recap/key theorists for newspapers

Antonio Gramsci (Hegemony)-

Refers to the dominantly shared system of values, ideas, and ethics of a society or community during a particular historical period. The definition of hegemony is leadership or dominance off one group over another. An example of hegemony would be the government power over its citizens. a hegemonic struggle is the presentation of people going against and challenging the dominant ideologies and social norms placed in.

Jurgen Habermas (public sphere)-

 The public sphere is the concept of a social space where people would meet and discuss social problems in for example a coffee shop, and through that would influenced political action .

James Curran & Jean Seaton (theory of liberal free press)

Curran and Seaton elaborate and further explain the theory by Habermas on the topic of the “Free Press” and how the press should not be influenced or heavily dominated by large companies enforcing opinions and views on daily news. by doing this is manipulates the viewers to seeing a certain side of a story when the news should be a unbiased platform to inform our community.

Noam Chompsky (5 filters that manufacture consent)-

The theory explains five general classes of “filters” that determine the type of news that is presented in media. These five classes are: ownership, advertising, the media elite, flak, and the common enemy or “fear ideology”.

Ownership-Mass media firms are big corporations. Often, they are part of even bigger conglomerates. Their end game? Profit. And so it’s in their interests to push for whatever guarantees that profit. Naturally, critical journalism must take second place to the needs and interests of the corporation.

Advertising-Media costs a lot more than consumers will ever pay. So who fills the gap? Advertisers. And what are the advertisers paying for? Audiences. And so it isn’t so much that the media are selling you a product — their output. They are also selling advertisers a product — YOU.”

The Media Elite- The establishment manages the media through the third filter. Journalism cannot be a check on power because the very system encourages complicity. Governments, corporations, big institutions know how to play the media game. They know how to influence the news narrative. They feed media scoops, official accounts, interviews with the ‘experts’. They make themselves crucial to the process of journalism. So, those in power and those who report on them are in bed with each other.

Flak-If you want to challenge power, you’ll be pushed to the margins. When the media – journalists, whistleblowers, sources – stray away from the consensus, they get ‘flak’. This is the fourth filter. When the story is inconvenient for the powers that be, you’ll see the flak machine in action discrediting sources, trashing stories and diverting the conversation.

The Common Enemy Or “Fear Ideology”– To manufacture consent, you need an enemy — a target. That common enemy is the fifth filter. Communism. Terrorists. Immigrants. A common enemy, a bogeyman to fear, helps corral public opinion.

Louis Althusser ( interpellation and ISA)

Ideological state apparatus are the social things around us i.e the media, school, family, friends ans state and they shape us into what we are today and conform us using their values. They interpellate us into what they expect us to be using the ISA.

newspaper theorists

Louis Althusser:

Louis Althusser looked at Ideological state apparatus (ISA) which refer to the structures filled with ideological ideas and beliefs that are connected to States and dominant interests and idea. ISA’s are complied with as they constantly reinforced and viewed by the mass as what is ‘right’, ‘normal’ and ‘expected’.  IDA’s includes the theory behind how atrocities such as Slavery and Genocide are allowed to happen as they are ideas formed by the ruling classes to trap everyone into set beliefs and actions. He also theorised about Interpellation and haling which are the way in which identity is formed by the way that you are perceived by others and in turn see yourself due to the reinforcement of these ideas.

Habermass:

Habermass came up with the theory of the free press whereby the stated that the media/the press should be free from interference and bias, ownership and political control. He argued that the free should be made by the people for the people and deliver factual and unbiased accounts.

Curran and Seaton:

Curran and Seaton further developed the idea of Habermass that the media/press should be free from interference and bias, ownership, political control. They also stated that the patterns of ownership and control are the most significant factors in how the media operate. They recognised the dangers and issues associated with this such as domination and control of the mass by only filtering dominate ideals and biased assumptions through the media mainstream.

Noam Chomsky:

Chomsky devised the theory of manufacturing consent and the five filters in which it is obtained. Manufacturing consent is theory behind the way in which dominate powers corruptly control and artificially gain consent from the masses through the media. This is obtained through Chomsky’s five point filters, Financial ownership (Monopolistic companies, striving for profit and financial control aim to obtain this through any means) Advertising news (advertising paying media companies to attain audiences and cover cost of media production) Media Elite (the role and influence mass co-operations have within journalism) Flack and Anti-Communism. Financial ownership: Monopolistic c

Antonio Gramsci – the concept of hegemony / hegemonic struggle

CSP 12 – NEWSPAPERS

  1. Jurgen Habermas (Public Sphere)=a theory by Habermas where people can come together to freely discuss problems and give their opinions within society. A public space includes places, such as a coffee shop.

2. James Curran and Jean Seaton = concept of the Free Market, where media are free to publish what they want, without restrictions and interference from the Government and political control. The information that is published by the press is free to use in the public domain and is open to anyone to access this information.

3. Noam Chomsky = Manufacturing consent, there are 5 filters towards manufacturing consent.

Resensi Buku] Manufacturing Consent - Noam Chomsky
Hate Speech Defends NZ PM's Alliances

4. Louis Althusser = Interpolation and Ideological State Apparatus, ISAs describe the way in which society is structured, such as education, the arts and religion have a purpose to structure ideological perspectives within society, which then will form our own individual identity. He also noted that people believe they are “outside ideology” and that “interpolation” is a way to recognise the way that ideology is formed.

5. Antonio Gramsci = Hegemony/hegemonic struggle, hegemony is a struggle which emerges from negotiation and consent. Hegemony outlines how certain ideas can be more influential then others. Hegemony is the type of power between the working classes and the higher classes, with an example being Trump’s election.

Gramsci in Lebanon: Analyzing the Powerful('s) Ideology - New Politics

Curran and Seaton

Curran:

– “The freedom to publish in the free market ensures that the press reflects a wide range of opinions and interests in society”

– “Newspapers and magazines must respond to the concerns of their readers if they are to stay in business”

– “The press is the people’s watchdog, scrutinising the actions of the government and holding the country’s rulers to account.”

– “The assumption that ‘anyone’ is free to start as new paper has been an illusion ever since the industrialization of the press.”

– “The advent of the internet has enhanced the freedom to publish by lowering entry costs. [..] It is possible to set up small websites, the equivalent of small corner shops, but this is not the same thing as publishing well-resourced news websites, the equivalent of supermarkets, in which a large number of people visit.”

Seaton:

– “Public service regulation has secured the survival of a successful broadcasting industry, one which has become more significant economically and which has become an important exporter of programmes, while continuing to discuss and mold national issues”

– “Broadcasting in Britain, monopoly or duopoly, always depended on an assumption or commitment to an undivided public good”

– “The concept of broadcasting has always been of a service, comprehensive in character, with a duty of public corporation of bringing public awareness to a whole range of activity and expressed developed in society”

– “One cause of the collapse of the principle of public service broadcasting has been the deterioration in the relationship between the state and broadcasting institutions.”

– “Broadcasting is a process which cannot be entirely understood from its products. few would claim that the whole nature of the industrial enterprise can be understood from the shop floor of one factory. Neither can all the pressures which condition broadcasting institutions can be revealed by an examination of what Tracey has called ‘the world of determination of a television programme’.”

The 3 Types of Media Ownership

Media as a commodity vs Media as a public good

Transnational Media Corporations and the Impact of Globalisation

– Globalisation is when businesses/companies expand from their home country to international countries and begin to offer their services internationally and in countries outside of their home country.

– Transnational media corporations have subsidiaries in other countries outside of their home country.

5 theorists

Habermas- the creation of the public sphere an area for the people safe from the government the idea of making connections with each over rather underneath the control of the government, safe haven to discuss them.

Curran- The media needs a form of regulation or they can post whatever they want and it won’t matter if it’s real or not so we have a filter what media goes through also known as “flack” so the government could stop negative information against them to never be published for the public as well as watchdogs who are mainly anonymous people who keep an eye out for the public to ensure there is no corrupt people or media. FREE PRESS should be free from interference/ ownership/political control

Chomsky– the five filters of consent is the process that the media goes through to control and manipulate the public. Advertising, common enemy, flacking,

Critical Frameworks for Contemporary Culture : Herman & Chomsky - Courtney  Sparling
Films For Action on Twitter: "Watch '5 Filters of the Mass Media Machine'  here: https://t.co/1yHr3EqlnC… "

Louis Althussar – argues that “there is no ideology except by the subject and for the subject” and that ‘All ideology hails or interpellates concrete individuals as concrete subjects, through the functioning of the category of the subject’. So Ideological state apparatus is a theoretical concept which is used to describe the way in which structures of civic society (education, culture, the arts, the family, religion etc) keeps people in their place – ‘the ruling ideology, which is the ideology of ‘the ruling class’.

Antonio Gramsci – Hegemony is a tug of war for power, and that the balance of power can be changed, how certain cultural forms predominate over others, which means that certain ideas are more influential than other. Post colonialism articulates a desire to reclaim, re-write and re-establish cultural identity and thus maintain power of The Empire.

CSP 12 Newspapers

DAILY MAIL & THE i (AS CSP)

In order to develop this knowledge and understanding, you should consider one complete print edition of the newspaper chosen by your teacher and selected key pages from the newspaper’s website, including the homepage and at least one other page

CONNECT NEWSPAPERS CSP TO 2020 US PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION

KEY DATE: US PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION TUESDAY 3rd NOVEMBER. A simple guide to the election can be found here

So most likely to use the editions on Wednesday 4th (provisional planning at present)

PRESIDENTIAL DEBATES: Sep 29, Oct 15 & Oct 22

https://www.channel4.com/programmes/trumps-coronavirus-catastrophe/on-demand/71430-001

The Right to Vote

  • Who has the right to vote?
  • Should everybody have the right to vote?
  • Does everybody have the right to vote?
  • Has everybody always had the right to vote?
  • How to enable / disable the right to vote?
  • How does that help: candidates, the electoral process, democracy?
  • What should be the role of the media in covering an election in terms of voting rights?

THE ELECTORAL COLLEGE A SYSTEM THAT HIGHLIGHTS KEY STATES NEEDED FOR PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION

Current data on US Election polling & Interactive ‘Who will win the election‘ a good link that gives data on US elections

Intro . . . re-cap some key thinkers:

TASK 1: Write a paragraph on the following (post on your blog) – use your own words and avoid copying big chunks of text from either the internet or from someone else in the class

  1. Jurgen Habermas and the concept of the Public Sphere
  2. James Curran & Jean Seaton – the theory of the liberal free press
  3. Noam Chomsky – the 5 filters that manufacture consent
  4. Louis Althusserinterpellation & Ideological State Appraratus
  5. Antonio Gramsci – the concept of hegemony / hegemonic struggle

TASK 2: SKIM READ THE FOLLOWING 2 ARTICLES AND TAKE OUT 5 QUOTES FROM BOTH AUTHORS THAT HELP YOU TO UNDERSTAND: 1) THE THEORY OF THE LIBERAL FREE PRESS & 2) THE ROLE OF PUBLIC SERVICE BROADCASTING

THREE TYPES OF MEDIA OWNERSHIP

Fuchs, C ‘Reading Marx in the Information Age’ Routledge 2016

MEDIA AS A COMMODITY v MEDIA AS A PUBLIC GOOD

Fuchs, C ‘Reading Marx in the Information Age’ Routledge 2016

TRANSNATIONAL MEDIA CORPORATIONS: THE IMPACT OF GLOBALISATION

Fuchs, C ‘Reading Marx in the Information Age’ Routledge 2016

Intro . . . watch some episodes of Press

https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b0bk9c89/press-series-1-2-pure

PostModernism Terms

Pastiche – a work of art or other visual project that imitates the style or character of the work of another artist.

Parody – a jokey version of something usually used to imitate or make fun of an original work.

Bricolage – the construction of different texts which forms one new text.

Intertextuality – the shaping of a text’s meaning by another text

Metanarrative – a narrative about narratives of historical meaning, experience or knowledge.

Hyperreality – the inability to distinguish reality from a simulation of reality. Often seen in the media eg in TV when the reality being portrayed is not real.

Simulacrum – something that replaces reality with its representation.

Consumerist Society – a society in which people devote lots of time, energy and thought to ‘consuming’. The general view is that consumption is good and the more there is the better.

Fragmentary Identities – the idea that you can have different identities online and in real life.

Implosion

Cultural Appropriation – the idea of taking aspects of one culture into another. eg. art, rituals, behaviour, music, style.

Reflexivity – the examination of one’s own beliefs. Thinking about your own thoughts.

Postcolonialism Terms

Colonialism – the act of taking over another country politically, either fully or partially.

Post Colonialism – the study of the human consequences from the control of people and their land following being colonised.

Diaspora – a scattered population living in somewhere other than their place of origin. eg. the dispersion of Jews from Israel involuntarily.

BAME – Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic (all ethnic groups except White groups).

Double Consciousness (Gilroy) – the internal conflict that a person feels living in a country that their ancestors are not from because of colonisation (African American). The conflict that people feel of not knowing which ethnicity they belong to.

Cultural Absolutism – the declaration of a societies culture to be of supreme ethical value.

Cultural Syncretism – when ideas from 2 or more cultures blend together to create a new custom.

Orientalism (Said) – style, artefacts or traits that are considered a characteristic of a certain place. eg. Asia is stereotyped in a way that is regarded as embodying a colonialist attitude.

Appropriation – the adoption of element of one culture by members of another culture.

Cultural Hegemony – the domination of a culturally diverse society by the ruling class who manipulate the culture of that society.

The Public Sphere (Habermas) – a virtual or imaginary community who basically mould peoples views and interests through the use of the media.

The Role of Public Service – the public reporting on events used to shape our cultures and define our national identities.

Broadcasting in terms of fair representation of minority groups/ interests – non-biased news that simply reports on news and tries to not take a specific viewpoint. eg. The I.