Photography and Truth

Truth or Fiction

Photography can lie we see this constantly in online media and newspapers whether that’d be an image that has been cropped a certain way or an object that has been removed from the image completely giving the photograph a completely new meaning. As most individuals now days have access to editing software photographs have somewhat become unreliable. However, most people do still see a photo record as something reliable. When a photo is released in a newspaper or news channel people take it for granted that the photo has not been tampered with or edited in anyway. Yet when we look through the past news photos often been edited to convey a certain way, showing bias towards one point of view or dramatizing a certain event. Most of the time these little subtle changes go unnoticed however there are many cases the audience have picked up on the changes.

Photos can change the way people view certain situations and literally change the worlds decisions. A good example of this is the photo below. The photo is of the a Vietnam soldier mercilessly  executing what looks like an innocent civilian in the streets. In the this photo the man with gun is clearly portrayed as the bad guy in this situation. This photo was recorded from the violence of the Vietnam war in 1968. This photo was taken back to america for millions of people to witness. This caused peoples attitudes towards the war to change as this photo captured the graphic, raw, brutal and violent side of war. The name of the man with the gun is called General Nguyen Ngoc Loan. Nguyen Ngoc Loan was denied medical attention at an Australian hospital after being shot in the leg. He was then sent to America where there was a campaign to have him deported all due to this photo below. People didn’t want a stone cold killer in their country. For the rest of his life he was hated by anyone who recognized him. The photographer himself said

“Two people died in that photograph: the recipient of the bullet and General Nguyen Ngoc Loan. The general killed the Viet Cong; I killed the general with my camera.”

It was later discovered that the man getting shot in the photo wasn’t as innocent as people thought. The man on the right was a Vietcong officer Nguyen Van Lem who was captured at the site of a mass grave that included the bodies of at least seven police family members. This man was a killer. Yet because people only saw photographic evidence of him being killed they saw the General as the bad guy. This is a clear example of how photography can misdirect people to believe something that never happened. A photograph with no words or explanation can be as dangerous as a gun. This is the point the photographer has now released after this photo was so misunderstood. Photographer said he had a lot of sympathy for the shooter and wished he had never published the picture. The article below explains how the officer had done the correct thing yet he was persecuted for the rest of his life.

South Vietnamese Gen. Nguyen Ngoc Loan, chief of the national police, shoots Vietcong officer Nguyen Van Lem, also known as Bay Lop, on a Saigon street on Feb. 1, 1968.

Saigon execution: Murder of a Vietcong by Saigon Police Chief, 1968

This is a clear example of how photography can actually lie without there being any sort of editing. This was all due to the fact people were not exposed to the story behind the photo. However, the photo below clearly shows how editing can take place not to change the story necessarily but instead make it clear. The photo of an anti-war demonstration at Kent State University, Ohio, May 4, 1970. Four students were killed when Ohio National Guard troops fired at 600 anti-war demonstrators. As you can see the first photo hasn’t been edited and some would say that the more reliable, less bias version of the photo however, it looks like the pole is coming out of the women’s head so the photographer removed this. Personally I think this was ok as it is not change the story the photo is trying to tell it is only making it clear for the view what has happened.

To record and share an event has become so easy now day as almost every person has access to a camera and some form social media. This given everyone the opportunity to share their stories and experiences they have had around the world that main media such as the news may have not cover if it wasn’t for the amateurs using their device to record this. We see this a lot with terror attacks as often people use their camera to record the aftermath and even when its happening. This can be used as evidence and to give awareness of the brutality that may have taken place. Due to the internet and these recording devices information has never been so easy to access.

What is a Stroke?

A Stroke occurs when the blood supply to your brain is interrupted or reduced. This deprives your brain of oxygen and nutrients, causing your brain cells to die. A stroke may be caused by a blocked artery, which would be called a Ischemic stroke or the leaking or bursting of a blood vessel, which is called a hemorrhagic stroke.

You are more likely to suffer from a stroke if the individual is overweight, aged 55 or over, have a family or personal history of strokes, doesn’t often exercise, drinks alcohol heavily, smokes or uses drugs.

The main symptoms an individual will experience would be:

  • Confusion- This can be trouble communicating such as with speaking and understanding.
  • Headaches
  • Numbness or inability to more parts of the face, arm or leg, particularly on one side of their body.
  • Trouble seeing- This can be in both or one eye
  • Trouble walking- Including dizziness and a lack of co-ordination

There are also some long term problems which arise from Strokes:

  • Bladder or bowel control problems
  • Depressive moods
  • Pain in the hands and feet, getting worse with movement and changes in temperature
  • Paralysis or weakness on one side of the body
  • Trouble controlling or expressing emotions

How is a Stroke Diagnosed?

Strokes happen fast and will often occur before an individual can be seen by a doctor for a proper diagnosis.

There are several different types of diagnostic tests that doctors can use to determine which type of stroke has occurred:

  • Physical examination – a doctor will ask about the patient’s symptoms and medical history. They may check blood pressure, listen to the carotid arteries in the neck, and examine the blood vessels at the back of the eyes, all to check for indications of clotting.
  • Blood tests – a doctor may perform blood tests to find out how quickly the patient’s blood clots, the levels of particular substances (including clotting factors) in the blood, and whether or not the patient has an infection.
  • CT scan – a series of X-rays that can show hemorrhages, strokes, tumors, and other conditions within the brain.
  • MRI scan – radio waves and magnets create an image of the brain to detect damaged brain tissue.
  • Carotid ultrasound – an ultrasound scan to check the blood flow in the carotid arteries and to see if there is any plaque present.
  • Cerebral angiogram – dyes are injected into the brain’s blood vessels to make them visible under X-ray, to give a detailed view of the brain and neck blood vessels.
  • Echocardiogram – a detailed image of the heart is created to check for any sources of clots that could have traveled to the brain to cause a stroke.

Ischemic strokes and hemorrhagic strokes require different kinds of treatment.

How the two types of strokes are treated:

How is ischemic stroke treated?

Ischemic strokes are caused by arteries being blocked or narrowed, and so treatment focuses on restoring an adequate flow of blood to the brain.

Treatment can begin with drugs to break down clots and prevent others from forming. Aspirin can be given, as can an injection of a tissue plasminogen activator (TPA). TPA is very effective at dissolving clots but needs to be injected within 4.5 hours of stroke symptoms starting.

Emergency procedures include administering TPA directly into an artery in the brain or using a catheter to physically remove the clot. Recent studies have questioned the effectiveness of these methods, and so research is still ongoing as to how beneficial these procedures are.

There are other procedures that can be carried out to decrease the risk of strokes or TIAs. A carotid endarterectomy involves a surgeon opening the carotid artery and removing any plaque that might be blocking it.

Alternatively, an angioplasty involves a surgeon inflating a small balloon in a narrowed artery via catheter and then inserting a stent (a mesh tube) into the opening to prevent the artery from narrowing again.

How is hemorrhagic stroke treated?

Hemorrhagic strokes are caused by bleeding into the brain, so treatment focuses on controlling the bleeding and reducing the pressure on the brain.

Treatment can begin with drugs given to reduce the pressure in the brain, control overall blood pressure, prevent seizures and prevent sudden constrictions of blood vessels. If the patient is taking blood-thinning anti-coagulants or an anti-platelet medication like Warfarin or Clopidogrel, they can be given drugs to counter the medication’s effects or blood transfusions to make up for blood loss.

Surgery can be used to repair any problems with blood vessels that have led or could lead to hemorrhagic strokes. Surgeons can place small clamps at the base of aneurysms or fill them with detachable coils to stop blood flow and prevent rupture.

If the hemorrhage was caused by arteriovenous malformations (AVMs), surgery can also be used to remove small them if they are not too big and not too deep within the brain. AVMs are tangled connections between arteries and veins that are weaker and burst more easily than other normal blood vessels.

Rehabilitation

Strokes are life-changing events that can affect a person both physically and emotionally, temporarily or permanently. After a stroke, successful recovery will often involve specific rehabilitative activities such as:

 

  • Speech therapy – to help with problems producing or understanding speech. Practice, relaxation, and changing communication style, using gestures or different tones for example, all help.
  • Physical therapy – to help a person relearn movement and co-ordination. It is important to get out and about, even if it is difficult at first.
  • Occupational therapy – to help a person to improve their ability to carry out routine daily activities, such as bathing, cooking, dressing, eating, reading, and writing.
  • Joining a support group – to help with common mental health problems such as depression that can occur after a stroke. Many find it useful to share common experiences and exchange information.
  • Support from friends and family – to provide practical support and comfort. Letting friends and family know what can be done to help is very important.

 

Rehabilitation is an important and long part of treatment. With the right help, rehabilitation to a normal quality of life is possible, depending on the severity of the stroke.

First-time incidence of stroke occurs almost 17 million times a year worldwide; one every two seconds. There are over 1.2 million stroke survivors in the UK. 3 in 10 stroke survivors will go on to have a recurrent stroke or TIA. 1 in 8 strokes are fatal within the first 30 days

Some Statistical facts

  • There are more than 100,000 strokes in the UK each year; that is around one stroke every five minutes.
  • There are over 1.2 million stroke survivors in the UK.
  • Every two seconds, someone in the world will have a stroke.
  • Stroke is the fourth single leading cause of death in the UK and the third in Scotland.
  • There are over 400 childhood strokes a year in the UK.
  • Black people are twice as likely to have a stroke compared to
    white people.
  • Stroke is a leading cause of disability in the UK – almost two
    thirds of stroke survivors leave hospital with a disability.
  • More than 8 out of 10 people in the UK who are eligible for
    the emergency clot-busting treatment thrombolysis
    receive it.
  • Only 3 out of 10 stroke survivors who need a six month
    assessment of their health and social care needs receive one.
  • The NHS and social care costs of stroke are around £1.7 billion x2 a year in England.

All of these facts were obtained from Stroke.Org

 

My personal investigation

Specification:

My idea is to create a project about my granddad, showing how his life has changed dramatically from illness, which started from a stroke, leading to other illnesses impacting his life. He did not only change physically having his eye removed, losing control of the left side of his face, the incapability to walk and having difficulty communicating. But he also changed emotionally, his personality changing hugely, his sense of humour changed as we found he was now a more serious person than he ever was before. He often gets frustrated with himself when he can’t do tasks he once could do, such as walk long distances, driving, having a bath, read a book, fly on a plane to go on holiday and making dinner.

Now as a result of his illness, he can’t:

  • Walk far at all and when he does walk he has to use a walking stick and often gets heart pains, he use to love walking and exercising so this becomes frustrating and upsetting for him as he can’t do what he once enjoyed.
  • He can’t drive as he got his driving license taken off him as he would be incapable to drive safely on the roads, as he is only now has one eye and finds it hard to feel his feet, often they cramp up, leaving him with an extreme pain. This is hard for him to get out the house to go to various places, which stops him going out at all. He goes out once a week normally to play dominos at his local pub, he looks forward to this time of the week.
  • He now has to have a shower instead of a bath as he is unable to get into the bath and out of the bath, which makes him feel helpless and as if he can’t do anything for himself anymore. You can really see that this affects him.
  • He loved books and learning new things, he was and still is a very intelligent man. However, he now can’t read the small text in a book, so often uses a kindle, which he can change the text size or has to use a magnifying glass to make the words big enough for him to read. His reading speed is increasing getting slower, which makes it hard for him to read.
  • He also has been advised not to get on flights longer than an hour, which makes him anxious about travelling, this results in me and my family not seeing him as much as we would like as we would have to flight to see him all the time, which is hard for my parents to get time off work and flights become expensive.

My project will consist of archival images of my granddad before he was affected by the stroke, when he was the person everyone in his life before this remembered him, some of these will be adapted. It will also include documentary photographs of him performing his daily routine and I will also take images of images, which  have great significance to his routine. Some of these images may be slightly staged but they will all be of things he would usually do on a day to day basis.

The main concept of this project is how a change biologically can affect the individual mentally and physically. The project aims to show these changes.

My Mood Board: