Smeraldina essay feedback

General points:

  • Don’t ‘bolt’ all your historical and social knowledge on to the Introduction. It delays getting you into the main part of the essay which is HOW you’d act.
  • Get to the acting quicker BUT do set up the context (2 sentences max.) Why is Smeraldina there in the scene?
  • Make the acting ideas creative and specific – steal if you have to but be assertive and bold. “I will…”
  • Try and get some historic/social facts into the paragraph ONLY IF THEY ANSWER THE QUESTION

SAMPLE INTRO – generic and then specific:

In Carlo Goldoni’s Commedia inspired 1745 play, ‘A Servant to 2 Masters (So2M), Smeraldina has a more prominent role than in earlier traditional Commedia scenarios. She is still based on the stock-type ‘servetta’ and she still has a commentator’s role bridging the gap between characters and audience, but she has been given her own romantic plot line with the other main servant Truffaldino.  She is outspoken and bold in the face of male authority but equally shy and endearing to the audience when seeking a suitable marriage partner. It is these character traits that I would exploit in my performance to create comedy for the audience.

1st Paragraph (showing HOW I would do this)

WHAT: A moment with comic potential is in Act 2 Scene 5 just after Smeraldina has saved her mistress Clarice from trying to commit suicide. She turns on Silvio; the hot-headed son of Dr Lombardi and Clarice’s fiancé, and delivers an amazingly energetic rant about the status of women in society and the inequality of the sexes, “The only reason we get the stick is because we don’t have a dick.” Her parting shot to Silvio is, “They (women) wouldn’t give you a second glance, ‘big boy’.” HOW: As Smeraldina, I’d use a sarcastic tone of voice and emphasise the words ‘big boy’ whilst dropping my pitch to imitate a male voice. I’d change my body language to that of a hulking, stiff alpha-male flexing his muscles in order to poke fun at Silvio and get a laugh from the audience. WHY: This would also be bold and spirited thing to do as Silvio is socially more superior, but as I’m playing Smeraldina as a 30 something woman with worldly experience and Silvio is just out of his teens, the audience will enjoy and hopefully find it funny that I am putting him back in his place through verbal and physical parody.

NEXT PARA:

Discuss something funny from the same moment – perhaps some of the sword business.

Next 2 PARAS:

Go to a new section: The Courtship of Truffaldino and Smeraldina Act 2 Scene 14: It’s a long scene so ask yourself the Question ‘WHAT’S THE FUNNIEST MOMENT’ AND JUMP TO THAT.

WHAT: Later in the play (Act 2 Scene 14) when Smeraldina and Truffaldino are having their awkward courtship, there is physical comedy that can be brought out from the moment that both admit they they can’t read.







Smeraldina essay

As a performer playing Smeraldina, discuss the performance methods you would employ in order to create comedy for your audience in at least 2 sections of the play. Make specific reference to social and/or historic contexts in the play (Servant of 2 Masters) in your answer.

Introduction

What generic (general) information do you need?

What specific information? (a good place to get in some of your social / historic information, BUT don’t let it turn into a History of Commedia essay!)

Use the notes I gave you and the Commentary about Smeraldina.

2 moments that are comic – what would you choose?

Plan it! (10 mins) Be prepared to SHARE

WHAT: Know the point to your paragraphs

HOW: Know what examples / moments / quotes

WHY is it FUNNY

WHO IS SMERALDINA?

We will explore Smeraldina ahead of acting out some key scenes next lesson.

Read and add to your notes about Smeraldina:

  • List the scenes she is most prominent in. (plot summary)
  • Commentaries (read the paragraph section about her character.)
    • Add to your notes
  • Form your own opinions /imagine your own virtual performance
What’s WRONG with the picture at the top?
Where does Smeraldina appear and what does she do.?

Act 1

  • Scene 1 – S. she listens to others, comments to audience, answers door (establishes her role, attitude)
  • Scene 2 – S.meets Truff, plays it cool, reveals she might be interest
  • Scene 12 – Announces arrival of Federigo to Clarice

Act 2

  • Scene 5 – Stops Clarice from from killing herself, turns on Silvio and has speech about ‘position of women in society’
  • Scene 13 – Outside Brighella’s inn – running a message, chatted up by waiter, she dismisses him
  • Scene 14 – Flirtation with Truff.
  • Scene 15 – Trying to read a letter with Truff- shows she illiterate

Act 3

  • Scene 12 – Encourages Clarice to make up with Silvio
  • Scene 14 – S. says she’d like to get married, though she has no one in  mind.
  • Scene 15 – S. ask Clarice for permission to ask Beatrice to release Truff. so that he can marry her. Finally Truff asks S. to marry him.
Commentary notes:

Stock type: female servant (servetta) Sometimes known as Columbine. Did not wear a mask. Costume: apron, dress, low cut blouse

Goldoni ‘interested’ and ‘promoted’ this part! WHY?

Didi Hopkins says she has aspects of the 4 mains Masks: She’s good with money (Pantoloon) She is able to engage in an academic debate about men /women/ injustice and society (Doctore) She is playful (Harlequin) and cunning (Brighella)

Personality: outspoken, sharp, perceptive (sees the world as it is), observant, wants to be married, motherly(?) towards Clarice (female mentor?)

Knows her place but doesn’t like it

Not afraid to speak her mind (even in front of her boss – Pantaloon

Video: Servant of Two Masters: Commedia Character Shorts-Lesson Six: Smeraldina

Watch clip from 0:40 in

Macbeth – live theatre – costume question

Write down this question into your Live Theatre Journals

Briefly explain the effects created by a non-naturalistic approach to costume design at particular moments. Analyse and evaluate how this contributed to the total dramatic effectiveness of the production by referring to two or three specific designs.

[25 marks]

Here is what you are expected to do: Read thoroughly.

In your opening paragraph of any Live Theatre questions you need to establish these things + engage briefly with the question set.

Name of company and play / playwright / genre
The media you saw it on/in
The Director and number of actors
The type of production and the space
The style of performance – Brechtian
The theme being focused on
The concept of the production (Bouffons) – why

Sample introduction (Mr Jones)

IntroductionWe watched a digital performance of the Shakespearen tragedy ‘Macbeth’ performed by Splendid Productions, adapted and directed by Kerry Frampton. The production was designed for a schools’ tour with 3 actors, no lighting and minimal use of props and set. It had many Brechtian elements like multi-roling, use of song and placards and a knowing sense of theatricality. Frampton’s overall concept, taken from Macbeth’s line “It’s a tale told by an idiot…” was to tell the story using 3 Bouffons. These bouffons: “People who believe in NOTHING and make fun of EVERYTHING” – Jacques Lecoq   engaged with the audience in a very direct way.  
5 lines 

You need to engage briefly with the question (consider this an over view of what you will focus on in the Main Body of your essay.)

Introduction Cont…As with the other non-naturalistic elements of this touring production, the costume designs were simple, inventive and allowed for swift changes of character. They were non-naturalistic in terms of colour scheme, shape and had symbolic elements to effectively help the audience understand themes like kingship and when actors were playing Shakespeare’s characters and when Bouffons.

The main body of your essay needs to be built up with a number of paragraphs that follow a Point, Evidence, Explain structure and follow the Question’s command words of Analyse and Evaluate.

Sample 1st paragraph (always useful to start with 1st impressions)
The first impression the audience have of a non-naturalistic approach to costume are of a chorus of grotesque Bouffons standing with placards stating, ‘Leaders wanted’. Bouffons traditionally were misshapen, deformed figures living on the edges of society and the costume’s shape acknowledges this with exaggerated shoulders pads, elbow patches and misshapen headwear. The costumes are as misshapen as they can be given that the actors are not exclusively ‘bouffons’ throughout the play. The headwear is created from various items of baby clothing. One Bouffon has a stuffed baby grow on his head (Insert diagram) This is a reference to the innocent children killed in wars and also a comment on the idea that the Macbeth’s are childless.
Coupled with this, is the make-up design which has the actor’s faces in smudged white foundation with dark sunken dark eye sockets. This effectively makes the actors seem ghoulish and other worldly making them convincing as the Unknowns (as the Witches are known in this version). There is also comic and clown connotations with the white face and supports the director’s concept that this is a story ‘told by… idiot(s) ‘ who exist outside the Shakespearean world. Director Kerry Frampton indicates in her production notes that the Unknowns are meant to be ‘otherworldly’. They link heaven and earth. The all-white costumes indicate purity and the mud, blood spatters and rips (usually in the lower part of the costumes) is a result of the Bouffons walking the earth and being sullied and made dirty.
[This LINKS back to the Bouffon paragraph which already makes reference to deformity]
The convention (rule) created in the first few scenes is that when the Bouffons remove their headwear they ‘take on the role’ of the various Shakespearean characters. As well as creating a silhouette that is misshapen and deformed, the addition of pads and wires under the costumes, especially the shoulder area, makes the Shakespearan characters seem powerful and masculine. Even Lady Macbeth has this feature to her costume. It bulks out her outline rather like an American football shirt. This enhances her power and is effective and appropriate as she is often more masculine than Macbeth – she is the one who suggests the murder of Duncan and strengthens Macbeth’s resolve when he is weakening. The Bouffons say “If she were born a man, would she be king already?’


What other areas are there to talk about?

The Red sash
The kilt like skirts
The bag


What Band and mark would you give this?

Checklist

 TaskDue byHow to submit
Complete costume pages (A3) for Macbeth, Lady Macbeth and a Bouffon [must be annotated with 3 ‘layers’ of NOTESWednesday 4th DecemberOn the A3 sheets
Servant – comprehension type questions (50 marks available – ASSESSEDFriday 29th NovemberIn your Journal or on a word doc and printed.
Work on Clarice and Emotional Journey – on the BlogFriday 6th DecemberIn your Journal or on a word doc and printed.

THE LOVERS -MAKING COMEDY FROM THE SERIOUS

Discussion:

What is this word – why is it relevant to COMEDY.

Watch this film clip

1st impressions:

  1. Is it a funny scene?
  2. If so, who is it funny for – Silvio & Clarice or the Audience?
  3. What generates the comedy? (types of comedy – slap stick, language, exaggeration, role-reversal – acting against type?)
  4. Why is Silvio acting like this *(look at what happened in the scene before.)
  5. What is Smeraldina’s attitude to what she discovers?
  6. How does she behave?
  7. What quotes are memorable?
  8. Why is this RADICAL for the 18th century?

TUESDAY SET WORK Clarice – how does she develop?

Do this in your Journal for ‘Servant of 2 Masters’

What is a character arc? What is an emotional journey? (Are they the same? THINK /PAIR /SHARE

Consider Clarice in all 3 Acts (how does she develop)

Skim read the plot summary and identify ALL the scenes that Clarice is in. Then create a table

What happens in the sceneHow does Clarice come across to the audience
Act 1 Scene 1

Clarice is being engaged to |Silvio – she does not grieve at losing Federigo as her true love has always been Silvio.
She is over the moon in love. Excessive “my heart would always be yours” – She wants to go somewhere private with Silvio – she’s like a giddy teenager. Daddy’s girl!
Continue for the rest of the play

Create an ’emotional journey for Clarice –

She starts off displaying XXXX then moves into displaying YYYY (that sort of thing)

Make sure you get into Act 2 and Act 3

Discussion: Create one – two sentences that explain your ‘director’s concept’ for Clarice. You want the audience to see WHAT over the course of the play?

UNDERSTANDING ‘SO2M’

COVER LESSON – WORK ON YOUR OWN IN THE LRC

This is to test your knowledge of basic plot events, character knowledge and motivations in the first 2 Acts of the play “A Servant of 2 Masters” (So2M)

YOU SHOULD HAVE READ THE WHOLE PLAY A NUMBER OF TIMES BY NOW. I

IF YOU HAVE ANY TIME LEFT IN THIS LESSON YOU MUST READ ACT 3 WHICH WE DIDN’T DO IN CLASS

All the answers are in the play – you may also find the plot summary of the Commentaries useful.

TO BE DONE IN YOUR JOURNAL FOR NEXT LESSON – answers to INCLUDE the KEY WORDS of the question

Comprehension Questions for Acts 1 & 2 of ‘Servant of 2 Masters’. (Questions)

 QuestionAnswerMark
1What are the 3 stock types of Commedia?   3
2Traditionally which characters would have worn a mask 2
3Name 2 character types that are not in the play? (You need to watch one of the early videos on the Blog about characters) 2
4Where is the play set – (city)   1
5What is a lazzi?   2
6Who wrote the play?   1
7When did they write it (to within the nearest decade)   1
8What are the names of the 2 older men?   2
9What are the names of their children?   2
10Beatrice comes from which city?   1
11Who is her brother?   1
12What has happened to him before the play begins? Who did this?   2
13Who was he meant to marry and why?         2
14Beatrice arrives at Pantaloon’s house disguised as whom?         1
15Who recognises her and why?       2
16Who is her servant?   1
17Who is his love interest throughout the play? 1
18What 2 things does Beatrice hope to get by arriving in Venice?       2
19Why does Truffaldino sign up with another master?     1
20Who is the ‘character’ Truffaldino. makes up? 1
21Why does he ‘invent’ this person?   1
22Name 2 objects that are the types of things that confuse Truffaldino now that he serves 2 masters?       2
23Towards the end of Act 1 what does Beatrice do when in the company of a distressed Clarice?       2
24Why is Silvio angry with Pantaloon and Beatrice/Federigo?         1
25When discovering Silvio with a sword what does Beatrice/Ferderigo do?         1
26What does Clarice threaten to do when confronted by Silvio’s jealousy?         1
27What city is Truffaldino from?     1
28How do we (the audience) know that Truffaldino can’t read?           2
29Why does Truffaldino get a double beating at the end of the Act 2?           2

30) Explain in a paragraph how you would play the role of Pantaloon (focus on personality, voice, posture, body shape, rhythm, facial expression)         6 marks available

Total marks = 50             

Essay feedback – after Truffaldino essay

TASK 1

  • Look at the structure of the mark scheme for this part of the exam.
  • Identify what the General progression is up the Bands
  • Identify what the SPECIFIC bullet points that you (the candidate have to make)
  • PAIR TALK what your understanding of this is (the language can be quite hard to decipher at first)
  • Look at your essay again (1 week later)
  • What Band would you give it (where does MOST of the essay fit)
  • Now, give it a NUMERICAL MARK out of 25 based on your analysis and the Notes I have provided.
  • Look at the Mark Scheme I have given you to see if your analysis of your essay corresponds to mine.
  • Stick in the BLANK Mark sheet into your So2M Journal.

How to improve (some general points)

POSITIVES: Most of you understood and got in some historic facts about|:

  • Harlequin being the original / traditional name.
  • The characters being a servant and lover (with the better answers indicating that the lover role was 1) made larger and 2) was more romantic than just ‘lust’ because Sacchi was the ‘star’ and had paid for the ‘commission’
  • Most of you mentioned Sacchi but BE CAREFUL that you don’t rob yourself of time for the detailed focus on ‘performance’ that the essay is all about.
  • YOU ARE NOT WRITING A HISTORY OF THE PLAY type essay – it must be an essay about HOW WOULD YOU PERFORM TRUFFALDINO.
  • All of you wrote about being the PERFORMER (no one missed the target)

NEGATIVES:

  • Write more! I gave you a detailed plan – you should have written for 45 mins {but actually you had 30-35 mins}. At 7-10 mins a paragraph that’s 4.5 paragraphs = 2 to 2.5 side of A4
  • You must talk in specifics: Establish the moment clearly. Who, where, when and why: {Zoom in from a Long shot to a Close Up) “ When I enter Pantaloon’s room to announce my Master is down stairs, I will…”
  • You MUST imagine you are playing the role. “If I was playing the part…(?) You are playing the part!!! E.g. “As Truff. I will… {Use the PRESENT tense as if you are acting as you write}
  • You need to state ‘the effects’ you wish to create. I gave you a list of 6
  • Some of you MUST re-read your words/sentences because what you’re writing is NOT GOOD ENGLISH.
  • Try and develop a writing style that is simple but specific. Every line you write should specifically refer back to the question or illustrate your answer in some clear way.
  • Don’t say ‘over the top’  – say exaggerated or heightened …
  • Get in more than 1 acting skill per example: If you are saying something about vocal delivery then go on to add what your face is doing, add a gesture or move you make, say what your body language is doing, how close or far away you are from other characters or the audience. (Try for 4 acting terms – the Mark scheme say you must use subject specific terminology)
  • Be more creative – don’t just say what the script says (add value!) E.g. The letter re-sealing lazzo. To say you’ll do it 3 times is just repeating what’s in the script. To say you strangle yourself in your attempt not to swallow or you tie string to the bread as a ‘clever’ precaution is CREATIVE – even if the idea came from someone else. Pass it off confidently as yours!

Letters and Lazzos

Recreate the Letter Lazzo in pairs.

One actor reads the words and the other comes up with comic business. Try and use the script as a blue print but feel free to improvise lines or physical business. Swap over when done.

Watch this and see what ‘invention’ this actor brought to the lazzo. You will get credit for ‘creative additions’ [value added] As there is virtually no stage directions MOST of the physicality in this play is up for you to decide upon.

Other moments:

What voice? (Explore the monologue Truffaldino has on P16

Explore P26 – How does Truffaldino’s voice and physicality change depending on whether he is talking to a Master or the Audience.

What can we deduce about his relationship with the audience?