Formal Analysis of an Image
- Composition is the way in which something is made up, its layout; whether it be art or photography or food or music; composition is its overall structure or layout. The artist who took this image is called Aaron Lee Fineman. It has clearly been set up and the man is sat in the center surrounded by, essentially, lots of other different portraits. There are a couple of leading lines which are visible including the top of the sofa and the line where the lamp and mirror meet. The body language of the man within this image is very deep and can tell a story if you let it. He is in an open position and has evidently been planned out as he is looking face-on into the camera which I really like; it’s a serious and informative, in a way, of this man’s life as he sits there. It is quite dark in colour, however, there is the beam of light that hit directly onto the old mans position. I would have thought that the layout of the images in frames was thought out carefully at the same time as trying to perceive a casual look. I really like the photograph as a whole and I want to know more about it; I’m intrigued.
- The rule of thirds is perhaps the most well-known ‘rule’ of photographic composition. It is the basis for well balanced and interesting shots.
With this grid in mind the ‘rule of thirds’ now identifies four important parts of the image that you should consider placing points of interest in as you frame your image.
Here is a photographic example of where the rule of third has been put into place; this is particularly a picture I really like.
I like this image because once again, its seems to tell a story. I want to know more about this musician. I know that if I was to put a grid like the above onto this picture that important aspects to focus on would be situated in the region of where the lines meet and his face for example would be situated in one of the boxes.
The guitar gives the image a sense of symmetry and balance because it is in the middle. If you were to split it in half, you would get a balanced symmetrical look either side. The guitar strap hook would also be on the meeting point of the lines of the grid in the rule of thirds. My eyes are drawn to that object instantly as well as the face of the man. It is again serious, making me intrigued to know the story behind the photo but as well, making me feel a little uncomfortable to look at it.
Formal Analysis of an Image
Formal Analysis of an image Composition and Rule of Thirds
FormaL Analysis of an image…composition and rule of thirds
Use C.E.L.L. to help you describe and analyse images. Be prepared to discuss…
Composition : layout, structure, depth, rule of thirds, balance, symmetry, diagonals etc
Exposure ; over exposed, under exposed, sharp, blurred etc
Light : Natural, artificial, harsh, soft, overhead, side etc
Lens : wide angle, telephoto, standard, macro, fish eye, focal length, focal point, depth of field, foreground and background etc
3 Step Analysis of a photograph (emotional response)
Dorothea Lange
My initial feeling for this image is that i am interested in it and feel connected to it. I feel emotionally connected to this image as it tells a story and . The image is dramatic and immediately stood out to me due to the contrast between light and dark. The placement of the people in the images makes it have more depth and not just be a pointless photo. The photographer has placed the woman in the center, breaking the rule of thirds, so that she is the focal point to the image drawing your eye to her.
Daniel Joseph Martinez
I didn’t have an immediate positive emotional connection to this image however i was intrigue by the image as it is an abstract photo and different to normal portraits i have come across. This image contains leading lines by he scar on the mans head and leads my eye through the image. my feelings towards this image is sad as it makes me think something bad has happened to him to need an operation. the use of colour blue also indicates a cold tone to the photograph.
Cindy Sherman
I immediately didn’t like this image because the photo looks as though it is fake and the stance the woman is doing makes me feel uncomfortable. i also do not like the clashing colours that make the image bold. i feel that the whole image doesn’t fit together and there is no story behind the photograph. The photograph is breaking the rule of thirds and is in the centre of the image to capture your eye however due to the lack of depth i am still not drawn towards this image.
3 step analysis of a photograph (emotional response)
I like this photo as it looks very artificial but for a reason. The way she is positioned and the exaggerated colors make her look almost like a doll figure. When looking at her eyes, they are glazed over and looks as if there is no life in her. I think this picture represents the materialistic things that have taken over her life like the makeup and the crown she is wearing. She is more caring for the way she looks and the things she has than the way she acts. This is the reason why the colors are so saturated. Surrounded by materialistic things she looks dead.
I do not like this photo as it almost looks like a painting or a drawing. I also dislike the position she is standing in as it looks awkward and nothing like how a child would stand. It is also too perfect for example her skirt matches the green of the leaves and the background is symmetrical. The perfectness of the photo shows that it is artificial however unlike the photo by Cindy Sherman it is artificial but I do not see the purpose. The child is not acting like a child.
This photo interests me as the man in the picture looks like some kind of war hero with his old fashioned coat, scarf, haircut and pipe in his mouth. He also looks very serious. I like the long distance blurry background as it gives you an opportunity to see the range in which the picture captures without loosing the focus of the photo (the man with the pipe). Also the man looks like he is day dreaming even though someone is quiet clearly speaking to him. Maybe he is having a flashback from serving his country.
3 Step Analysis of a photograph (emotional response)
I like this photograph because it displays a sense of power to it. For example: The man shows influence in the photograph and therefore we as the viewer should almost feel nervous in his presence. To back this up, the man has got two young men behind him who convey a protective nature over the man, therefore the man clearly has influence over these men. This puts an imposing emotion on the viewer that makes us fear this man’s presence. Also, the paintings in the background show stories of the past, showing that the man is knowledgeable but also has some level of authority over history because he can look back at history the way he wants to. Also, the fact that the man has valuable ornaments emphasizes the man’s wealth in the sense that, these possessions, no matter the value of the currency, the value of the ornaments wealth will stay the same. This emphasis of wealth and power make us feel wary and uncomfortable. This is backed up by the fact the man is staring at the lens sort of challenging us.
I don’t like this photograph nor do I like it very much either. This is because the feelings of pain and other similar emotions in my opinion aren’t particularly well expressed. This is probably because the photographer wanted to communicate the idea that the man who we can’t see his face, generally tries to hide his pain. However the fact his wound is being displayed in front of the camera shows he clearly isn’t successful at this. This makes us feel sympathetic towards this man with the fact that he is trying to hide his emotions probably because that he has no one to talk to. However because we don’t see much of his face we can’t make a judgement of who he is so it is quite difficult to feel sympathetic in that respect. Therefore I feel this photograph is confusing which is why I am not particularly enthusiastic about it.
I don’t like this photograph because it expresses negative feelings to the viewer. For example: the woman is looking away from the camera. The fact she is doing this suggests she lacks in confidence to do so and therefore is afraid of interacting with us. This makes the viewer feel somewhat guilty that we can’t do anything to help her. Also, this is emphasized further with how the 2 children are cuddling into their mother’s shoulders. Children are often associated with happiness and joy, however the fact they are turning into their mother’s shoulders suggests the hostility of the setting that they are hoping to receive some sort of comfort from their mum. However we know that the mum feels the same way as her children and so this comfort from the mum allows us to understand that it is a hollow, temporary comfort that doesn’t fix the problems. It also makes us understand how the mum longs for someone to comfort her too. Therefore this negative theme makes us feel sad, and makes us want to help but we can’t.
Week 2 AS Photography
This week you will be learning a range of new and different analytical skills, and tackling a set of practical tasks as well as completing some research about various photographers.
We will introduce you to using the blog, how to create contact sheets from your photographs and how to begin using a DSLR camera effectively…
Reminder of homework task due in for Week 3 (lesson 4)
You must take 150-200 photographs of environmental portraits
Divide this up into 2 /3 photoshoots…then create contact sheets
This must then be added as a new post to your blog,
saved and published
Title = Environmental Portraits Photoshoot (1 /2 /3)
Three step Model of Analysis
FAVOURITE PHOTO
Out of the ten photos that we were shown, my favorite one was the image of the woman with the children surrounding her. When I first saw the photo, my initial thoughts where it was extremely intriguing and I wanted to know more about it. I really like the way the photographer edited the photo into black and white. It creates an atmosphere of war and hurt. The woman’s staring into the distance which also makes the image very intriguing. It seems like there’s a story behind the image with the setting and the emotional feelings behind the photo.
WORSE PHOTO
The photo that I disliked the most out of the ten was the photo with the woman at the seaside. My initial thoughts to the image is that it may have been taken as an accident, because the woman is not positioned very well, and there are things coming into the shot that shouldn’t be there. There’s a lot of color within this image that I do like, but the whole setting and style I don’t like. It makes me feel like I don’t understand what the photographer was trying to do.
INTERESTING PHOTO
My most interesting photo was the very last one, with the guy looking down towards the floor with a large cut on the top of his head. It made me feel slightly sick with the cut, but I was also interested because i wanted to know why he had the cut, and the reasons to why the photographer was taking his photo.