fisherfolk of Fife and Edinburgh. These early photographs tell us a lot about their life and work.

For many people, documentary photography is defined as a form of sharp-focus photography that captures images of raw, candid human emotion in ‘real-life’ situations. It is the opportunity for a photographer to show the viewer the complexities and interlaced layers of life. The photographer often follows a topic or story over a period of time, and in this regard can be considered to differ from photojournalism where the objective is usually to cover events in real-time.

Common themes explored by documentary photographers are social and political problems such as injustice, conflict and inequality. For example, photographer and pioneer of the documentary genre, Don McCullin, is best known for his powerful works covering the horrors of war and documenting hardship.

“Seeing, looking at what others cannot bear to see is what my life is all about”

Don McCullin –

Street Photography

Street Photography may at first glance seem an easier style to define being characterised by its urban setting but Documentary photography can also be set in the streets. To most people, the clear distinction is that street photography usually captures an unplanned moment in time, and, unlike documentary photography, it has the absence of a central theme or topic. That said, street photographs can and often do, ‘acquire’ value as documentary images, especially within time, because they can offer a glimpse into a scene from the past and form pieces of social history.

Also, there is more freedom in street photography for the photographer to express themselves artistically. Using precise framing and composition they can capture a desired image at a desired moment. When it comes to locations, documentary photography takes place wherever the central topic or theme dictates, whereas in street photography the setting forms an essential part of the composition.

“To me, photography is the simultaneous recognition, in a fraction of a second, of the significance of an event.”

Henri Cartier-Bresson  – http://www.gupmagazine.com/articles/the-decisive-moment

Resourses Used:

https://www.loc.gov/teachers/classroommaterials/connections/daguerreotype/history.html

http://www.jameshymangallery.com/search?q=walker+evans

http://www.jameshymangallery.com/artists/6636/biography/paul-strand

http://www.jameshymangallery.com/artists/7361/biography/alfred-stieglitz

ANDY WARHOL

Andy Warhol – ‘Eat’

‘Eat’ is a 45-minute underground film created by Andy Warhol which features painter Robert Indiana, filmed in 1964 in Indiana’s studio.

‘Eat’ is filmed in black and white, with no soundtrack and depicts pop artist Indiana engaged in the process of eating a mushroom throughout the whole of the static film, with a final appearance of a cat at the end. The video is an intimate piece of art that is rather more of an experience for the viewer which allows a connection to be made with the subject of the film. The close up shots particularly, like in the frame above, emphasizes the feeling of intimacy. The simplicity of video art creates the idea that what the viewer is watching is not so far detached from reality and replicates real life. Particularly with ‘Eat’, the plot that doesn’t necessarily exist is very mundane, as eating is a part of life that everyone experiences on a daily basis.

Video art emerged during the late 1960s as new consumer video technology. Video tape recorders became available outside corporate broadcasting. One of the key differences between video art and theatrical cinema is that video art does not necessarily rely on many of the conventions that define theatrical cinema. Video art may not employ the use of actors, contain no dialogue, have no discernible narrative or plot, or adhere to any of the other conventions that generally define motion pictures as entertainment. Video art is often experimental, radical or unorthodox with respect to art, culture or society. It may also offer critique of the relationship between producer and consumer.

 

reviewing and relfecting

Lesson 1 – Reviewing and reflecting: Objective: Criteria from the Syllabus

  • Essential that students build on their prior knowledge and experience developed during the course.

when considering what I should further investigate within my project I started to think about my prior knowledge of my personal investigation and my overview so far. So far within my work I have investigated three main themes, this started off within the demonstration of narrative photography demonstrating how a political landscape should and is able to re create a personal emotion if someone  has an experience within that space. My second idea was a development of what is reality and if I could capture a false reality within my images, this being seen within the reflection of time. Lastly and currently the theme I am working within, this being the sublime and what images can be considered as painful and yet also beautiful. I have learned about how to show emotion through a piece of work and how to tell a story through not a direct narrative but fragmented images being grouped together to express a theme. I intend to further develop a theme that both links, reality the sublime and most importantly emotion. I decided if I used emotion I could denote factors about my own feelings and also those of people I photograph. I believe I want my project to be very unique but most importantly to have very interesting and individual imagery.I belive if I develop emotion I could use factors of the sublime to divide emotions into being beautiful and painful, and how emotions are so subjective to each and every person so much so that it is not the same reality for someone else.  Due to no one knowing what someone else is feeling I belive I could develop a book that shows the ups and down of what people feel. I believe living in what happens between planning for their future. So creating a book based on all my past research and shoot so far will really benefit myself. I could use the sublime to create further imagery in order to create a metaphor for how people feel during these emotions. I still want to use both a picture of landscape and portraits as this genuine combination presents a whole picture of what someone is possibly going through. To my mind when describing what themes are in my work I would say themes which have a sufficient meaning to a person and would effect their emotion shown within a sublime way. So a theme of vulnerability and perhaps a certain amount of truth to the person themselves. I have done much research on an array of artists, But I belive the most influential are those which achieve a sense of beauty and  such a unique appearance to the image itself.I believe focusing on people such as Tim walker and Claude chaun creating an interesting and subjective juxtaposition of techniques and aims within their work. Tim walkers outgoing and almost surrealist manifestos of tablo photography would enable oneself to create the eye-catching unique and sublime imagery. Whereas Claude chaun has a combination of political and social views which would allow me to achieve an emotional representation of individuality of people. Her account for fighting for gender rights and such should be prelivant within my work as the vulnerability of people is such a huge aspect. I have already done a direct response to her work, but if continue to do so with the intent of using her narrative responses this should successful work as an artists inspiration. I believe the difficult aspect of my work I am trying to achieve will be that of what approach I take. I have so many ideas and vision and I need to find the correct approach to tie all the serpent narratives into one intertextual idea. However because I want to find emotion I the sublime this is Both a combination of narrative as a reflection of what people are going through, to trying to create breathtaking and table photography images to then further demonstrate their emotions in a metaphorical physical interpretation. The skills I need are both successful convening an emotion. Through my images and yet also having an interesting composition to the images themselves. Also I think editing will be a large part of successfully creating the images I want to show. I believe I need to take a lot more photos and developing them to create the atmosphere within colour and the angle of the image itself will be difficult but would really advance and help the overall effect of my images. Techniques that inspire me the most are those which I find fascinating and eye catching, this is experimenting its under water photography, night time and light traces, close of textured work, seeing a sublime beauty within nature and lastly using colour a directed narrative to show a sense of atmosphere and the surroundings of myself and the people I aim studying around myself. what techniques am I using to create an overall synced view? As said previously I want to experiment within using many photoshop techniques as well as photographic sutures of using an experiment of slow shutter speed synced with fast capture to show many different atmospheres and characters within my work. Why am I inspired by this? I Find these ideas interesting to me because, showing emotions in such a sublime and new way, possible allows people to be more vulnerable and expressive wihtin their emotions and what they are really feeling. So many people when talking about emotions derive only negative connotations from doing so and belive emotions can only be spoken about in a negative and ill mannered way. I believe emotions should be an expression of who we are, it shouldn’t be reflected as a mirror of oursleves but should be seen wihtin our environment and those around us. Emotion have the ability to show strength and happiness. Examples of current experiments I am thinking about achieving are the following; Overall I am inspired by this through my wanting such an abstract surreal book that express emotion in such a why that is so unexpected yet so obvious to threader about its contact and the feeling it is trying to convey altogether.Emotion and sublime to my mind work hand in hand and I believe this would really successful tie my work in together.

Academic sources: bibliography

A list of sources I have read as part of my essay and text I will submit:

Hills,P and Cooper, T(1998), dialogue with photography.New York: Dewi Lewis publishing

…which is the point that Paul Hill makes when she says ‘verbs expression of this is most difficult and awkward, and that is annoying.’ (Robert 1998:81)

(Cacioppo et al. 2001 p. 173)

-The authors investigated whether people can feel happy and sad at the same time. J. A. Russell and J. M. Carroll’s (1999) circumplex model holds that happiness and sadness are polar opposites and, thus, mutually exclusive. In contrast, the evaluative space model (J. T. Cacioppo & G. G. Berntson, 1994) proposes that positive and negative affect are separable and that mixed feelings of happiness and sadness can co-occur.

k.Anish(2002) Tate Modern: Contemporary

– Kapoor as most powerfully expressed in the monumental void works of recent years.

E.Burke’s(1757) Philosophical Enquiry – Oxford worlds classics 

-It was the first complete philosophical exposition for separating the beautiful and the sublime into their own respective rational categories.

R.Barthes(1980) Camera lucida

-. It is simultaneously an inquiry into the nature and essence of photography and a eulogy to Barthes’ late mother. The book investigates the effects of photography on the spectator.

Contemporary arts

J.bell (2013) ‘contemporary art and the sublime’ 

-In the first section of this essay, I shall offer a directly personal take on the theme that will open out on to various aspects of current art-world thinking and practice. Many of the tactics and visual effects discussed here can easily be related to the tradition of artistic production stimulated by the writings of Burke

B.newmans(1948) ‘the sublime is now’

-The invention of beauty b the greek, that is , their postulate of beauty as an ideal. Mans natural desire I the arts to express his relation to the absolute became identified and confused with the absolutisms of perfect creations. 

PHOTOGRAPHY AND TRUTH

Week 10: 12 – 19 Nov
CONTEXTUAL STUDIES

Photography and Truth

Can a photograph lie?

robert-capa-falling-soldier
Robert Capa, Death of a Loyalist Soldier, 1936

Are all photographs reliable?

lflaga2
Joe Rosenthal, Raising the Flag on Iwo Jima, February 23, 1945

A photograph is a certain delivery of facts?

Jeff Wall, Mimic, 1982

Claims of truth that most people take for granted?

Tom Hunter, Woman Reading a Possession Order, 1997, after Johannes Vermeer (1632-1675) A Girl Reading a Letter by an Open Window, 1647-49after

You often hear a photographer saying: ‘the camera was there and recorded what I saw’.

A common phrase is to ‘shed light on a situation’ meaning to find out the truth.

‘A picture tells a 1000 words‘, is another aphorism that imply images are more reliable.

Picasso famously said: ‘We all know that art is not truth. Art is a lie that makes us realise truth.’

Magritte’s painting La Trahison des Images in which he painted a picture of a pipe with the words ‘Ceci n’est pas une pipe’ (This is not a pipe) goes some way towards an explanation.

margritti-not-pipe

Documentary photography’s central aesthetic, political and moral associations are:

depicting truth

recording life as it is

camera as a witness.

TASKS: Produce a number of blog posts that show evidence of the following 

DEADLINE: Mon 19 Nov

1. ANALYSIS: Choose one image from case studies listed below that questions the notion of truth regarding the photographic image and its relationship with reality and explain why.

Follow this method of analysis:
TECHNICAL > VISUAL > CONTEXTUAL > CONCEPTUAL.
Read more here on PhotoPedagogy

2. PHOTO-ASSIGNMENT: Based on your chosen theme of Political Landscape make two images, one that you consider truthful and one that is not.

The rationale behind this task is for you to consider the nature of the photograph to be a true representation of reality. In order to complete the tasks successfully, you must read and look through supporting material and consider the bullit points too that may prompt you in your answers .  It is important that you do thourough research and use direct quotes and reference  from sources included below

RESEARCH: Look through this Powerpoints:  Photography and Truth and also read also this text for further context:  Issues in Photojournalism.

For a contemporary perspective on documentary practice read photographer, Max Pincher’s Interview: On Speculative Documentary  To read this interview you must access it online from home as it is blocked the internet filter in school.

Documentary photography is based on assumptions that the photograph represents a one-to-one correspondence with reality, which is nearly accurate and adequate, and that the photographic image is capable of conveying information objectively.

Consider these points when you analyse your image

  • Traditional documentary believes the viewer to be a receptive subject taking in the objective information of the world through the photograph
  • Can we rely on its ability to capture a moment in time accurately as historical evidence or as a witness to the world?
  • Postmodernism points out that all forms of representation is subjective? How? Why?
  • Digital photography has made manipulation much easier?

READING: Background and context of the historical, conceptual and aesthetic approaches and differences  between documentary practice and tableaux photography.

David Bate (2016), Art Photography. Tate Publishing

New approaches to documentary in contemporary photography
David_Bate_The_Art_of_the_Document

On rise of Tableaux in contemporary photographic practice David_Bate_The_Pictorial_Turn

Also read and look through both these PPTs to get a basic understanding of Documentary vs Tableuax

Documentary Photography

ICELAND / Saudakrokur / 26.09.2010 / Annual horse gathering country ball (c) Rafal Milach / Sputnik Photos/ Anzenberger

Tableaux Photography

Jeff Wall

CASE STUDY 1:. In the terrorist attacks in Brussels in 2016 Fox News was reporting from the Place de la Borse. Video footage shows a young photographer posing a woman in front of a makeshift memorial: is it bad journalism ethics, or just the way it’s done?

Read the Guardian newspaper article here and make a blog post that expresses your own thoughts and views.

Further insight can be read here on Petapixel

Here is the image that photographer, Khaled Al Sabbah posted on Instagram

Untitled-1

 

CASE STUDY 2: Another image from the Brussels attack has also generated a lot of chatter on social media.

A photograph of a woman in shock with torn clothes and injured foot has gone around the world.

Read a few articles here.

Time Magazine

The Guardian

USA Today

Following the second explosion, Kardava  (the woman who took the image on her phone) fought her urge to run to a safe place. “I also wanted to take pictures. As a journalist, it was my duty to take these photos and show the world what was going on. I knew I was the only one at this spot.”

In this photo provided by Georgian Public Broadcaster and photographed by Ketevan Kardava two women wounded in Brussels Airport in Brussels, Belgium, after explosions were heard Tuesday, March 22, 2016. A developing situation left at least one person and possibly more dead in explosions that ripped through the departure hall at Brussels airport Tuesday, police said. All flights were canceled, arriving planes were being diverted and Belgium's terror alert level was raised to maximum, officials said. (Ketevan Kardava/ Georgian Public Broadcaster via AP)
In this photo provided by Georgian Public Broadcaster and photographed by Ketevan Kardava two women wounded in Brussels Airport in Brussels, Belgium, after explosions were heard Tuesday, March 22, 2016. A developing situation left at least one person and possibly more dead in explosions that ripped through the departure hall at Brussels airport Tuesday, police said. All flights were canceled, arriving planes were being diverted and Belgium’s terror alert level was raised to maximum, officials said. (Ketevan Kardava/ Georgian Public Broadcaster via AP)

Is there a moral dilemma in photographing people injured or dying? As photojournalist should you take the image?

What is your view? How has this image become iconic of the terrorist attacks in Brussels airport?

CASE STUDY 3: Using another news images as an example, such as the drowned Syrian boy (read article here), consider if photographs can change the world or change people’s perception?

heartbreaking-photo-of-a-drowned-toddler-embodies-the-worlds-failure-in-syria

syria (1)

Here is a link to another article about the photographer who took the photos of the dead Syrian boy where she speaks about why she took them.

For a different point of view read this blog post by photographer and lecturer, Lewis Bush where he discuss the above in light of recent images of dead Syrian refugees in Europe. Incorporate his views and include quotes, for or against your own analysis and point of view.

photographs-wont-change-the-world

CASE STUDY 4: Jeff Wall, Canadian artists known for his large scale tableaux image presented in light-boxes

installation-d-web

Today, most of his images resemble reportage and, as such, are likely to incense his detractors, who claim he’s not a “true” photographer. His most contentious new work, called Approach, shows a homeless woman standing by a makeshift cardboard shelter in which we spy the foot of what could be a sleeping vagrant. Wall tells me it was shot under an actual freeway where the homeless congregate and that “it took a month to make, working hands-on” – but he won’t divulge just how staged it is. Is this an actual homeless woman, or an actor? Is the shelter real, or was it built by Wall’s team of assistants to resemble one?

3506

Re-creating images from memory is crucial to Wall’s practice – perhaps because it flies in the face of the tradition of photography as an act of instant witnessing.

“Something lingers in me until I have to remake it from memory to capture why it fascinates me,” he says. “Not photographing gives me imaginative freedom that is crucial to the making of art. That, in fact, is what art is about – the freedom to do what we want.”

Read full interview with Jeff Wall here

In terms of truth or communicating an idea that make references to a real social problem such as homelessness, does it matter if the image is staged or not? Where does authenticity come into the picture?

CASE STUDY 5. The images of renowned photographer Steve McCurry, who made the famous and iconic image of an Afghan girl for a front cover of National Geography has recently been criticized for making ‘too perfect pictures’ which not only are boring but reinforces a particular idea or stereotype of the exotic other.

afghan-girl

Read this article by Teju Cole in the New York Times Magazine which compares McCurry’s representation of India with a native photographer, Raghubir Singh who worked from the late ’60s until his untimely death in 1999, traveling all over India to create a series of powerful books about his homeland.

03onphoto3-articleLarge
Taj Mahal and train in Agra, 1983. Credit Steve McCurry
03onphoto1-master675-v3
Subhas Chandra Bose statue, Kolkata, 1987. Raghubir Singh

Reference to Coldplay’s new video also highlight the idea of cultural appropriation that harks back to Britain’s colonial rule and exploitation of the Orient.

Read this artcicle on Petapixel in In defense of Steve McCurry’s images

What is your view? Back it up with references to article read and include quotes for or against.

CASE STUDY 6:

Kevin Carter and The Bang Bang Club

Starving Child and Vulture

Kevin Carter knew the stench of death. As a member of the Bang-Bang Club, a quartet of brave photographers who chronicled apartheid-­era South Africa, he had seen more than his share of heartbreak. In 1993 he flew to Sudan to photograph the famine racking that land. Exhausted after a day of taking pictures in the village of Ayod, he headed out into the open bush. There he heard whimpering and came across an emaciated toddler who had collapsed on the way to a feeding center. As he took the child’s picture, a plump vulture landed nearby. Carter had reportedly been advised not to touch the victims because of disease, so instead of helping, he spent 20 minutes waiting in the hope that the stalking bird would open its wings. It did not. Carter scared the creature away and watched as the child continued toward the center. He then lit a cigarette, talked to God and wept. The New York Times ran the photo, and readers were eager to find out what happened to the child—and to criticize Carter for not coming to his subject’s aid. His image quickly became a wrenching case study in the debate over when photographers should intervene. Subsequent research seemed to reveal that the child did survive yet died 14 years later from malarial fever. Carter won a Pulitzer for his image, but the darkness of that bright day never lifted from him. In July 1994 he took his own life, writing, “I am haunted by the vivid memories of killings & corpses & anger & pain.”

 

 

 

 

Contextual Studies: Photography and Truth

Woman Reading a Possession Order

  • Object:

    Photograph

  • Place of origin:

    Hackney (made)

  • Date:

    1997 (made)

  • Artist/Maker:

    Hunter, Tom (photographer)

  • Materials and Techniques:

    Dye destruction print (Ilfochrome)

“Every time you saw a picture of a squatter or a traveller, it was to go with a story about how antisocial they were. I just wanted to take a picture showing the dignity of squatter life – a piece of propaganda to save my neighbourhood.”

This photograph was taken in Tom Hunter’s home street in Hackney. Residents that made up the community, including himself, were fighting eviction as squatters. The title of the series comes from the wording used in eviction orders. The postures and gestures reference Vermeer’s paintings and set out to give status and dignity to his community. Hunter captures with acute sensitivity, the zeitgeist of the 1990s and life in London at that time.

-In Johannes Vermeer Painting titled ‘Girl Reading a Letter at an Open Window’  the open window is on one level intended to represent “the woman’s longing to extend her domestic sphere” beyond the constraints of her home and society, while the fruit “is a symbol of extramarital relations.” The letter that she holds is a love letter either planning or continuing her illicit relationship. Tom Hunter re-imagines this image in current times showing a woman reading a possession order that tells her she has to leave her home.

“The balance is what I find most interesting: the friction between “is it staged or is it documentary”? I love documentary photography and I love staged photography, but I find the latter too unbelievable, as it becomes a bit too fantastical.”

Hunter uses natural lighting to hit the side of the woman’s face allowing for emphasis of her emotional state. Using a large-format camera, “which really captures that light”, he set the exposure for about a second. The ISO that Tom uses appears to be low as the image is mainly darker in tone. This is used as an advantage to give focus to where the light hits, the woman and the baby.

Creating paintings and creating photographs are two different processes. Often a painting presents what was truly seen at that moment in time but a photograph can be manipulated to show people what they want to see. Appropriation in art and art history refers to the practice of artists using pre-existing objects or images in their art with little transformation of the original.

With the picture getting noticed by the council, Tom Hunter’s community managed to save the houses.