Comparative films

i will be comparing these films based on how the serial killer genre has changed between 1968 and 2007


The zodiac was released in 2007 and was directed by David Fincher, it is a crime/mystery film

Image result for The Boston Strangler 1968
The Boston strangler was released in 1968 and directed by Richard Fleischer

similarities:

both based on true events

The Boston Strangler is the name given to the murderer or murderers of 13 women in the Boston, Massachusetts area during the early 1960s. 

The Zodiac Killer is the pseudonym of an unidentified serial killer who operated in Northern California from at least the late 1960s to the early 1970s.

Guillermo del Toro “all the formal elements become quasi-hypnotic. It puts you in a trance-like state that makes everything operate at a deeper level”

DENNIS LIM reporter for the LA times
“It’s a paean to obsession, a dream match of subject and filmmaker”

Cultural context – Alien

Alien was released in 1979, a time period where second wave feminism was in full force after the introduction during the early-mid 1960’s. This influenced the types of characters being made and produced in films, because there was a greater need for stronger female characters. Script writer Dan O’Bannon focused on writing a diverse range of characters to really resonate with the audience. As a result, the characters included in Alien were older than the typical characters included in a horror film and there was also a gender mix. Since most of the characters get killed off fairly early on within the film, keeping Ripley as the sole survivor although she is a female, was a bold move to represent a strong female character. But this was needed drastically at the time to prove that the second wave feminism was moving in the right direction, so the character of Ripley represents the necessity of strong women for the movement of second wave feminism.

Second wave feminism developed the interpretation of a female character in horror films. The movement showed the implied inferiority of women to men, and the unfair systems implemented. In horror film, women were typically portrayed as ‘damsels in distress’ and usually saved by men. An example of this prior to the second wave feminism movement is the character Lila Crane from Psycho (1960, by Alfred Hitchcock) who relies on Sam Loomis to save her. But second wave feminism argued to change this, and during the late 1960’s there was a resurgence of new, strong and empowered female characters. ‘Alien’ was produced towards the end of the movement, which had resulted in the introduction of many new strong female characters. Over the period of the movement, there became a development of female characters from victims to survivors, which led to Clover defining the term ‘final girl’.

Although there are several examples of ‘final girls’ evident in horror during the early 1970’s, many of these lack actual development from survivors to heroines and although there was a resurgence of female empowerment; they typically just make it to the end without facing off with their antagonist. An example of this is Sally Hardesty from ‘The Texas Chainsaw Massacre’ (1974, by Tobe Hooper). Although she is cited as one of the earliest examples of a ‘final girl’ and displays some qualities: she does not avenge against Leather face or the family and is eventually rescued at the end of the film, by a man.

Ultimately, second wave feminism inspired a new wave of strong female characters. There was a slow but visible decline in overly-sexualized female characters, and a growth in female protagonist who began to survive towards the end of the film. However, there was still an emphasis on survival. This represented women still as victims, who barely clung on to their lives and were typically rescued by men (see Hardesty and Strode) instead of taking revenge on their pursuers. Arguably, Ripley is one of the earliest examples of a strong ‘final girl’, she outlives her (mainly male) crew by fighting to survive and finally defeats the alien alone with no assistance from anyone. The development of ‘final girls’ were slow, but stemmed from the second wave feminism movement, many showed strong qualities during the early 1970’s but Alien is one of the first horrors which actually shows a strong heroine who does not rely on anyone aside from herself to survive but also defeat the alien.

The particularly later half of the 1970’s was a major decade for film, most specifically horror and sci-fi. From horror we got: ‘Halloween’ (1978, by John Carpenter) and ‘Black Christmas’ (by Bob Clark, also 1974). All of these films utilized the final girl trope, and were a major success. They all showed a strong female character at the forefront of each plot, not only surviving but battling against the antagonist; usually male. These films were also influenced by second wave feminism, which showed the immediate impact that the movement had on filmmakers and the horror industry has a whole because it led to the creation of strong female protagonists rather than just helpless victims. Similarly, science fiction was enjoying a major run at arguably the top of the film industry perhaps due to the massive success of ‘Star Wars’ (1977, by George Lucas). The influence of such success in both genres from the hybrid would have a profound impact on Alien as there was a large target audience for Alien who would’ve been willing to see the film based on the other successful horror and sci-fi films released at the same time.

Final project Director screenplay draft

Bold Text is the action the criminal is doing while doing the monologue.

Fade to black

Criminal

Remember a time when you were so innocent, no one could see who you really were. I can tell you I never learnt or felt that one particular feeling, from day 1 my path was always to a life of crime. You can always try and be better but it never feels right. Black Screen for entire part of this speech.

EXT. PATH. DAY

Criminal

At age of 15 I was already out my 2nd visit to juvy for petty pickpocketing, Walking down a road in prison uniform and a bag. and that wasn’t the worst thing I did at that age,

EXT. CAR PARK . DAY

Criminal

I vandalized, stole cars, robbed, and even started working for a local car salesman to vandalise vehicles Scratching a logo into the car, also doing transferring jobs if you know what I mean. Putting a package into the bin being cautious. Did I feel guilty? No. Why would I, it was good pay, this made me feel alive. Counting the money in his hand.

INT. LIVING ROOM .DAY

Criminal

Yeah there is danger to this life. Yet if you learn early enough and you are good at it why stop, what am I doing wrong at the end of the day? Anyone caught in my cross fire deserves it. They deserve it by the way they speak of me, look at me or come at me. At the end of the day I get reputation as the more I do brings me more respect and power than having some sort of dead ass job. I am hated by the uncaring higher class yet they didn’t realise what I would become one day. One day they would be asking me for favours, or to corrupt systems, or certain assignments what could send me down for multiple life sentences. Shows beer bottles, money ash trays in dark room with their feet up on the table.

INT. CARPARK. NIGHT

Criminal

To them I Satan, just happened they were in my hell and being tortured and controlled by me, it was great I was a King with power, followers, money, but I could never change, I was going down a darker path I refused to turn back. When people talk about origin stories they are usually tragic or heroic mine is neither, I am what I have always been, a cold blooded son of a bitch. Is chasing someone with a gun

Running person

Tell Kurt Gilligan I didn’t co-operate with the Balts Group…please.( Very scared) then shoots it.

INT. ROOM. DAY

Criminal

If you want to hear everything you’re going to have to listen from the fucking beginning. (This part sounds like it’s a recording). A person in a suit looking at them self in the mirror. 

Female Officer

We’ve got him!

Sound Design 2

Sound Designers for sci-fi, Predator sound designer, Charles. L Campbell (E.T). These sound designers are the inspiration for this scene as they are able to combine common earthly sounds with unusual, unheard of sounds to create a sci-fi experience.

Sound designer action, Mark Mangini (Mad Max), Dane Davis (The Matrix). These sound designers have inspired me to use common action film sounds but at a quick pace and at a slow pace as that allows to build a more entertaining scene overall compared to having a scene with normal sound effects.

David Fincher lighting

David fincher is in my opinion the master of lighting in the film industry, He carries the same techniques and styles through all of his films no matter what the genre is. Most of his films are quite dark for example: Se7en, Zodiac and Gone Girl. In all of these films he uses dark lighting in a lot of the scenes as shown bellow. But he uses this dark style even in his happier films such as The social Network.


Gone girl
Drama/Mystery

The Zodiac
Mystery/Crime

Se7en
Drama/Mystery

Social network
Drama/History

Fight club
Drama/Action

Auteur Theory Directors

Sergio Leone, the motifs of Leone is how he uses a very similar cast with his own style. In the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly he uses many of his many characteristics in film. This is seen by the:

  • Opening titles what are always the same what he uses to add his own artistic style at the beginning.
  • The main principle actors are made up of a 11 people who play different roles in the dollar trilogy.
  • The Mexican standoff by itself is a trademark of Leone.
  • The shots of the eyes to signify conflict and tension is a clear style choice by Leone as well.

James Cameron is a hard one to decide if he is a auteur or not as he doesn’t stay with one genre or has clear film style. However there are stick out things what can lead to you considering him as auteur:

  • His way of balancing multiple protagonists in a movie.
  • How he handles females as the main hero and are the ones who are usually made to be both strong and compelling.
  • He casts actors he’s worked with before occasionally.
  • He is able to make nonhuman people feel real and give them emotion.
  • His biggest detail of him being an auteur is how ambitious and incredible is his cinematography is in movies.

Cinematography 2

Horror Film cinematographers, Neal Frederick’s (Blair Witch Project), Pablo Rosso (REC 2). These 2 cinematographers are going to be the cinematographers I am going to be inspired by as both shoot in first person and have been behind the most classic POV horror films. Rosso’s switch between first person and security cameras will be definitely the main inspiration of the whole scene though in general as it shows different types of cinematography.

Sport Film cinematographers, James Crabe ( Rocky), Maryse Alberti (Creed), Vittario Starrio (Apocalypse Now). Crabe and Alberti’s styles will be the main inspiration from the shots as they are able to show ambition and ability of a person through camera shots. Starrio’s scene from Apocalyse Now, on the boat will also be inspiration as I want to show enjoyment in the character.

What I am aiming with these 2 scenes is to have them both being able to show a complete contrast. What I mean by that is the both style and movement of the camera as in the Horror scene it will itself contrast from switching between a still and moving camera what may be presented as a messy style while on the other hand the sports film will be clean and continuously moving with many different shots what will present a cleaner style.

The significance of genre

Both films are similar in that they put a spin on the concept of ‘genre’ with combining around three different genres as a whole. The concept was accurately coined a ‘hybrid-genre’ (also known as cross-genre) where multiple elements from a genre are combined to create a new style of a film. ‘Black comedy’ was introduced into the arts by surrealist André Breton in 1935 who actually coined the term in his 1940 book ‘Anthologie de l’humour noirafter’, wrote after he acknowledged the merging of comedic and dark elements in particularly the work of poet Jonathan Swift. Within film, the first strong example comes from director Billy Wilder, with the 1940 academy award hit ‘Sunset Boulevard’ which utilized elements from comedy but also had quite a dark tone.

As film revolutionized, ‘Black Comedy’ became more popular, with around 88 films being produced after 2010 compared with only 20 in the 1980’s. this shows the growth in popularity of the genre mix because many people are wanting to see it onscreen. ‘Happy Death Day’ successfully employs elements from this hybrid by maintaining a dark and somber tone usually seen in horror films with the killer stalking Tree but also the nature of some of the killings. But this is juxtaposed with a lighter mood, with constant jokes and ridiculous moments. The film takes inspiration from ‘Scream’ (1996, by Wes Craven) to combine comedy and a dark mood to create a contemporary, successful black comedy

Whereas, arguably sci-fi horror is a much larger and more popular area. There is debate over whether or not the genre combination is actually a hybrid, due to the similarities in genre it can be difficult to actually define whether or not a film is a sci fi or horror because many science fiction films can unintentionally create fear and horror can typically rely on science for justification. So as a result, many films can be referred to as ‘sci fi – horrors’ although some can only contain minimal elements of either genre. The hybrid genre can be seen as early as 1918, with Michael Curtiz and Edward Fritz’ Hungarian sci fi-horror ‘Alraune’. Although there is not much actually known about the film since it is now lost, it is believed to be about a mad scientist creating a demonic child which perfectly unites common tropes and elements from both the sci-fi and horror genres.

Arguably, Alien can be considered a science fiction film from afar, in general terms. It involves the discovery of extraterrestrial life then the struggle for survival. The film does employ horror tactics however, with the alien itself scaring some viewers with its grotesque look but also the infamous scene where the alien rips its way out of Kane’s chest. Although the film contains elements of horror to engage the audience through fear, the main premise is science fiction which defines Alien as a sci-fi horror, with some elements of a thriller from the intense action. The success of Alien inspired many sci fi horrors, most notably ‘Predator’ (1987, by John McTiernan). The film was similar to Alien in the way that it blurred the line between horror and sci fi, creating a hit which showcased the successes of both genres.

Ultimately, both films can be classed as horror hybrids because they mainly utilize strong elements of a horror to scare but also engage the audience with the plot and the characters. HDD also uses comedy to add a lighter tone, and also adds a refreshing spin on the ‘slasher genre’with the idea of Tree’s killer hunting her down until she can break the time loop by figuring out who is behind the mask. There is also an element of sci-fi with the film because the time loop plot, but this is focused more on in the sequel ‘Happy Death Day 2U’, whereas the original focuses mainly on a slasher horror, with a general comedic tone. On the other hand, Alien centers around a sci-fi heavy plot, but the film was released at a time where horror was arguably much bigger and more widely received than it is now in contemporary cinema so as a result: the film employed scare tactics to reach the large horror fanbase. Even today, Alien is constantly referenced as a horror masterpiece, regardless of the inital sci-fi plot

Feminist film theory

The development of film theory was influenced initially from second wave feminism, and women’s studies in the 1960’s/70’s. A main aspect of the theory is generally based around how women were being sexualised throughout the mid 1960’s particularly through the era of second wave feminism. However, theorists such as Clover argue that women are not always the victims because they are typically the only survivor and face an intense showdown with the rival throughout the film. These characters succeed due to their own skills and instincts rather than being saved by a male character

However, it can also be considered that these characters are on the gender borderline with many having ‘masculine names’ (such as Ripley and Laurie Strode). Also, when successfully defeating the male antagonist, they do so by taking up a weapon such as a knife or chainsaw to finally defeat the killer or entity. The idea of a typically male dominated audience of the horror genre, identifying with a female protagonist raises many questions about the relationship between feminism and the horror (particularly slasher) genre.

Inspiration – Happy death day

Happy death day was only released in 2017, a modern take on the slasher genre, which (like Alien) subverts the concept of genres by utilizing most of the major elements from several genres itself of sticking with the conforms of the a slasher. Released at a time where strong female protagonists are the norm, this is one of the most strongest example of a contemporary ‘final girl’. However, script writer Lobdell plays around with the ‘final girl’ trope, creating a refreshing new twist since our protagonist ‘Tree’ is essentially a mean girl who we only begin to understand and invest in as the film progresses. As the concept of a ‘final girl’ has evolved over time, the expectations and traits of these females have developed too, for example the ‘final girl’ Erin from the 2011 horror hit ‘You’re Next’ (directed by Adam Wingard) is another example of a strong and powerful ‘final girl’ who is ruthless when opposing the killers.

The time-loop concept of the film was based around the infamous ‘Groundhog Day’ (by Harold Ramis, 1993) and the film even gets a reference towards the end, with the characters acknowledging that the situation ‘was like the movie groundhog day’. Also, the character development and growth throughout the film is another significant element director Landon took inspiration from. This juxtaposes nicely against the ‘final girl’ trope, because we end up rooting for ‘Tree’ and investing in her because we can appreciate and understand her character growth throughout the film.

Although there is some confusion over the genre, the film is widely and generally classed as a ‘slasher-horror’, which is simply from the concept of Tree getting repeatedly killed and having to work out who is killing her and why, as well as obliviously stopping them from doing so. Director Landon cites ‘Scream’ (by Wes Craven, 1996) as one of the main influences because it combines comedy and horror extremely well, with similar techniques being employed in HDD. The mask itself is also by Scream, with it being created by Tony Gardner who had also created the ‘Ghostface’ mask