Famous Transgender People | Truth

I wanted to focus in on some more famous transgender people that I knew of before researching too much into the topic. It really interests me to see how different people transition and how they are perceived and the way they present themselves to the public. I do think that it can almost be harder to transition when so many people know who you were and there is also so much pressure and stigma coming from those who don’t know much about the topic. I wanted to research this topic as it is something that I don’t know a lot about and want to find out more so that I can make accurate images. I am intrigued by this topic as for me it seems so sad that a lot of these people never go through their transition because they feel to scared or trapped based purely on fear that society will judge and ridicule them.

Caitlyn Jenner
Caitlyn Jenner has to be the most famous transgender person in the world right now. She went from being father, Bruce Jenner, of the Kardashians as well as an Olympic gold medalist for the men’s decathlon in 1976. Everyone knew who Bruce Jenner was. He was married to Kris Jenner for 24 years. Caitlyn’s transition seemed to come as a shock to everyone, including his own family. It must have been such a difficult transition as it would have been so different to any other trans person’s transition. His was televised all over the world as he is part of one of the most famous families at the moment, the Kardashians. On Keeping Up With The Kardashians we really get an insight to the struggles that the entire family are going through and how they are dealing with their father coming out and going through this transition. It really does interest me to see this and I feel that because they are so much in the public domaine that they kind of have to accept the transition as they don’t want to be seen as transphobic and I do think it’s hard to live your life constantly being followed by cameras. When Caitlyn transitioned she said she felt free and that she could be her “authentic self”. I could never imagine being trapped inside a body that you know isn’t really who you are, it seems like such a hard thing to accept and to be able to openly come out and have the strength to go through that transition. I do think that the topic of transgender people is becoming more widely known and possibly becoming more accepted within our Western society. Caitlyn has also started her own TV show entitled I am Cait, I think that this show is actually educating people on transgender and what it is to feel the way she does and how people can be their true authentic selves.

Lili Elbe
I had no idea who Lili Elbe was before late last year when I went to go see a film entitled The Danish Girl. The film really enlightened me on what transgender people go through and this was the first time I really think that I sat down and thought about it and the lives that this topic effects. The film was amazing, showing the fun aspects of Elbe’s life and how she lived. Lili was born a male, Einar Magnus Andreas Wegener, and lived alongside his wife. They were both painters and in fact he was a very well known one. At first Einar posed as a woman for his wife to finish off a painting but it turned into something more, he came to realise that he was a woman authentically. The film goes through the ups and downs of Einar’s life as a man and Lili’s life as a woman. This film was so interesting to watch and I really think that I learnt a lot from it. Without this film I would never have known about Lili at all. She was one of the first known people to undergo proper surgery to become a woman. She successfully transitioned in 1930 but later died due to complications of one of her sex reassignment surgeries. Lili’s memory lived on in Gerda [Einar’s wife] who made her fortune on paintings of Lili. This story actually makes me really emotional as it seems so rare to have a transgender case at such an early time period, 1920s-1930s, yet Gerda was so understanding and supported Lili the entire time. She must have loved her very much as she painted her.

Colonel Victor Barker
Possibly a less famous transgender person but a local one. I came across this story while working with the Jersey Archisle. This story really is amazing and almost unbelievable to actually fathom that there were many, not just one, transgender people across this island at a period as earlier at the 18th century. It really amazes me how still so many people are transphobic and don’t care to understand it. I myself do not fully understand but I am trying and am finding out more and more about this community through my research. I want to know because I want to be able to fully accept it. Victor Barker was a war veteran, he worked as a hotel clerk when he was arrested for not paying a debt he owed to a restaurant. This story truly is gripping and, in a way, it excites me that it happened in Jersey because so often I feel that not a lot happens here and that not many great people live or have ever lived here. I find this island to be very consumer driven, we seem to passively accept things most of the time but the more I look into local history the more I find that not to be the case. It is so interesting to find that Victor Barker was on the island around the same time as Claude Cahun, a photographer who challenged gender norms. When reading Colonel Barker’s Monstrous Regiment I found that Barker seemed to want to be a man because of the life men led back then compared to how women lived theirs. This has really taken my interest and made me want to research into the lives of transgender people more.

Gigi Gorgeous
Gigi is a Canadian YouTuber who has actually gone through her transition in the public domain. She has been making videos since she was male and has carried on making those videos throughout her transition. In Gigi’s videos she comes across as a very open and strong character and is full of confidence. It just shows how different it is nowadays for transgender people and, in the Western world especially, people are more open to them and more accepting. I do think it is still really difficult to be transgender in our current world and society but Gigi is just living as her authentic self regardless. I find it baffling to even think that she was ever a man. Obviously she has undergone a somewhat large amount of surgery to get to the physical stage that she is at now and it is so interesting to see how far surgery and procedures have come even from the 1930s. Gigi is always so open in her videos and lets people know about her personal life and how she feels and who she is, something that those in the 1930s for instance would never be able to do. I really do think we live in a more intelligent world where most people can accept others for who they are and although might not fully understand it they will still accept that it is that person’s choice. Gigi is also friends with Caitlyn Jenner’s daughter Kylie Jenner who, I feel, has become more open to the transgender community and showing other young people that accepting transgender people is a good thing. The age of social media really is taking over and celebrities are becoming more and more influential which is why I think Gigi is so great as she is in the public domain and does show herself for who she is.

Gigi’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/user/GregoryGORGEOUS/videos

Colonel Barker’s Monstrous Regiment | Book Research

When working with the Archisle I was given a really interesting book to have a look at and take inspiration from. This book is basically about a Colonel who came over to Jersey during the first world war after getting a bad injury. He made his way through the circles and men of Jersey, unknown to everyone else that he was actually a woman. He was arrested and imprisoned when he was found out. This is the basic information that I know but after reading the book I found out so much more and find it so interesting and unique to actually have a transgender person living in Jersey as well as Claude Cahun around the same time who challenged gender norms. The book is called Colonel Barker’s Monstrous Regiment. To me the title sounds awful as if Barker had done something so horribly unforgivable and evil that is was a ‘montrous’ thing to do as if they could be nothing much worse, when in fact all that Barker ever did was pose as a man and maybe because she felt in her self that she was a man.

colonel-victor-barkerVictor Barker

Barker was obviously treated differently as a man to when he was a woman and preferred the treatment he received as a man. 1929, Central London Barker was a reception clerk of the Regent Palace Hotel. He wore very formal clothing and constantly wore an extremely tight belt. The story goes that he would tell a long story of how he was blown up in the war and without his surgical belt he would not be able to move. He would often tell stories about his experiences during the war. Something that I found interesting too was that in 1929 there was a warrant for Barker’s arrest, he owed a lot of money after the failure of a restaurant he once owned. The book also suggests that Barker had a son who he looked after and was at boarding school. His first wife left and in 1929 he was with another woman who he took good care of and would take time off work to care for her. This is really intriguing to me as maybe as a woman Barker had a child and when he then went through the transformation [non-surgical] into a man he had to make up a back story and came up with this.

Family Background

father: Thomas Barker
mother: Lillias Adelaide Hill
The couple married in Jersey when he was thirty and she was just eighteen years old. He spent his time on gentlemanly pursuits and enjoyed playing out this role. He also put his dog into shows alongside his wife. He had a smooth-haired fox terrier while she had two bloodhounds. Lillias Adelaide Hill belonged to a family whereby a relative, Olave Baden-Powell [female], founded the Boy Scouts and the Girl Guides. The Barker’s moved to Jersey in 1889 and settled in St. Clements. Around this location in the sixteenth and seventeenth century it was the prevalence of witchcraft, were witches were tried. Thomas was the Honorary Secretary of the Jersey Dog Club. He was also club captain at the Royal Jersey Gold Club in 1898. The Barkers first born was a girl on 27 August 1895 but she wasn’t registered until 13 September 1895 due to her father being busy with the Jersey Dog Club holding its 8th Annual Show at the Vegetable Market. She was named Lillias Irma Valerie but everyone was to address her as Valerie. They had a second child, a boy, on 20 April 1899 he was named Tom Leslie. Valerie was very tomboyish and grew up enjoying reading boys books and pranks. Thomas [father] taught her the skills of fencing, cricket and boxing. Valerie attended a convent school at Graty to finally finish her schooling. She would shock the nuns by dressing up as a boy as well as smoking.  Back in the Victorian days it was not seen as feminine to aspire or want to achieve success.

Local Transgender cases

William Pallot was an islander who went to court because he would dress as a woman and walk around near Fort Regent. In the court it was declared that ‘from the eccentric manner in which he had seen him parading in the streets’ that he had no sanity and was to be taken to the asylum. He ‘dressed partially like a woman, with curled hair, powdered face, bracelets, etc. He had the voice and gait of a woman, as well as the mind of a woman.’ I find this so interesting to see how people would react to possible transgender cases and how they could not see that a gentleman would ever be trapped inside his own body or that he could quite possibly be trying to be himself with becoming a woman. Their immediate reaction is to say that he must be insane and that he must go to the asylum because no man would ever think in such a way. It amazes me that back then people would be so naive and unaware of what others may be going through. We now live in a time were we are a lot more accepting of transgender people, women and gay people [nowhere near a perfect world but a better one]. These people are so narrow minded and closed minded to the fact that quite possibly this man was born in the wrong body that he knows deep down that he is not a man but in fact a woman. I guess back then that it would be uncommon for a transgender person to be so open and free but then again it seems to me that people have been challenging gender norms more often then than say now in Jersey. Claude Cahun, Victor Barker and William Pallot all seem to know who they are and they all seem to have had this fascination with challenging gender norms and seeing what life is like as someone else or even if they adopted to the opposite sexes way of living. This book is really interesting and I am really enjoying finding out more about local history too. It is interesting to see how men were treated compared to women and how Pallot was found to be insane and that a sane man would never think is such a way. It shows how differently they treated men to women. Women were often found to be witches and were tried and killed while men were never really tried as witches and even though Pallot stated that he was reading another man’s fortune with cards he was not tried as a witch but seen merely as insane.

During the 1890’s there was a huge amount of suicides and attempted suicides. This suggests that for most people that was there only escape with there being on average two suicides a month with a population of barely 55,000. Jersey seemingly hated anyone or anything that was different and so if you did not conform to the norms of life back in the 1890s you were seen to be a witch or insane.

Edward de Lacy Evans was an Australian man who married his third wife, Julia Marquand, a Jersey girl. He would dress as a woman and when in the mines, to amuse the other residents, he would dress as a woman and sing. He suffered an accident in the mines and somehow ended up in court and was checked by doctors and the verdict came of lunacy and was certified with amentia [softening of the brain]. He was admitted to a lunacy ward where he shared a room. He would never change in front of anyone. After a six week period on this ward he was transferred to a hospital in Melbourne where he was furthered examined. It was revealed that Edward de Lacy Evans was in fact Ellen Tremaye, a woman. He was deemed to have amentia by doctors and was insane. There was no way that he could actually think in such a way as a woman. Ellen Tremaye was the anonymous author of a book entitled The History and Confession of the Man-Woman.

Louis Jobosch was a German in his late fifties. He wanted to travel over to France but was stopped and checked by a doctor who then would not allow him to travel into France. As a result he headed to Jersey where a witch hunt was going on and people were told to keep an eye on him. He was arrested as soon as he arrived at his lodgings. He was in fact a woman. The Jersey police soon learned that Jobosch had been living as a man for forty-two years. He was orphaned at the age of thirteen and then went on to travel the world working as a courier and who by then could speak several languages.  He was often head saying that he wished he was dead and had before attempted to jump into the sea but was caught by passing boat’s. He died after being taken from Jersey to a Southampton hospital where he died on pneumonia. A note was left after his death that read ‘I die of misery – trust God forgive me’. This is so sad because I think that Jabosch truly felt trapped inside the wrong body and that dressing up as a man wasn’t enough and that throughout Jabosch’s whole life he could never come to terms with himself or make peace with his own demons. He asked for forgiveness from God as though he had done something terribly wrong, this is really sad to read as it makes me think about all those that feel trapped and encaged in their own bodies that the body that they inhabit isn’t actually their own and that they don’t belong.

Truth | A Possible Specification

For the past couple of weeks I have been working alongside the Archisle and finding out more information about Jersey history. I have more specifically been shown how feminism exists within the islands history. At first I was just looking at this from personal interest as it is something that I have always felt passionate about and am always keen to find out more and broaden my knowledge on the ever growing topic of feminism. Something I never thought about was local feminism or even how local men and women were treated decades and centuries ago. I wanted to learn about the women of Jersey in the earlier periods of the 1920s and how they present themselves and how women were portrayed. The archive really helped with this as they have an vast amount of portraits taken by a local photographer of the elites of Jersey back in the earlier period of photography. I found this to be so interesting and really brought some inspiration to mind. The other week, when down at the Archive, I visited the library and was shown around by Anna. She was showing me around and introduced me to many different books and magazines from Jersey history and opened up the prospect of looking into the idea of how many women were tried as witches compared to the amount of men. Jersey was always a hugely superstitious island and there were many witch hunts that went on here. I think I want to find out more and possibly focus some work on this topic as it really does interest me. One book that Anna actually let me borrow was one entitled Colonel Barker’s Monstrous Regiment. This book is something I think I would be able to base some work off of the idea of truth. This book tells the story of a young woman who posed as a man for many years of her life and worked in a hotel for years and lived alongside men with a strong presence. She was never found out until she was arrested for owing money to a restaurant that was in debt. I find this story to be so extraordinary and am amazed that someone, who was possibly transgender, that interesting lived on this island. I am currently reading the book and am learning about so many different cases linked to the island of transgender people and what it meant and what it was like to be transgender in those days. I think that I could really get into this project and find out more about it, even though it will be quite difficult to get a handle on as I am an outsider looking in. This will be a challenge but I want to at least attempt it and see if it works out. I have other ideas to fall back on so it isn’t too much of a big deal if it doesn’t work out. I think that in recent years transgender has really become a topic of interest for a lot of people with more and more people, such as Caitlyn Jenner, feeling comfortable with coming out and showing who they truly are. I think that I will research more into this and see how it could work out.

What Am I Doing?

At the start of this course I had planned out that I was going to do a project based on the environment and involve surrealism into this. I find this topic so interesting and would be really fun to carry out. However, I’ve now got other ideas in my head which I am leaning more towards as they seem to be interesting me more. I think that I am going to carry on with all three of my different ideas and once done some further experimentation I will narrow it down and finally choose my favourite topic to focus in on and work on that. Other ideas involve gender and the generic conventions of how we are expected to me. More specifically I have been looking into the transgender community and what it is like to actually be transgender. I am also looking more into witchcraft and how superstitious the people of Jersey were when witchcraft was a big thing.  I really want to explore all of these ideas but feel that there isn’t much time to do so and I really need to finalise my key ideas and actually go out and do some experimentation with those ideas in mind.

Screen Shot 2016-04-11 at 18.30.41

Questions of Truth, Fantasy or Fiction?

For those of you still haven’t considered the fundamental questions raised in this exam paper between Truth, Fantasy or Fiction, please select one or more of these 4 case-studies and produce an in-depth blog post that illustrates your thinking.

1. In the recent terrorist attacks in Brussels Fox News was reporting from the Place de la Borse. Video footage shows a young photographer posing a woman in front of a makeshift memorial: is it bad journalism ethics, or just the way it’s done?

Read the Guardian newspaper article here and make a blog post that expresses your own thoughts and views.

Further insight can be read here on Petapixel

Here is the image that photographer, Khaled Al Sabbah posted on Instagram

Untitled-1

 

2. Another image from the Brussels attack has also generated a lot of chatter on social media.

A photograph of a woman in shock with torn clothes and injured foot has gone around the world.

Read a few articles here.

Time Magazine

The Guardian

USA Today

Following the second explosion, Kardava  (the woman who took the image on her phone) fought her urge to run to a safe place. “I also wanted to take pictures. As a journalist, it was my duty to take these photos and show the world what was going on. I knew I was the only one at this spot.”

In this photo provided by Georgian Public Broadcaster and photographed by Ketevan Kardava two women wounded in Brussels Airport in Brussels, Belgium, after explosions were heard Tuesday, March 22, 2016. A developing situation left at least one person and possibly more dead in explosions that ripped through the departure hall at Brussels airport Tuesday, police said. All flights were canceled, arriving planes were being diverted and Belgium's terror alert level was raised to maximum, officials said. (Ketevan Kardava/ Georgian Public Broadcaster via AP)
In this photo provided by Georgian Public Broadcaster and photographed by Ketevan Kardava two women wounded in Brussels Airport in Brussels, Belgium, after explosions were heard Tuesday, March 22, 2016. A developing situation left at least one person and possibly more dead in explosions that ripped through the departure hall at Brussels airport Tuesday, police said. All flights were canceled, arriving planes were being diverted and Belgium’s terror alert level was raised to maximum, officials said. (Ketevan Kardava/ Georgian Public Broadcaster via AP)

Is there a moral dilemma in photographing people injured or dying? As photojournalist should you take the image?

What is your view? How has this image become iconic of the terrorist attacks in Brussels airport?

3. Jeff Wall, Canadian artists known for his large scale tableaux image presented in light-boxes

installation-d-web

Today, most of his images resemble reportage and, as such, are likely to incense his detractors, who claim he’s not a “true” photographer. His most contentious new work, called Approach, shows a homeless woman standing by a makeshift cardboard shelter in which we spy the foot of what could be a sleeping vagrant. Wall tells me it was shot under an actual freeway where the homeless congregate and that “it took a month to make, working hands-on” – but he won’t divulge just how staged it is. Is this an actual homeless woman, or an actor? Is the shelter real, or was it built by Wall’s team of assistants to resemble one?

3506

Re-creating images from memory is crucial to Wall’s practice – perhaps because it flies in the face of the tradition of photography as an act of instant witnessing.

“Something lingers in me until I have to remake it from memory to capture why it fascinates me,” he says. “Not photographing gives me imaginative freedom that is crucial to the making of art. That, in fact, is what art is about – the freedom to do what we want.”

Read full interview with Jeff Wall here

In terms of truth or communicating an idea that make references to a real social problem such as homelessness, does it matter if the image is staged or not? Where does authenticity come into the picture?

4. The images of renowned photographer Steve McCurry, who made the famous and iconic image of an Afghan girl for a front cover of National Geography has recently been criticized for making ‘too perfect pictures’ which not only are boring but reinforces a particular idea or stereotype of the exotic other.

afghan-girl

Read this article by Teju Cole in the New York Times Magazine which compares McCurry’s representation of India with a native photographer, Raghubir Singh who worked from the late ’60s until his untimely death in 1999, traveling all over India to create a series of powerful books about his homeland.

03onphoto3-articleLarge
Taj Mahal and train in Agra, 1983. Credit Steve McCurry
03onphoto1-master675-v3
Subhas Chandra Bose statue, Kolkata, 1987. Raghubir Singh

Reference to Coldplay’s new video also highlight the idea of cultural appropriation that harks back to Britain’s colonial rule and exploitation of the Orient.

Read this artcicle on Petapixel in In defense of Steve McCurry’s images

What is your view? Back it up with references to article read and include quotes for or against.