Collaborative Film Project, comparative essay Section A: Task Components (research & analysis), comparative essay Section B: Compare and Contrast (examples and info)(research & analysis), comparative essay Section C: Assembly (info about assembly), Film Reel: Final Film role show reel, Film Role 1 (pages / portfolio), Film Role 2 (pages / portfolio), Film Role 3 (pages / portfolio), Short Film Production
Category Archives: comparative essay Section A: Task Components (research & analysis)
Filters
Where I am now
Points
•Propps characters, anti heroes
Man with No Name=Sarah Connor, the hero
Tuco= T-800(Arnold Schwarzenegger), the helper
Angel Eyes=T-1000, the villain
Gold=John Connor, the dispatcher, the prize
General Clinton=Miles Bennet Dyson, The donor
Bounty Hunters/Law=Dr Peter Silberman, False heroes
•Film Structure
•Where they become similar, auteur theory, directors ideas in story
•Western to a Western Sci-fi
•Where Cameron innovates and evolves from Leone’s structure
The Standoff
The Good, The Bad, And the Ugly movie references
The trauma of the hero: 1 hour exact
The messenger: 1 hour, 10 minutes
The villain: 10 minutes
The Helper: 20 minutes
The hero: 29 minutes
The prize: 2 hours 50 minutes
The donor: 2 hours 12 minutes
The False heroes: 21 minutes
Quotes for Comparative
“dominated by repetition, but they are also marked fundamentally by difference, variation, and change.”
– Steve Neale, Film and Theory: An Anthology, 2000, p165
“The relationship between the individual text and the series of texts formative of a genre presents itself as a process of the continual founding and altering of horizons. The new text evokes for the reader (or listener) the horizon of expectations and “rules of the game” familiar to him from earlier texts, which as such can then be varied, extended, corrected, but also transformed, crossed out, or simply reproduced.”
– Hans Robert Jauss, Towards an Aesthetic, 1978, p79
comparative essay plan
- intro to zodiac (director, Year ext)
- into to Boston strangler (director, Year ext)
- plot of each film
- context (what was happening at the time)
- hays code Boston strangler
- compare murder scenes
Improved Comparative Script
Comparative clips
Deckard is introduced to Rachael by Tyrell
Deckard is confronted by Captain Bryant
This scene shows that Deckard is a tool for the people in power – he is being forced into a situation that he doesn’t want to be involved with because Bryant implicitly threatened him if he did not cooperate and kill the replicants.
Rachael and Deckard love scene
The District attorney interrogates spade
https://www.youtube.com › watch
This scene shows how Spade is hostile to authority and it shows that the people in power are detrimental to Spade’s investigation by trying to get in his way. This is similar to the way that Bryant threatens Deckard in Blade Runner
Information Sources for Comparative Study
Wikepedia
IMDB
Chris Jones Filmmaker Blog
Raiders of the Lost Ark and New Hope Films
YouTube – MovieClips Channel
Vogler’s Hero’s Journey
Background:
Christopher Vogler is a Hollywood development executive as well as a screenwriter, author and educator. He is best known for his work in Disney as well as being responsible for highlighting the Hero’s journey in his 7 page memo called “A Practical Guide to The Hero with a Thousand Faces. The Hero’s Journey describes the typical adventure of a Hero in fiction. The journey as a whole has 12 stages that details the Hero’s development as a character throughout the narrative.
The Stages:
- The Ordinary World – This is when the hero is introduced sympathetically so the audience can relate to them. There is usually something causing the hero stress.
- The Call to Adventure – Something shakes up the hero’s life and their life begins to change from that point onwards.
- Refusal of the Call – The hero briefly turns away the adventure, either because they are afraid of what lies ahead or because of their duties in their own life.
- Meeting with the Mentor – The hero meets someone who will guide them on their adventure. Alternatively, the hero can find courage within themselves.
- Crossing the Threshold – This is when the hero fully commits to leaving their old life behind and starting their adventure.
- Tests, Allies and Enemies – The hero is tested and seeks out allies during the adventure.
- Approach – The hero and their allies prepare for the major challenge during the narrative.
- The Ordeal – At this point in the story, the hero suffers an ordeal that consists of either facing their greatest fear or losing a loved one or a part of themselves. The hero’s life is forever changed from this point onwards.
- The Reward – The hero takes possession of the ‘treasure’ won by facing their ordeal. There is still a risk of losing the treasure again, however.
- The Road Back – At this point, the adventure is nearly over and the hero is driven to complete it. There is often a chase sequence that signals the urgency of the situation.
- The Resurrection – Usually the climax of the adventure. The hero is tested once more and this is followed by another moment of death and rebirth that will once again alter the hero’s personality and life from this point onwards.
- The hero returns to either their home or a new home after the journey, permanently transformed by the events that transpired.
There are also many archetypes that are present throughout the journey. These are basically characters that represent a specific role throughout the narrative.
The Archetypes:
- Heroes – Main characters in stories, often the characters that the narrative is focused around.
- Shadows – Villains of the story. Could be actual physical antagonists or could just be an internal struggle within the hero.
- Mentors – The hero’s guide.
- Herald – The one who brings the call to adventure to the hero, could often be the mentor or an event that transpires.
- Threshold Guardians – Characters, events or internal struggles that stop the hero from crossing the threshold.
- Shapeshifters – Essentially refers to how the audience’s perception of a character can change as they develop throughout the narrative.
- Tricksters – Mischief makers, could even be the hero’s mischievous subconscious that forces them to change.
- Allies – Characters who help the hero throughout the adventure. Some may cause the hero to change or some may even change with the hero.